The Ancient Greek Economy. Markets, Households and City-States

(Rick Simeone) #1

PATTERNS OF AMPHORA STAMP DISTRIBUTION 211


often reused. As a result, an amphora may be found in a location determined


by its reuse and not because it was deposited there immediately after being


imported. This makes it difficult to link the find spot of an amphora to an


importing center. But this factor does not lead to serious distortions because


it appears that amphoras were reused in a confined area, not very distant from


the place to which they were imported (Lund and Gabrielsen 2005 :  164–5;


Lawall 2011a).


A substantial gap in amphora stamp studies lies in the absence of strict rel-

ative and absolute chronology for most of the series. In effect, only stamps of


Rhodes and Thasos (and on a broader level those of Cnidos) can be closely


dated. Consequently, we cannot trace the fluctuations of trade with chrono-


logical precision (Davies 1984 :  274). Still, we can start by using the existing


dating methods to identify broad chronological differences while counting


stamps.


A different problem in our ability to interpret amphora stamp distribution

has been highlighted by Gabrielsen ( 1997 : 65). By the example of the donation


of 10,000 jars of Rhodian wine to Sinope in 220 BC, reported by Polybius


(4.56.1-5), we should be warned in linking amphora stamps directly and exclu-


sively with trading activities (see also Rauh 1999 :  181 note 3; Finkielsztejn


2011 ). Apparently, when evaluating stamp distribution figures, we should take


into account also activities other than trade in the same way as Davies has


pointed out five major mechanisms responsible for the distribution of coins


( 1984 :  279–80:  payment for troops, subsidies/bribes/gifts, booty, taxation,


trade).


In addition, a general problem in the interpretation of amphoras in ancient

trade is that they are often too easily viewed as containers of wine and olive


oil. This often leads to false assumptions, because transport amphoras were


used for a vast variety of goods, ranging from honey and fish to pitch and alum


(Lund and Gabrielsen 2005 : 162; Panagou 2010 : 9–13; Lawall 2011b).


At the same time, it is essential to keep in mind that various goods were

transported in other forms of containers as well, such as sacks or askoi, or even


in bulk (Panagou 2010 : 8, 9). Thus, the estimation of the trading ability of a


given region cannot be based solely on stamps. Stamps offer us but a piece of


the puzzle.


Amphora Stamp Distribution


Despite the problems encountered when using amphora stamps as evidence


for ancient trade, they still provide much valuable information about export


patterns and advance our knowledge of the ancient economy. It is impor-


tant to count the number of recorded stamps at any given location because

Free download pdf