Mothers and Children. Jewish Family Life in Medieval Europe - Elisheva Baumgarten

(Rick Simeone) #1

dency of Sepher Hasidim,” Zion3(1938): 1–50 [in Hebrew], but subsequently rejected. Recently,
Talya Fishman has revived this idea: “The Penitential System of H·asidei Ashkenaz and the Prob-
lem of Cultural Boundaries,” Journal of Jewish Thought and Philosophy8 (1999): 201–30.



  1. David Berger, The Jewish-Christian Debate in the High Middle Ages(Philadelphia, 1979),
    section 205, 209. Comments on the same topic also appear in sections 42, 69–70.

  2. Ibid., 70; Bernhard Blumenkranz, Les auteurs chrétiens latin du moyen âge sur les juifs et la
    judäisme(Etudes juives, 4), (Paris, 1963), 98.

  3. Sylvie Laurent, Nâitre au moyen âge: De la Conception à la naissance, la grossesse et l’ac-
    couchement XIIe–Xve siècle(Paris, 1989); Jacques Gélis, L’Arbre et le fruit: La naissance dans l’oc-
    cident moderne(Paris, 1984).

  4. Rashi, Eruvin 27a, s.v. “P’riyah ureviyah”; Rashi, Kiddushin34a, s.v. “UP’riyah ureviyah.”

  5. For example in connection with tefillin(phylacteries), women are excluded from perform-
    ing this mitz·vabecause of requirements of guf naki—a clean body. See R. Samson b. Z·adok, Sefer
    haTashbez·(Warsaw, 1901), no. 270.

  6. John W. Baldwin, The Language of Sex: Five Voices from Northern France around 1200
    (Chicago and London, 1994), 206–10.

  7. For example: Catherine M. Mooney, “Claire of Assisi and Her Interpreters,” in Gendered
    Voices, 69–70.

  8. This idea comes across in the word used in Midrash Yez·irat haValad Oz·ar Midrashion, ed.
    Judah David Eisenstein (New York, 1915), 1: 244, where the woman’s body is referred to as a k’li,
    or receptacle.

  9. Ron Barkai, “Greek Medical Traditions and Their Impact on Conceptions of Women in
    the Gynaecological Writings in the Middle Ages,” A View into the Lives of Women in Jewish Soci-
    eties. Collected Essays, ed. Yael Azmon (Jerusalem, 1995), 124–26 [in Hebrew]; Joan Cadden,
    Meanings of Sex Difference in the Middle Ages: Medicine, Science and Culture(Cambridge, 1991).

  10. This is outlined in the versions of Midrash Yez·irat haValad, 1:244–45.
    39.SHP, no. 1188, and see a fuller discussion of this source (ch. 4, n. 14).

  11. These laws appear in Tractate S’machot(7:15) and are repeated throughout the Middle
    Ages. See for example: Sefer Or Zaru’a, Hilkhot Evel (Laws of Mourning), no. 448.

  12. In some cases, special magical chants and prayers were said to help ensure the birth of a
    son, especially in cases where a man had already fathered several daughters. Some of these for-
    mulas appear in MS Oxford Bodl., Mich. 9, (1531), fols. 175a–186a.

  13. For example: Rashi, Shabbat, s.v. “Ga’aguin—bremors... and this cure does not pertain to
    females since the father does not love them as much from the start.” For this preference in Chris-
    tian society, see Gélis, L’arbre, 163.

  14. In an excerpt from a thirteenth-century commentary on Genesis from northern France, the
    author writes: “And she was named Dinah”: It is not explained why she was named thus, for it is
    not necessary to explain except in the case of males, for they are the ikar—the core (cf. MS Vati-
    can 123, fol. 8b); Sefer Tosafot haShalem, Gen. 30: 21, no. 10 “and named her Dinah”: One does
    not give thanks for the birth of a daughter like for a son.”

  15. Gélis, L’arbre, 160–64.

  16. On child brides: Grossman, Pious and Rebellious, 63–87. Some girls were sexually active
    even before reaching sexual maturity. For example: SHP, no. 1155; MS Paris héb. 1120, fol. 66b,
    discusses difficulties during birth. One of the difficulties mentioned is: “And if for internal reasons,
    the girl conceives before she brought signs [of sexual maturity] and her straits are narrow.” For the
    history of this text, see: Ron Barkai, “A Medieval Treatise on Obstetrics,” Medical History33(1988):
    96–119. This passage describes the difficulties of young girls giving birth. Another fifteenth-
    century source voices concern over girls sexually active from a young age and recommends that
    doctors instruct these girls on how to prevent conception. See MS Paris héb. 1122, 46a, on preg-
    nancy and birth control: “And you should know that the doctor must give these medicines to a
    woman so that she does not conceive when she is young and has not yet reached her time.” It seems


200 NOTES TO CHAPTER 1
Free download pdf