The best guess is that the culprits are “organized Asian criminal
syndicateswhomusthaveaprettyextraordinarysourcingnetwork”45PangolinscaleshavebeenusedinChinesemedicinesince
atleastthe16thcentury.Untilrelativelyrecently,thedemand
couldbemetbysmall-scalepoachingoflocalpopulations.
“Whatwe’veseeninrecentyearsis growingprosperityinthose
regions,whichis a goodthing,butit doesmeanthey’reableto
affordthingsthatwerepreviouslyunobtainable,”Thomassays.
PersuadingChineseandVietnameseconsumerstogive
uppangolinwillbetheworkofmanyyears.A surveyby
thecharityWildAidof3,000Chinesecitydwellersin 2017
foundthat50%believedpangolinproductshavemedicinal
value.(Theyalmostcertainlydon’t:You’llgetasmuchben-
efitfromeatingyourfingernails.)Despitetheiruselessness,
scalesremainlistedintheofficialpharmacopeiaissuedby
China’shealthregulator,andaccordingtoWildAidmorethan
60 drugs approved in the country contain pangolin products,
indicated for conditions such as swelling, hemorrhoids, tight
muscles, and poor circulation. The next edition of the phar-
macopeia is due in 2020, and activists hope the scales will
be removed from that version or a subsequent one, as rhino
horn and tiger bone were in the 1990s.
Environmental organizations are doing what they can to
educate the public. WildAid and the Nature Conservancy have
commissioned ads featuring the Chinese actress Angelababy,
as well as an adorable one starring Jackie Chan as kung fu
instructor to a trio of CGI pangolins. WildAid has also
deployed educational videos in Vietnamese shopping cen-
ters and airports and convened Chinese medicine experts
for seminars on alternatives to scales.
Stamping out demand entirely could prove impossible,
though. Ad campaigns discouraging consumption of rhino
horn and elephant ivory for more than a decade have seen
some success, but neither trade is close to disappearing. A
recent study by Traffic showed that ivory jewelry was still
readily available in Vietnam’s stores and social media chan-
nels, while another survey of the country, commissioned by
the U.S. Agency for International Development, reported that
6% of respondents had purchased rhino products in the pre-
ceding year.
At Cuc Phuong National Park, a sweltering nature preserve
in northern Vietnam, a group of veterinarians, zoologists, and
volunteers is working to rehabilitate pangolins confiscated
from trafficking operations and to help revive the country’s
population. Save Vietnam’s Wildlife (SVW) was founded in 2014
by Nguyen Van Thai, a conservationist who’d been working
with pangolins in the park for nearly a decade. It has about 40
to 50 of the animals on-site at a time, many of which arrived
dehydrated, malnourished, and traumatized.
Pangolin gourmands prefer the meat be freshly killed, as
with lobsters, so busts—conducted by the Vietnamese author-
ities with increasing frequency—often turn up live animals.
Some come from as far away as Borneo. The conditions of their
carriage are appalling, with pangolins sometimes confined in
shipping containers, marinating in their own waste. Others
have been force-fed to fatten them up. Serving pangolin meat,
Nguyencomplains,still“isseenasa waytoimpresssomeone
withsomethingrare,somethingspecial.”
AftertheyarriveatSVW,pangolinsspend 30 days under
quarantine in concrete-enclosed pens. They may require
urgent medical care: rehydration therapy, often, and some-
times the removal of eyes damaged by malnutrition or the
amputation of limbs or tails wounded by snares. Next to the
door of each pen, a dry-erase board lists the occupant’s date
of arrival, identification number, and health issues such as
cloudy eyes or lingering wounds. On one, the problem is
listedassimply“stress.”
Theworst-offanimalsspendtimeinanintensive-careunit,
tendedbya teamofveterinarianswhosepangolin expertise
is evolving, to say the least. “We do a lot of MacGyvering.
You have to make things work,” says Jessica Jimerson, who
came over from the Houston Zoo to manage SVW’s veteri-
nary clinic; her right bicep features an impressively detailed
tattoo of a balled-up pangolin. Jimerson recently performed
the clinic’s first pangolin blood transfusion, drawing from
a strapping male specimen to aid a female on the verge of
death. That procedure was a success, but not every patient
can be saved. “We’re so far behind the eight ball by the time
we get them,” she says.
The healthy pangolins at SVW while away their days in
special sleeping cubbies with narrow apertures, a design
intended to mimic the pitch-black conditions of a burrow. At
night they’re fed a dish of frozen ant eggs, placed just inside
the doors of the spacious enclosures they roam while awake.
Within a few moments they emerge from deep inside their
pens, positioning themselves above the bowl and hoover-
ing up the meal with methodical strokes of their tongues.
After that they’re left to explore the tree trunks and branches
threaded through their living areas. Staff sometimes hide
“enrichment toys”—bamboo pole lengths stuffed with ants,
covered at each end with a disguise of leaves. The idea is
to get the residents sniffing for meals to revive their forag-
ing instinct for when they’re released back into the wild.
They typically stay at SVW for a couple of months before
that happens.
Nguyen’s operation is something of a conservation show-
piece, supported by Sydney’s Taronga Zoo, the U.S. Fish
and Wildlife Service, and Humane Society International.
Funding is easier to come by than it once was, with the pan-
golin marching up the list of conservation priorities. “Before
a few years ago, when I went to North America or Europe
to talk about pangolins, people thought I meant penguins,”
Nguyensayswitha laugh.
Theworkis stillarduousanditssuccessdifficulttomea-
sure.SVWhas rescuedmorethan 1,000pangolins and
returned the majority to the wild; how they fare afterward is
hard to know. Nguyen’s goals are necessarily modest. “We’re
trying to slow the speed of the decline, and hopefully in the
nextfewyearswecanstopthedeclineandstarta recov-
ery,”hesays.“Westillbelievethethingswedocanmake a
difference.” <BW> �With Giang Nguyen and Daniela Wei