Mothers and Children. Jewish Family Life in Medieval Europe - Elisheva Baumgarten

(Rick Simeone) #1

that fourteen was considered the age at which women commonly gave birth. See Sefer Tosafot
haShalem, Gen. 25:26, no. 9. Eleven was seen as the age at which girls were deemed able to give
birth: Rashi, Ketubbot 39a, s.v. “Pah·ot mikan” and s.v. “Veyeter al ken.”



  1. Karen E. Paige and Jeffrey M. Paige, The Politics of Reproductive Ritual(Berkeley, Los An-
    geles, and London, 1981); Whyte, The Status of Women,53–54, 80.

  2. This idea comes across in the medieval marriage and inheritance laws as well. Israel J. Yuval,
    “HaHesderim haKaspiyim shel haNissuin beAshkenaz beYemei haBenayim,” in Religion and Econ-
    omy: Connections and Interactions. Collected Essays, ed. Menahem Ben Sasson (Jerusalem, 1995),
    191–207, esp. 193–96, 199–205.

  3. Vern Bullough noted this paradox in his path-breaking article written almost thirty years ago:
    “Medieval Medical and Scientific Views of Women,” Viator4(1973): 497.

  4. See pp. 35–36.

  5. Jacqueline Murray, “On the Origins and the Role of ‘Wise Women’ in Cases for Annulment
    on the Grounds of Male Impotence,” Journal of Medieval History16(1990): 241–45. For an il-
    lustration of these examinations, see: Laurent, Nâitre au moyen âge, illustration 16. For an exam-
    ple in the Jewish sources: Sefer Or Zaru’a, 1: no. 652.
    51.SHP, no. 380.

  6. See, for example, in the Sefer Assaf, published by Zusman Muntner, Korot5(1970): 58, no.



  7. Supra, n. 50.

  8. It is not clear who would have performed the examination. Sefer Or Zaru’a, 1: no. 653.

  9. For examples of women bewitching in cases of fertility as well as in other cases, see Joseph
    Dan, “Sippurim demonologim mi-kitvei R. Judah he-H·asid,” in The Religious and Social Ideas of
    the Jewish Pietists in Medieval Germany, ed. Ivan G. Marcus (Jerusalem, 1987), 288, no. 29 [in
    Hebrew]. Witches are often called by their German name, “streya,” for example SHP, no. 1465–
    67, as well as Dan, ibid., 278, no. 2; 280, no. 5.

  10. Lett, L’Enfant des miracles, 242–44.
    57.See, for example, R. Gershom Me’or HaGolah’s discussion of a woman who does not men-
    struate but shows no exterior signs of physical difference. R. Gershom b. Judah, Teshuvot Ragmah,
    ed. Shlomo Eidelberg (New York, 1956), no. 84, and parallel source: Mordekhai, Yevamot, no. 113.

  11. MS Oxford Bodl., Opp. Add. 14 (1101), fol. 187a–b. This experiment was omitted from the
    printed version of the Lekah·Tov.

  12. Laurent, Nâitre au moyen âge, 48. The Trotulatexts have been thoroughly examined over
    the past years by Monica Green. See her articles “The Development of the Trotula,” Revue d’his-
    toire des textes16(1996): 119–203; and “A Handlist of Latin and Vernacular Manuscripts of the
    So-called TrotulaTexts.” Scriptorum50(1996): 137–75; 51(1997): 81–103. See Green’s transla-
    tion of the text: The Trotula: An English Translation of the Medieval Compendium of Women’s Med-
    icine(Philadelphia, 2002).

  13. These cures appear in a manuscript of the book Sefer Z·ori haGufby Nathan b. Joel Fal-
    quera, MS Paris héb. 1122, fol. 4b, 45a. On the author, see David Margalith, “Falquera, Nathan
    b. Joel,” EJ6: 1140, and the passing references to him in Barkai, Jewish Gynecological Texts, 88;
    Joseph Shatzmiller, Jews, Medicine and Medieval Society, 53–54.

  14. For example: “Sefer Assaf”; Korot4(1968): 531 no. 325.

  15. James Brundage, Law, Sex and Christian Society in Medieval Europe(Chicago-London,
    1987), 39, 115, 143–45.

  16. Murray, “Role of Wise Women,” 235–50.

  17. These statutes are documented in Louis Finkelstein, Jewish Self-Government in the Middle
    Ages(New York, 1964), 20–30, 139–47. For the different opinions on the dating of the manu-
    scripts and evidence, see: Grossman, Pious and Rebellious, 122–33. Recently, this topic has been
    discussed by Elimelech Westreich, Transitions in the Legal Status of the Wife in Jewish Law
    (Jerusalem, 2002), 62–96 [in Hebrew].


NOTES TO CHAPTER 1 201
Free download pdf