SOME TIME in 1984 the fashion photographer
Deborah Turbeville made the long journey from New York to
San Miguel de Allende a former Spanish colonial town some
300km north of Mexico City. She was flying down to take a closer
look at a house she had glimpsed after a fashion shoot amid the
townâs Baroque architecture and which might now be for sale.
In Rome she had just photographed Cy Twombly and the col-
ours of the painterâs house led her to consider creating her own.
As a photographer Turbeville would invariably place her
models in a mise en scène of derelict buildings. Then she would
distress the results to further remove them from any precise time
or place relocating them in a world of her own imagining. This
crumbling house in a town with history might allow her to do the
same and she acquired it on the spot. âIt was like some ugly child
of mineâ she said later âthat I coaxed into line to make beautiful.â
âIt was horrible like a suburban house complete with avocado-
coloured refrigeratorâ recalled her close friend Barbara Peters. âBut
the bones were there; it had perhaps been an old staging post
maybe 200 years old. It had so much potential...â Turbeville fo-
cused on the half-ruined balcony; on the Moorish arches and pil-
lars along the patio; and on the faded frescoes of biblical scenes.
Two imposing doors led from the street into a covered reception
area and then into a courtyard. It was an L-shaped house with a liv-
ing room a large kitchen and a walk outside to the main bedroom.
There were four further bedrooms and a room for the âhelpâ.
Upstairs one small bedroom faced the courtyard; behind it a lar-
ger room was used as a studio. The history of the house was unfath-
omable so Turbeville christened her new home Casa No Name.
âIn factâ she wrote years later âit was a small casa that carried
on inside like a village.â At the back next to the staircase that led
to the roof a bougainvillea tree climbed the wall like a giant un-
furling umbrella. Its village-y feel was down in no small part to
her own design for living. âThe atmosphere was usually placidâ
says Petersâbut then out of nowhere it would be punctuated by
blaring music so that it felt like an opera house. Deborah created
her own world and lived completely within it.â
She filled the house with birdcages statues wood carvings
plaster saints wickerwork broken dolls crucifixes and tin can-
dlesticks. It took her two years to renovate though the friend over-
seeing told the builders not to make too perfect a job of it for âThe
señora likes it that way.â It was in fact as much a deconstruction
as a restoration. âI wanted a return to a beautiful ruinâ explained
Turbeville âa rehearsal for something that would never take place.â
The faded splendour of the nearby Hacienda Jaral de Berrio (WoI
Aug 2009) was an immediate source of inspiration.
Atmosphere was fundamental to Turbeville. It marked out her
photographs like nothing else. She told one interviewer from Vogue
that she enjoyed not belonging âto any place or group and the same
thing could be applied to my personal life. And itâs true of time too.
I donât want to belong completely to the present. There are things
I love about the past. Atmosphere â I crave it the way some people
crave food or sex.â This reached a photographic apogee in Unseen
Versailles (1981) a book of spectral behind-the-scenes vignettes
of Louis XIVâs pleasure-dome and Deborah Turbevilleâs Newport
Remembered (1994) in which the Gilded Age mansions of Rhode
Island are revealed in all their desiccated grandeur.
Born into Bostonian wealth Turbeville had been briefly a
model then an assistant (and house model) to sportswear de-
signer Claire McCardell which she followed with stints as a styl-
ist and editor at Harpersâ Bazaar and Mademoiselle. After attending
a workshop led by Richard Avedon she realised that making
fashion photographs was her destiny. Not the bright sporty
happy outdoorsy ones that were then in demand but dark
brooding and painterly ones which were not.
Though she was all but self-taught Turbevilleâs career would
last 35 years. At Vogue she made an impact with a set of pictures
that remain her most famous and a landmark of 20th-century
fashion photography. âDo something remarkable dear. Iâm ex-
pecting it!â admonished Alexander Liberman the magazineâs edi-
torial director one day in 1975. In a dimly lit turn-of-the-century
bathhouse on 23rd Street she did just that. Five models posed
languidly across the gloomy tiled walls in an eerie subaqueous
light. âI always quiet everyone down during a sitting and there was
not even a breathâ explained Turbeville. âAnd everyone got really
tense and was moving in this synchronised way... They moved
like puppets. And when it was over there was dead silence.â
Though not when Vogue came out. There were howls of protest.
Pale and unsmiling the women looked disengaged if not trapped.
Fashion editor Polly Mellen recalled: âThe [pictures] shocked every-
one. You canât imagine what people saw in them â everything from
prisoners in a gas chamber to addicts in a shooting gallery.â
Turbevilleâs life was nomadic and although she had close
friends she was by many accounts self-contained. She was used to
shuttling back and forth between the fashion capitals of New York
Milan Paris and London. An apartment in the Beaux-Arts land-
mark the Ansonia on New Yorkâs Upper West Side was as near to
home as she would allow but here she kept the colours muted and
the curtains drawn. âShe didnât like New York light unlike the light
of Mexicoâ says Barbara Peters. âShe lived for her aesthetics. I told
her if she didnât get a comfortable chair Iâd never come back.â
Casa No Name seldom made a good location for her fashion
work; perhaps because the long journey to Mexico from wherev-
er she had been working was itself an exhausting creative pro-
cess; perhaps because at last Deborah Turbeville as mercurial
and unknowable as her photographs had finally come home $