Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
traits arising from southwestern Yunnan’s disease environment that

conferred a greater resistance, ifby no means total immunity, on indi-

genous peoples.^76 Hemoglobin genetic disorders are a human response

to southwestern Yunnan’s disease environment.

Swidden agriculture may have helped to produce this environment by

making malaria endemic. Frank B. Livingstone’s classic anthropological

study of this connection in West Africa indicated that the employment of

iron tools for swiddening effectively increased the breeding ground

forAnopheles gambiae, the regional falciparummalariavector.Swid-

dening increased the density of human populations and reduced shaded

areas avoided by the insects to expand the blood supply and space

available for A. gambiae’s reproduction. Incidence of the defensive

human genetic adaptation of sickle-cell anemia increased in response.

Livingstone also showed a lower incidence of malaria and genetic

adaptations among foragers who do not practice swiddening and who,

therefore, had not accidentally built a disease environment in response

to local ecology. One 1932 study foundA. gambiaenumbers actually

increased when a forest was cut down and dropped during subsequent

reforestation. Similar environmental dynamics may also have been

operative in southwestern Yunnan. The affinity of certainAnopheles

species for environments transformed by humans would help explain

the persistence of regional malarial ties despite the radical terraforming

by Han cultivation.^77

In sum, observations by Qing subjects and Nationalist citizens

regarding the superior resistance of southwestern provincials to the most

lethal form of malaria endemic to the region has a basis in current

scientific understanding. A 1943 study of the disease in Mangshi

confirmed a much higher incidence of chronic malaria among Chinese

than among indigenous residents. Of course, it is necessary to qualify

observations that tend to overgeneralize in racial terms and so can easily

give the false impression that Han residence in southwestern Yunnan’s

malarial disease environment was impossible in all circumstances. Some

accounts note the particular susceptibility of“migrants”(liuyu). Yet, in at

least one instance, Ortai demonstrated his own understanding that resist-

ance to malaria was not so determined and thus did not constitute an

immutable distinction between Han and local peoples. In 1726 , respond-

ing to fears that a proposed site of walled construction in Yuanjiang

prefecture might be malarial, he pointed out that Yuanjiang had been

underjunxian, and, so, Han, control since 1660. Over time,“both gentry

and commoners”had become“acclimated”(xiguan) to the disease.^78

196 Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain
Free download pdf