C4 EZ RE THE WASHINGTON POST.MONDAY, OCTOBER 21 , 2019
Inevitably,
Alberto is
drawn into
the imagi-
nary world
created by
his grandfa-
ther. But,
like many of
the stories in
the collec-
tion, the ulti-
mate reveal is less important
than the discoveries made along
the way. In Alberto’s case, it’s the
process of understanding the
strange gift that has been be-
stowed upon him by his grandfa-
ther.
Another cog in the corporate
wheel occupies the central role
in the short story titled “Snow
Globe.” Also named Alberto, he is
an encyclopedia salesman who
lives in a fugue-like state, fretting
that he will “fritter away the
future” while lost in feelings of
apathy.
He yearns for change but goes
to bed each night “terrified at the
prospect that this world was
immutable.”
This Alberto yearns for human
contact. He wants to connect
deeply with another person, and
he finds little of that in the
company of his lover Cristina, his
emotionally distant father and
his workplace colleagues. Bur-
dened by malaise, he finds him-
self gazing one night into the
idealized universe of a snow
globe that contains a quaint little
village.
By chance he stumbles into an
elderly woman who mistakes
him for her dead son. The affec-
tion she shows him satisfies his
deep need for connection, and
his presence sates her need to
erase her greatest loss. He plays
along, marveling that she has
“constructed a world where ev-
erything is exactly as it was.”
Inside the old woman’s apart-
ment, we see a kind man in the
act of perpetrating an expansive
kindness, albeit one built on a
foundation of untruths.
They found comfort in “a
world of lies, a world within a
world where they could be hap-
py,” Palma writes.
Once outside, Alberto gazes up
at the sky. It’s snowing. It was as
if someone had shaken a snow
globe — and he was inside it.
[email protected]
affection and the strange elusive-
ness we can sometimes encoun-
ter, even in the arms of the ones
we love.
“It could have been paradise,”
Marcelo’s lover muses, “but for
the fact that I was unable to
forget that I was embracing a
man who was constantly fleeing,
a man determined to dismantle
himself.”
Palma may be best known to
American readers for his 2011
bestseller, the first of a trilogy of
novels, “The Map of Time,” which
has now been translated into
30 languages. What elevates Pal-
ma’s storytelling is that he
plumbs the most mundane as-
pects of everyday life and the
most invisible of human beings,
the sort of people we pass on the
street without noticing, and uses
them as launchpads for phantas-
magoric flights of the imagina-
tion.
In the collection’s finest piece,
“Roses Against the Wind,” a des-
ultory office worker named Al-
berto suddenly sees himself in
“the tiny figure of a gray-suited
man carrying a leather briefcase”
standing along the tracks of the
elaborate model railway that his
grandfather has been building
for half a century in a crumbling,
once-grand apartment.
The track runs through an
“impossible world” where the
Palace of Versailles sits next to
the pyramids of Machu Picchu
and the Eiffel Tower casts a
shadow over the Taj Mahal.
Alberto visits his grandfather
almost daily, usually finding him
“sleeping with his eyes gently
closed and a complicit smile on
his lips, as if he knew a secret
that was forbidden to the rest of
us.” Alberto is puzzled by his
grandfather’s apparent content-
ment until he realizes that the
old man is transporting himself
into the railway, “every last detail
of his creation engraved in his
mind.” His grandfather is enjoy-
ing a thrilling, though imaginary,
life of globe-trotting adventure
while Alberto’s own life couldn’t
be any more dull.
“My days had been uneventful,
tranquil, and monotonous,” he
laments. “Mornings in the office
like an insipid overture that led
into lazy evenings of crosswords
and coffees.”
BOOK WORLD FROM C1
instinct is to go as dark as possible.
But when another actor comes in,
it feels like a really abstract energy
you’re playing against. It’s always
a little bit funnier and lighter.
