Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
livestock. The Qing adaptation, consequently, was more anthropocentric,

relying heavily on culture, generally mediated through native chieftain-

ships, to transform indigenous peoples into proper subjects. Even the

region’s basic set of relations, highland swidden agriculture, was less

adaptable to imperial arablist practices of lowland cultivation.

So southwestern Yunnan was a borderland radically different from

its northern counterparts in Manchuria and Mongolia, the home

territories of the Qing core elites. The embodiments of these latter

borderlands were quite acclimated tothem, and this facilitated the Qing

imposition of imperial pastoralism or imperial foraging. Neither

embodiment, however, was sufficiently conditioned for the extremes of

the empire’s mountainous southwestern fringes. Even a Han agrarian

identity, which had proved so adaptable to conditions across forest,

steppe, and alluvial plain, had difficultyfinding a foothold in these

precipitous highlands and diseasedlowlands. All three of the empire’s

primary ethnic identities were united by their mutual vulnerability to the

disease environment of southwestern Yunnan, which precluded stand-

ard imperial adaptations for administratively significant Manchu,

Mongol, or Han residence. Dynastic control over the region was corres-

pondingly weaker than in Mongolian or Manchurian borderlands

despite southwestern Yunnan’s much smaller size. Nevertheless, its stra-

tegic importance both as gateway to the area’s considerable mineral

wealth, which attracted large numbers of Han migrants, and as conduit

between Qing and Konbaung territory made the borderland decisive for

regional stability.^3

Differential resistance structured these critical southwestern borderland

interactions. The state’s interpretation of the effects of malaria in mono-

lithic “racial” terms reinforced ethnic identities. Distinctions between

vulnerable Han newcomers and acclimated indigenous“tribal”(yi)peoples

were spatially expressed as the ethnic administrative areas contrived for

separate control. Organizational distinction between particular ethnicities

interconnected with particular ecologies, rather than simply between

different“cultures”alone, was characteristic of Qing borderland policy

in general. The disease-attenuated Qing southwestern order took the

administrative form of an unstable“imperial indigenism”of chieftainships

as the dynasty’s compromise with southwestern Yunnan’s nexus of

malarial nature and indigenous culture.

Of course, the Qing southwestern borderland was not simply a

product of relations between humans, mosquitoes, and haematozoa,

but these were integral to the regional order of imperial indigenism.

170 Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain
Free download pdf