Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
susceptibility to tropical disease,”ecological factors substantially condi-

tioned these cultural relationships.^4 Consideration of connections

between malaria and ethnic identity in Qing Yunnan expands the two-

dimensional representation of Han-indigenous relations as a cultural

product to include biological processes such as differential resistance.

Residence in southwestern Yunnan meant intimate involvement in the

life cycles of both mosquitoes and haematozoa with malaria a common

result. The most spatially significant human adaptive response produced

chieftainships. In this way the disease environment created political as

well as biological boundaries that complicated borderland construction of

imperial indigenism.

Pertinent and forbidding ecological boundaries commence amid the

river systems that cut through Yunnan’s mountains. These make up about

84 percent of a province that is part of larger geographical systems such as

the Greater Mekong Subregion and the Southeast Asian massif. They

extend millions of square kilometers beyond the boundaries of any single

state past or present. Wide divergences in elevation, ranging from well

under one hundred to well over six thousand meters, can occur over

comparatively short distances covering tropical to frigid zones. The pro-

vince is also a meeting point for monsoon systems from both the Pacific

and Indian oceans. These widely varying conditions permit year-round

malaria transmission at lower altitudes, generally belowfifteen hundred

meters and south of 25 N, while usually, but not always, precluding it at

higher elevations.^5 The resulting ecological diversity created many envir-

onmental obstacles, especially disease, to a direct, sustained dynastic

presence. The Qing solution was a reliance on native chieftainships

despite the problems they caused.^6

These problems were numerous and complex but generally stemmed

from the considerable indigenous autonomy enjoyed by these“native

chieftainships”as well as by free-range“wild tribals”(yeyi). In large

degree, these Qing administrative terms were another variation on the

traditional imperial binary of“civilized”(shu) and“savage”(sheng), or,

as in the discourse of smallpox,“raw”and“cooked.”Yet differences

between wild and chieftainship peoples were often indistinct and even

imaginary, as some officials recognized. Liu Bin, a provincial private

secretary in the 1710 s, wrote that in Yongchang and Shunning prefectures

there was no practical difference between wild and chieftainship groups.

Both were actually subject to the dynasty“in name only”because they

resided in areas such as Gengma where dynastic“law did not reach.”

One frustrated Yun-Gui governor-general in 1766 even recommended

172 Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain
Free download pdf