“If somebody else played Wil-
lem’s part in ‘The Lighthouse,’ it
could be the most brutal, horrible
drama. But there’s something
about the anarchic energy Willem
brings. No matter how dark he is,
there’s always something pretty
entertaining about him.”
Critics have praised Dafoe and
Pattinson, who seem perfectly
suited to their roles in a film that is
equal parts melodramatic and ab-
surd — a casting success story
Eggers said he cannot explain be-
yond calling it a hunch.
“They’re both actors who like to
take risks, who like to do strange,
challenging work, who like to seek
out auteurs and wannabe auteurs
like myself and really stretch
themselves,” he said. “Certainly,
they both have noses and cheek-
bones and teeth, and they almost
look related sometimes, which is
nice. On the cover of Esquire UK,
they’re like a long-lost sexy vam-
pire father and son.”
[email protected]
also includes him chugging kero-
sene and masturbating to a mer-
maid figurine.)
“I couldn’t really see anything,”
he said. “Being blind, naked and
having various people artistically
arrange s--- all over your naked
body, that was an unusual thing to
do. Sort of a strange spa treat-
ment.”
Pattinson initially noticed the
film’s “strikingly strange script,”
which spends a good amount of
time in an even-paced, dour zone
and switches to a “turbocharged
surrealist thing” in its final act.
Winslow opens up as the film
progresses (or spills his beans, as
Wake puts it) and reveals himself
to be a man on the run from his
tragic past — not unlike other
characters Pattinson has played in
his recent indie films, including
the space-traveling death row in-
mate from Claire Denis’s “High
Life.”
“I find it’s much more fun to
play characters who don’t know
who they are,” he explained. “It
opens you up in how you play
individual scenes, because you
don’t know how you’re going to
play it until you’re there.... My
formances in ways they couldn’t
predict. (A portion of the 35-day
shoot also took place on sound-
stages in Halifax, a city about a
three-hour drive away.)
“We chose that location be-
cause it was punishing and had
terrible weather and would give us
what we needed for the story, and
it delivered on that,” Eggers said of
the high winds, pouring rain and
slightly-above-freezing tempera-
tures. Most of the film’s weather
events were real — a few milder
days required rain machines —
but “obviously, when you have
waves crashing and it’s Robert
Pattinson trying to launch a ship,
that’s done in a controlled way so
we don’t lose Rob to a riptide.”
Dafoe found the scenes where a
shirtless Wake basks in the light at
the top of the tower to be his most
physically challenging, as “high-
velocity winds aren’t too good,
particularly when you’re naked
and it’s raining.” Pattinson, asked
about obstacles he faced, instead
recalled his amusement while
filming a scene in which Winslow
is covered in all sorts of debris.
(This is a tamer stop on the char-
acter’s journey to insanity, which
ter (with the exception of brief
appearances by Valeriia Kara-
man’s shrieking mermaid and a
very aggressive seagull). Their
path to doom is hinted at from the
start, when Thomas Wake (Da-
foe), a brutish man who has been
on the rock for so long that he
describes himself as “damn near
married to this here light,” in-
forms his new apprentice,
Ephraim Winslow (Pattinson),
that the latter’s predecessor died
after raving about sirens and some
sort of “enchantment” in the tow-
er’s light.
Both actors said they were cast
in the two-hander after, beguiled
by “The Witch,” they reached out
to Eggers and pledged to work
with the rising indie director
sometime in the near future.
Dafoe was especially drawn to
the specificity of Eggers’s vision,
he said, as “one of the strongest
things a director can do is make
the world detailed and articulate
and deep... so when you enter it,
it’s much more easy to pretend.”
