Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
reign, the Luohei’s activities in gaps between chieftainships andjunxian

jurisdictions in southern Shunning and Pu’er triggered three major upris-

ings between 1796 and 1814.^50 Belin’s encounters with the Luohei and

Kawa during his 1804 – 14 governor-generalship informed his observation

that the malarial conditions of their zones made assault with anything but

chieftainship auxiliaries impossible. The Luohei“lairs”he mapped out on

both sides of the Lancang stretch of the Mekong River boundary between

Shunning and Pu’er,however,werewellwithintheinnerfrontierchief-

tainships supposed to keep the wild at bay.^51 Imperial indigenist space

was also hosting wild infestations that would leave Yunnan proper

exposed.

Consequently, the Qing had to cultivate a particular type of polit-

ical ground within this disease environment, in the more centralized

forms of Kachingumsaand Shan organizations, but state efforts did

not blossom into a stable borderland. Even the centralized chieftain-

ships were unacceptably disruptive, in the view of some officials,

precisely because they had hereditary or“feudal” (fengjian)rulers.

Hereditary succession made bloody, divisive succession struggles inev-

itable and obstructed the removal of established chiefs by any means

shortofwar.^52

Chronic conflict was a main rationale for campaigns, peaking in the

Yongzheng reign, to replace native chieftainships with central state

administrations (gaitu guiliu). Perhaps the most radical Qing attempt to

expand Yunnan proper, along with similar expansions in Guizhou and

Sichuan, this conversion effort was led by the famous Qing official and

imperial confidant Ortai as governor-general of Yun-Gui. His deployment

of more than one hundred thousand troops in a series of bloody and

controversial conversion operations against what he called“the frontier’s

great scourge”can easily give the impression that Ortai wanted to eradi-

cate indigenous rule throughout southwestern China.^53

In practice, Yunnan’s disease environment helped to preclude such

extremes, as some limited statistics suggest. Out of an estimated 220 native

chieftainships abolished during the Yongzheng reign, only seventeen were

located in Yunnan and only four in southwestern prefectures, which were

otherwise untouched by Yongzheng conversion operations. Ortai himself

had explicitly put chieftainships west of the Mekong (“Lancang”)River,

namely, those in Shunning and probably southern Yongchang, effectively

out of conversion bounds before operations started in 1726. The south-

westernmost two of the four converted chieftainships, located in what

would become Tengyue, were even restored in 1771. Conversion operations

The Nature of Imperial Indigenism in Southwestern Yunnan 187
Free download pdf