DISGRACE AND EXILE 203Starin a, V (1872), p. 470; N. S. Il'inskii, "Vospominaniia," Russkii Arkhiv, (1879),
No. 12, pp. 377--434; L. H. Jacob, Denkwurdigkeiten aus meinem Leben (manuscript);
F. P. Lubianovskii, "Vospominaniia F. P. Lubianovskogo," Russkii Arkhiv, (1872),
pp. 98-185, 448-533; V. R. Marchenko, "Avtobiograficheskie zapiski gosudarstvennogo
sekretaria V. R. Marchenki 1782-1838," Russkaia Starina, 85 (1896), 471-505, and
86 (1896), 3-20, 291-317; M. Mikhailovskii-Danilevskii, Nekotorye vypiski iz bumag
M. Danilevskogo, (Leipzig 1875); prot. Evg. Popov, "Dvukhletnii izgnannik v Permi- Speranskii" in J1elikopermskaia i Permskaia eparkhiia (inaccessible to me); Ia. I-
de Sanglen, "Zapiski 1776-1831," Russkaia Starina, 37 (1883), 1--46, 375-394,
539-578; Amiral Tchitchagoff, Memoires de l'Amiral Tchitchagoff 1767-1849
(Leipzig 1862); F. F. Vigel', J1ospominaniia (Moscow 1928); S. G. Volkonskii, Zapiski
S. G. J101konskogo (St. Pbg. 1902, 2d. ed.).
Contemporary polemical sources: G. P. Ermolov, "Pamfiet na
Speranskogo 16 marta 1813," Chteniia (1895), No.3, part 2, pp. 1-24; N. M.
Karamzin, "0 drevnei i novoi Rossii," Russkii Arkhiv, (1870), No.2: pp. 2225-2350.
Joseph de Maistre, "Cinq lettres sur l'education publique en Russie, It Monsieur Ie
Comte Rasoumovski, ministre de !'instruction publique - Juin 1810," Oeuvres
completes, J1III (Paris 1884), 163-232; de Maistre, "Quatre chapitres sur la Russie,"
Oeuvres completes, VIII, 279-362; "Pis'mo grafa Rostopchina k Aleksandru I s
donosom na Speranskogo 17 marta 1812:' Russkaia Starina, 122 (1905), 412--416.Con t em p ora ry corres p on d ence: P. Bartenev (ed.), Arkhiv kniazia
J1orontsova (Moscow 1870-1895); N. Dubrovin, Pis'ma glavneishikh deiatelei v
tsarstvovanie imperatora Aleksandra I (1807-1829), (St. Pbg. 1883); (Lauriston, Blome)
"Diplomaticheskie depeshi 0 ssylke Speranskogo," Russkii Arkhiv, (1882), No.2, pp.
169-176; Lettres et papiers du ahancelier comte de Nesselrode (Paris 1909-1912);
Grand Duc Nicolas Mikhailowitsch, Les relations diplomatiques de la Russie et de
la France d'apres les rapports des ambassadeurs d'Alexandre et de Napoleon (St. Pbg.
1905-1914); Nikolai Mikhailovich, Perepiska imperatora Aleksandra I s sestroi, velikoi
kniaginei Ekaterinoi Pavlovnoi, (St. Pbg. 1910); Ostafevskii arkhiv kniazei J1iazemskikh
(St. Pbg. 1899-1901); Parrot, "Lettres It Alexandre I et Nicolas I," in Shil'der,
Imperator Aleksandr I, III, appendix No. VI, 487--491; M. Pogodin, "Otryvok pis'ma
A. N. Murav'eva 0 Speranskom:' Russkii Arkhiv, (1871), pp. 1945-1948; A. Vandal
(ed.) "La cour de Russie en 1807-1808 - Notes sur la cour de Russie et St. Peters-
bourg ecrites en decembre 1807 par Ie general Savary:' Revue d'histoire diplomatique,
IV, (1890), pp. 399--419.Sec 0 n dar y w 0 r k s: A. Afanas'ev, "Dopolnenie k stat'e 0 Speranskom Long-
inova," Russkii J1estnik, 25 (1860), 26--41; T. Bakounine, Le repertoire biographique
des francs-macons fusses (XJ1III et XIx.e 55.), (Bruxelles, n.d. - Publication de
l'institut de philologie et d'histoire - Univ. de Bruxelles serie slave No. 2); M.
Bogdanovich, "Padenie Speranskogo" J1estnik Evropy, Vol. III, No. 12 (Dec. 1868),
pp. 495-505. I-A. Bychkov, (ed.), "Ssylka Speranskogo v 1812 g," Russkaia Starina,
110 (April 1902), 5--44; id., "Deiateli i uchastniki v padenii Speranskogo," Russkaia
Starina, 109 (March 1902), pp. 469-508; id., "Prebyvanie Speranskogo v Nizhnem
Novgorode i v Permi," Russkaia Starina, 110 (May 1902'1, 231-249; id., "Speranskii
v Velikopol'e i v Penze," Russkaia Starina, 110 (June 1902), 467--486 and 111 (July
1902),45-59; A. Dmitriev, "Prebyvanie M. M. Speranskogo v Permi," Russkii J1estnik,
(1869), No.8, 744-749; Ar. Fateev, "La dis¢ce d'un homme d'etat (It l'occasion du
centenaire de la mort de Speransky en 1839)," Zapiski russkogo nauchno-issledovatel'-
skogo ob'edineniia v Prage, tome X (old series XV), (Praha 1940), pp. 33-73 -
the second part (if published) could not be located by me; Ia. Grot, "K istorii ssylki
Speranskogo," Russkii Arkhiv, (1871), pp. 2073-2078; S. Iuzhakov, "Padenie
Speranskogo," Russkaia Mysl', (1890), No. 11, pp. 111-131; Karamzin i Speranskii
(Paris 1858); Robert A. Klostermann, "Speranskii's Sturz in L. H. Jakobs 'Denkwiir-
digkeiten' "Archiv filr Kulturgeschichte, 23-No. 2, (1932) 217-233; P. M. Maikov,
"A. A. Zherve," Russkaia Starina, Vol. 92 (1897), No. 10, pp. 97-120 and No. 11, pp.
393--403; E. A. Popov, M. M. Speranskii v Permi i Sibiri (Perm' 1879); V. I-
Semevskii, "Padenie Speranskogo" in Otechestvennaia voina i russkoe obshchestvo,
II (Moscow 1911), 221-246; A. V. Vasil'ev, "Progressivnyi podokhodnyi nalog i
padenie Speranskogo," Golos Minuvshego, IV (July-August 1916), No. 7-8, pp. 332-
340; Kenneth R. Whiting, Aleksei Andreevich Arakcheev (Harvard University,
unpublished Ph. D. thesis, 1951).