501 Critical Reading Questions

(Sean Pound) #1
definitions of happiness and goodness are intertwined; living a
good life will bring happiness.


  1. c. In the third paragraph, Aristotle lists several different ways that
    people define happinessto show that they all fit into the broad
    definition of a kind of good life and well-being.

  2. e.The opening sentence tells readers that making a list of pros and
    cons is a technique of utilitarian reasoning. Thus, readers who
    have used this technique will realize they are already familiar
    with the basic principles of utilitarianism.

  3. b.The second sentence explains the main argument of utilitarian-
    ism—that we should use consequences to determine our course
    of action. Thus positsis used here in the sense of asserts.

  4. c. Lines 2–4 explain that according to utilitarianism, only the conse-
    quencesof our actions are morally relevant. Lines 5–8 explain
    that an action is morally good if it creates good (happiness).

  5. d.Lines 15–17 state the utilitarian principle of choosing actions
    that create the greatest amount of good (happiness) for the greatest
    number of people.

  6. a. Lines 17–22 explain two aspects of utilitarianism that complicate
    the decision-making process: that it is not always clear what the
    consequences of an action will be (whether they will bring short-
    or long-term happiness and to what degree), and that sometimes
    we must sacrifice the happiness of others.

  7. b.In the first sentence, the author states that the subject-matter of
    knowledge is intimately united(line 2), while in the second sen-
    tence he adds the Sciences [... ] have multiple bearings on one
    another(lines 3–4). In line 6 he states that the sciences complete,
    correct, balance each other.

  8. d.In the first sentence, the author states that all branches of knowl-
    edge are connected together(line 1). Then, in the second sentence,
    he writes Hence it is that the Sciences, into which our knowledge may
    be said to be cast(lines 3–4). Thus, Newman is using the term the
    Sciencesto refer to all branches of knowledge.

  9. c. The word excisehere is used in an unusual way to mean imposeor
    put upon. The main context clue is the word influence, which sug-
    gests a giving torather than a taking away.

  10. a. Throughout the first paragraph, the author emphasizes the
    interdependence of the branches of knowledge and warns
    against focusing on one branch at the neglect of others. He
    states that to give undue prominence to one [area of study] is to be
    unjust to another; to neglect or supersede these is to divert those from
    their proper object(lines 10–12). More importantly, he states that

Free download pdf