The Spartan Regime_ Its Character, Origins, and Grand Strategy - Paul Anthony Rahe

(Dana P.) #1

56 Polıteía


events, learned much from experience, and then finally entered their twilight


years. The result is a psychological portrait of considerable subtlety which may


throw a great deal of light on the nature of the Spartan regime.


“In character,” Aristotle observes, “the young are guided by desire and pre-


pared to act in accord with its dictates.” They are particularly vulnerable to


sexual license because they lack full self-control. At the same time, “they are


quick to change and fickle in their desires”; and because “their impulses are


keen but not grand,” they tend to oscillate between violent passion and sudden


disinterest. In addition, “young men are spirited, sharp-tempered, and apt to


give way to anger.” They are unable entirely to restrain the spirited part of their


souls; and “owing to phılotımía, they cannot endure being slighted and become


indignant when they suppose that they have been wronged.” But although the


young love honor, “they love victory even more” because they desire the “su-


periority” which only victory can bring. Accordingly, they attach little value


to money “because they have never experienced the trials arising from want.”


This dearth of unpleasant experience has other consequences as well. In partic-


ular, the young are good-natured, quick to trust, and full of hope. In addition,


“they are hot-blooded—like men drunk on wine.” They have themselves had


little opportunity to blunder; and because the future before them seems open,


they are guided by hope. “In the first days of one’s life,” Aristotle observes, “one


has nothing to remember and everything to look forward to.”


Both because the young are hot-blooded and because they so easily give


way to hope, they tend to be courageous. “An angry man is not likely to know


fear,” Aristotle explains, “and hope is good for generating confidence.” This


courage is balanced by a certain vulnerability to shame, a certain natural bash-


fulness; and since the young “have been educated in accord with convention


and have not yet conceived of other things as honorable,” they can easily be


kept under control. Furthermore, because they have “not been laid low by life


and are as yet untried by harsh necessity,” young men tend to be high-minded


and magnanimous—to be what the Greeks called “men of great soul [megalóp­


suchoı ]”—and to think themselves “worthy of great things.” As a consequence,


the young choose “to perform deeds of nobility rather than works of advan-


tage and to govern their conduct in accord with the dictates of good character


rather than in accord with those of calculation.” This distinction is important


because “calculation aims at the advantageous while virtue seeks the noble.”


Furthermore, men are more likely when young to “hold friends and compan-

Free download pdf