Constructive Pneumatological Hermeneutics in Pentecostal Christianity

(Barry) #1
other form of mediation. In other words, we cannot escape the vicious

circle/s of mediation.

It is here that I need to mention the role that testimony plays in the

context of Pentecostal spirituality because it is the means by which media-

tion is communicated, even if it is rarely communicated in fi rst-order terms

as mediation. Pentecostals are constantly giving witness to what God is

doing in their lives. This witness varies according to the traditions that

shape the telling of the story and the expressions that are supported and

encouraged in different contexts and cultures of Pentecostalism. The nar-

rative of testimony allows the person witnessing to bring their experiences

into resonance with the Scriptures in order to demonstrate to the audience

that experience of the Holy Spirit is in continuity with the early church

and its profound experience in its constitution and mission. Elsewhere,

I have discussed the role of testimony in terms of epistemology, that is,

how knowledge of the Holy Spirit is mediated via the spirituality narra-

tives of Pentecostals. 13 Testimony has a coordinating function that brings

together other sources of knowledge (perception, memory, introspection

and reason) and expresses them in a narrative shape. However, it needs to

be acknowledged that empirical research cannot go behind the testimony.

It can only do what forensic enquiry does, namely to investigate whether

it is coherent with what is known from other sources. Where no other

evidence is present, then the coherence of the narrative depends on the

assumptions of those discerning the evidence of the testimony.

The descriptions we have in Scripture are mediated through the agents,

writers and redactors, however inspired and authoritative they may be.

Equally, our experiences of the Holy Spirit are mediated in all sorts of

ways. Therefore, what we are researching when we include the Holy Spirit,

is the person and work of the Spirit as mediated via Pentecostals in the tes-

timonies to these experiences, in their narratives about what is going on,

via the symbols that are important artifacts and events of such mediation

as well the patterned action, the praxis of the communities, which are

imbued with beliefs and values. 14 A theological reading of this mediation

seeks to understand the theology of the Pentecostals not as something to

be explained in other terms, namely, sociology or anthropology, however

valuable these perspectives may be, but to be explained by means of the-

ology. To read something theologically, one needs to put on theological

spectacles, which leads me to the question of hermeneutics. I am con-

cerned not just with the hermeneutics of written texts, which remain criti-

cal of course, but also with the hermeneutics of theology expressed in

LOCATING THE SPIRIT IN MEANINGFUL EXPERIENCE: EMPIRICAL THEOLOGY... 259
Free download pdf