Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain_ Environment, Identity, and Empire in Qing China\'s Borderlands

(Ann) #1
advantages under frigid northeastern conditions are apparent in the

1736 – 43 deliberations over Hulun Buir troop dispositions. On this

ground Solon-Ewenki and Bargut hunters proved better able to keep

themselves fed in extreme winter conditions than their agrarian Dagur

comrades.

Adequate cultivation in more temperate woodlands, of course, was not

impossible, as indigenous swiddening in the southwest demonstrates.

However, cultivation that minimized deforestation had to work harder

and, in an imperial arablist view, less efficiently, as Yun-Gui governors-

general Cai Yurong and Gao Qizhuo both asserted. Some of this work is

engraved on the forest protection steles erected during the period of

growing Han agricultural pressure centering on the first half of the

nineteenth century and scattered across areas of Yi settlement in Yunnan.

Other parts of it are inked mainly on paper prescriptions, such as Bao

Shichen’s. Swiddening practiced by the Yi and other indigenous peoples

appears to have been the most sustainable form of cultivation possible

under sylvan conditions. Devastating extractions spawned by arablists

such as the 1845 Han mushroom entrepreneurs in Yongbei and Dayao

were taboo in Zomi-culture.

Nevertheless, by the nineteenth century, even imperial foraging had

overconcentrated resources, symbolized by the barren pine stumps that so

vexed the Jiaqing emperor. Zones of indigenous cultivation in the south-

west had come under palpable pressure as well. Stress was legible in the

fear expressed on an 1808 stele from what is now the Yi autonomous

county of Jingdong in Pu’er prefecture: the“bitter toil of years gone by

would be lost”to“shameless”timbering, burning off hillsides, fuel cut-

ting, construction, and even herding.^15 Much of Yunnan, already under

some form of cultivation, proved eminently convertible to Han-style

agriculture in a way similar to that of the southern Inner Mongolian

ecotone, and southern Manchuria’s as well.

However, southwestern Yunnan’s mosquitoes and blood parasites

preferred fresh Han farmers to the livestock favored by Mongolian

wolves, probably driven into putting further pressure on herders by

arablist habitat destruction circa 1747. Settler susceptibility to the

southwestern disease environment precluded a Han takeover of indigen-

ousfields along the lines feared by northern officials deliberating in the

same year over whether or not to provide seed grain and steppe plots

for Mongol relief. Such differences were critical for the vulnerability

of wide-open Mongolian pastures in comparison with Yunnan’scoarse-

grained highlands isolated by sweltering lowlands. On the contrary,

272 Across Forest, Steppe, and Mountain
Free download pdf