His character, Wake, delivers the
bulk of the film’s dialogue in long-
winded speeches to Winslow, who
conversely declares that he “ain’t
much for talkin’. ”
Eggers, whom Dafoe considers
an “obsessive researcher,” provid-
ed the actors with recordings and
videos of lighthouse keepers to
help them nail the accent Dafoe
described as a mix of West Coun-
try English and “the Robert New-
ton kind of classic pirate.” He likes
to rehearse — a trait Eggers attrib-
uted to his background in theater
— and in his spare time often
invited Eggers over to the fisher-
man’s shack he stayed in so he
could run lines in the accent. (Egg-
ers said he and his brother got so
carried away writing dialogue like
Wake’s “faux-Shakespearean sea
curse” that Dafoe asked them to
cut it down.)
“It was mostly studying, read-
ing, getting fake teeth made,
growing a beard... learning how
to keep a clay pipe lit while I’m
doing these big speeches,” Dafoe
said of his preparation for the role.
“It’s a swirl of experience that
helps you enter the world, but you
can’t do it fully until you’re really
there.”
“There,” in this case, was Cape
Forchu, a small fishing communi-
ty along the southern coast of
Nova Scotia with rough condi-
tions that shaped the actors’ per-
LIGHTHOUSE FROM C1
BY ANNE MIDGETTE
In the mid-20th century,
Gustav Mahler, after a period of
semi-neglect, started to become
one of the canonical composers of
our time. It makes perfect sense.
Mahler foreshadowed 20th-cen-
tury angst; he can write a lyrical
melody and then jab it full of
anxiety and neuroses, like a voo-
doo doll. On Friday night, the Ger-
man baritone Christian Gerhaher
and pianist Gerold Huber gave a
Mahler song recital in the Terrace
Theater, courtesy of Vocal Arts DC,
that was laced with stabs of sound,
like raw and jangling nerves.
Indeed, Gerhaher took the neu-
rosis far beyond the measure of
Mahler business as usual, from
the very first song. “Wenn mein
Schatz Hochzeit macht” (When
my sweetheart gets married), the
start of the cycle “Songs of a Way-
farer,” is a melancholy outburst on
the sorrow of losing your beloved,
but it’s also a pretty tune and can
be sung beautifully. Gerhaher,
however, found everything that
was jagged in the vocal leaps and
verbal repetitions, half-barking
out abrupt high notes, and slow-
ing the whole thing down so much
that the sense of it as a small
lyrical entity was almost lost.
Make no mistake: This was a
deliberate approach. Indeed,
there’s little that Gerhaher does
onstage that isn’t deliberate, apart
perhaps from the fluttering of his
left hand where it hung by his side,
like a repressed plea for even more
expression. Around the same time
that Mahler began to become pop-
ular, so did the German baritone
Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, who
left a strong mark on the art of
German song through the way he
gave nuance and attention to ev-
ery note, every syllable and every
shade of a text’s meaning. Gerha-
her, who is accounted one of the
greatest lieder singers of the pre-
sent day, takes this approach even
further, if possible, offering each
word in this first song as a sharp
little shard of realization, scarcely
cohering beyond their ability to
give or convey pain.
At the piano, Huber took the
same approach, playing with
more fluidity of sound than Ger-
haher’s sandy bark but with even
more of a spasmodic quality, so
that the edge of the musical line
became as sharp and steely and
bending as a bowed saw. The two
artists have been collaborating for
more than 30 years, and there is
something intimate and personal
about such a partnership; in this
case, it was expressed in their
pushing songs to their limits, car-
rying waking emotion over into a
neurotic dream state, with the
subconscious bobbing up in
ghastly nightmare vignettes such
as “Das irdische Leben” (earthly
life), in which a child starves to
death while waiting for its mother
to bake bread.
The program arced over three
Mahler cycles. The Wayfarer
songs were followed by 10 songs
from “Des Knaben Wunderhorn”
(the boy’s magic horn), settings
from a collection of folk-inspired
poetry that echoes “Grimms’ Fairy
Tales” in their otherworldliness.
And the night concluded with
“Kindertotenlieder” (songs on the
death of children), one of the most
powerful and wrenching pieces of
music in the repertory, a setting of
five texts by Friedrich Rückert
written after his children had died
of scarlet fever, minutely evoking
the anguish of the loss. Searing
and keening and surging, the mu-
sic mirrors and expands the texts’
turbulence and beauty.
