The Origins of Happiness

(Elliott) #1
Chapter 4

each previous year of unemployment is reducing cur -


rent life- satisfaction by about 0.1 point. Thus unemploy-


ment causes pain not only at the time but also to a lesser


extent over the years that follow, even after the person is


back in work.^12


Local Unemployment


When jobs are scarce, this makes some people unemployed;


but it also creates fear and uncertainty for many more


people, even if they currently have work. In consequence,


when unemployment rises in a region, this reduces the life-


satisfaction of the employed population in the region. Table


4.4 shows this effect in the first row of the table.^13 It im-


plies that in Britain a 10% local unemployment rate reduces


the life- satisfaction of the employed population by 0.14


points— and rather more in Germany and less in Australia.


At the same time, for those who are unemployed, a high


unemployment rate reduces their sense of shame at being


unemployed, and it also expands the social group with


whom they can interact.^14 Does this help? We investigate


this issue in the second row of the table, and the answer is


Yes, it helps but not by much. For example, in Britain, using


the bottom two rows of the table we find the following. If


the local unemployment rate is 10%, unemployed people


suffer in total a loss of 0.69 points (i.e., 0.73−0.038), while


when the unemployment rate is zero they suffer by 0.73


points. This is not much comfort, and even though the esti-


mated interaction effect is bigger in Germany and Australia,


we conclude that social comparisons are not a big issue for


the effects of unemployment.

Free download pdf