Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
“perfect storm”of drought anddzudoccurred, in 1999 – 2001 , it killed off

30 percent (about 8 – 10 million head) of Mongolia’s total herd population,

the worst natural disaster in its recorded history.^34

A recent 2009 study, based in part on the 1999 – 2001 event, concluded

there was no empirical connection between drought and dzud. The

region’s extreme weather is likely connected somehow to dynamics

between its aridity, highly seasonal summer precipitation, enormous

annual temperature range, sparse vegetation, and unusual geographical

position. The Mongolian plateau lies at an elevated northern latitude far

from any ocean, indirectly affected by the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau’s rain

shadow, and exposed to Siberian high-pressure fronts. Some of these

conditions date back to the last major glacial period, the Pleistocene era

( 13 , 000 years BP). The resulting dynamics, however, do not necessarily

produce cyclic disturbances such as drought anddzudin what is other-

wise a steady state of ecological balance that inevitably reasserts itself.

In terms of regional precipitation, the 2009 study concluded that the

precipitation index in Mongolia’s South Gobi province defined the area

as a nonequilibrium zone that failed to meet the minimum requirement

for stable plant and animal ecosystem interactions.^35

Preindustrial pastoral practices, especially high mobility, that create

interdependencies between people and animals have been the primary

human response to the steppe’sdefinitive extreme, and often nonequili-

brium, weather events. Disaster relief has, consequently, been critical, but

reactive. So expedience has tended to prevail over pastorally appropriate

measures. In attempting to adapt to substantially ungovernable steppe

conditions the Qing state naturally inclined toward those most amenable

to human intervention. With its economic and political heartland located

well to the south in the agrarian and marketized alluvial plains of China

proper, eighteenth-century imperial Chinese human intervention arrived

as grain and silver, not livestock. It was not so much Mongol subjection

to banners, but Mongol dependency on livestock, that was the prerequis-

ite relation for the stability of imperial pastoralism. This connection

subsisted most immediately on grass and water, which, in turn, were most

imperilled by nonequilibrium drought anddzud.

rain, grass, and relief


The steppe’s already harsh environment probably became even less hos-

pitable during the Ming-Qing period (mid–fourteenth through nineteenth

centuries). Inner Mongolia’s general spell of dry cold air at this time could

The Nature of Imperial Pastoralism in Southern Inner Mongolia 129
Free download pdf