LECTURE 2. GROMOV-WITTEN INVARIANTS 243
combination of the structural constants
L (a1 o a2, ¢ 0 )r/"^13 (¢13, a 3 o a 4 ) ,
o:,/3
where ~ 'T/o:/3 ¢ 0 0 ¢13 is the coordinate expression for the Poincare-dual of the
diagonal 6. C X x X in terms of a basis { ¢ 0 } in H* ( X) and the intersection matrix
('T/^0 /3) inverse to ('T/o:/3) := ( (¢0:, ¢13) ).
The associativity property can be explained as follows. Consider the GW-
invariant A(a1, a2, a 3, a4)d which counts the number of degree d spheres with the
configuration (0, 1, oo, ,) of marked points mapped to the given 4 cycles. It is
obviously symmetric in (1, 2, 3, 4) and does not depend on -\. Now let the cross-
ratio ,\ approach one of the exceptional values 0, 1 or oo. In t he limit the same
GW-invariarit receives another interpretation: it counts the number of pairs of
maps f', f" : CP^1 ---+ X of degrees d' + d" = d such that f' ( oo) = f" ( oo) and
f'(O), f'(l), f"(O), f"(l) belong to the given 4 cycles. Which pair of the cycles
constrains f' and which - f" depends however on the special value of the cross-
ratio ,. Rewriting t he diagonal constraint f' ( oo) = f" ( oo) in X x X in terms of
¢ 0 0 ¢13 and summing contributions of various degrees with the weights qd we arrive
at the identity between the above quadratic expression of the structural constants
and the GW-invariant
L qd A(a1, a2, a 3, a4)d
d
symmetric under permutations.
Exercise. (a) Formulate the above argument in terms the contraction map ct :
X 4 ,d ---+ Mo, 4 and the evaluation map ev3 x ev~ : X3,d' x X3,d" and prove the
associativity of the quantum cup-product for a homogeneous Kahler space.
(b) Apply the same argument to the contraction maps ct: Xk,d---+ Mo,k with
k > 4 in order to show that the GW-invariant ~dqd A(a 1 , ... ,ak)d counting the
number of maps CP^1 ---+ X sending 1, ... , k to a1, ... , ak can be expressed in terms
of multiple products in QH* (X) as (a 1 , a2 o a 3 o ... oak).
( c) Degenerate a genus g Riemann surface ~ to the curve of geometrical genus
0 with g self-intersections, and express the virtua l number of holomorphic maps
~---+ X in terms of the quantum cup-product.
The associativity identity and the above interpretation of multiple products in
QH*(X) are examples of universal relations between CW-invariants referred some-
times as composition laws or Witten-Dijkgraaf-Verlinde-Verlinde equations. An-
other universal identity reads:
[) [)
qi~(a,p 1 ob)= q 1 ~(a,pi ob)
uqi uqj
where (p 1 , ... ,pr) in an integer basis in H^2 (X) dual to the basis in H2(X,Z) which
we use for labeling the degrees d by ( d1' ... ' dr). Due to qi[Jqd I aqi = diqd' it follows
from the divisor equation
(a,pi,b)d = di(a ,b)d
which simply means that a degree d sphere has intersection index di with a codi-
mension 2 cycle Poincare-dual to Pi ·