Gerhaher’s voice is not beauti-
ful these days — not at all. The
singer is 50 this year — still in his
vocal prime — and has excellent
technical command, but he’s so
resolutely focused on meaning
rather than aesthetics that beauty
of sound is not among his priori-
ties. Sometimes a bleaty quality
crept in, sometimes a dry high
note was rasped or snarled, some-
times an ornament emerged with
the bite of a buzz saw. This wasn’t a
performance about nonessentials,
certainly not about prettiness
when deeper meaning was there
to be probed. I found the relent-
less hammering and emotional
intensity a little wearing; others
were powerfully moved. Certainly
one could argue that the recital
was as raw and stark and jarring
as the music of Mahler originally
was, before it was swathed in a
mantle of familiarity.
[email protected]
MUSIC REVIEW
German duo delivers a raw, emotional Mahler recital
Actors take on ‘strikingly strange script’
Tales from the worlds we
create inside our heads
A24 PICTURES
Robert Pattinson, above, and Willem Dafoe are lighthouse keepers in a film set in 1890s New England.
Félix J. Palma
she crooned the meditative slow
jam “I Don’t Wanna Know,” and
sprinting as she feverishly sang
“Unlock It.”
“I just really hope that tonight is
a safe space where we can all be
ourselves, be free to be free, feel
good, be weirdos, love each other
and also party hard,” she told the
crowd. And for that night, Charli
XCX’s exuberant, expansive pop
music held that space.
[email protected]
ness by 2016’s “Vroom Vroom” EP,
her vision becoming even clearer
by 2017’s “Pop 2.”
Onstage, Charli’s energy
seemed never-ending; she was a
human defibrillator, and whenev-
er the crowd started to fade even a
little, she would jump up and re-
vive them. And despite her chaotic
movements, Charli’s breath con-
trol stayed strong, ringing out as
CHARLI XCX FROM C1
An artist who can bring
the audience back to life
KYLE GUSTAFSON FOR THE WASHINGTON POST
Charli XCX brought her exuberant pop sound to the 9:30 Club.
Christian Gerhaher
offers each word in this
first song as a sharp
little shard of
realization, scarcely
cohering beyond their
ability to give or convey
pain.
MUSIC - CHORAL
Waynepres.org/
music
Free
No
Tickets
Required
Washington National Cathedral
3101 Wisconsin Ave. NW
Washington, DC 20016
Waynepres.org/music
The Wayne Oratorio Society from Wayne, PA presents
Felix Mendelssohn’s “Elijah.” Featuring a 200 member
choir, professional soloists and orchestra.
Saturday
October 26, 2019
7:30pm
Wayne Oratorio Society
Elijah
Felix Mendelssohn
3GD&THCDSNSGD+HUDKX QSR@OOD@QRr2TMC@XHM QSR2SXKD
CD@CKHMD3TDR
MNNMr,NMC@XHM2SXKD
CD@CKHMD%QHC@XMNNM
r3TDRC@XHM2SXKD
CD@CKHMD,NM
MNNMr6DCMDRC@XHM2SXKD
CD@CKHMD3TDR
MNNMr3GTQRC@XHM2SXKD
CD@CKHMD6DC
MNNM
r3GTQRC@XHM$WOQDRR
CD@CKHMD6DC
MNNMr%QHC@XHM6DDJDMC
CD@CKHMD3TDR
MNNMr2@STQC@XHM2SXKD
CD@CKHMD%QHC@XMNNM
%NQHMENQL@SHNM@ANTS@CUDQSHRHMFB@KK1@XLNMC!NXDQNQ-HBNKD&HCCDMR
3NQD@BG@QDOQDRDMS@SHUDB@KK|FTHCDSN@QSRV@RGONRS
BNL 16-2898