Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
Chieftainships were exceptional from the onset of Qing rule, when they

were permitted to“temporarily follow their old customs until the region

was stabilized.”Only gradually would they be“made aware of ortho-

doxy and slowly compelled to a respectful compliance with the new

system”to effect the adoption of“norms and ethics identical”with China

proper’s.^14 This assimilation process, however, was qualified by security

concerns. As provincial military official Zhou Huafeng explained,

“China’s having native chieftains is like a residence having a fence.

If the fence is not secure, then the residence will not be peaceful”and

subject to incursion by other indigenous peoples or Myanmar invasion.

He also admitted that“the reason that native chieftainships along the

border...all accept our institutions and pay our taxes and labor services

without becoming disaffected is because of our state’s bountiful favor and

virtue and because we dare not recklessly interfere with foreign

customs.”^15 Such remarks indicate that chieftainships resembled allies

more than subjects and were treated accordingly by officials. Human

agency and ecological conditions necessitated compromise for the inter-

mittent Qing control of inner frontier chieftainships, which were tied to

an unstable concept of indigenous identity as the only option to embody a

dynastic presence in an otherwise forbidding disease environment.

Malaria was, in contemporary terms of eighteenth- and nineteenth-

century Yunnan, an immutable reality that did not arrest but did structure

and constrain human action. The following examination of interaction

between disease and human agency takes select environmental conditions

into active historical account without allowing them to dictate human

actions. Specifically, mosquitoes and haematozoa have contributed to the

spatial and ethnic formation of Yunnan’s imperial borderlands even as

these borderlands were formed by interactions of the region’s indigenous

peoples, Qing administrators, and Han settlers. Indeed, spatial and iden-

tity formations arising from human interaction with disease environments

were restricted neither to western Yunnan nor to the Qing empire

between the seventeenth and nineteenth centuries.

disease: some comparative considerations


Concepts of“biopower”or“biosociality”are some of the more influen-

tial approaches to the study of the formation of“health identities,”that

is, the production of human social diversity based on perceptions of

variation in the physical condition of human bodies. It has recently been

suggested, however, that the central concern of these approaches with

174 Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain
Free download pdf