dlscussed the aesthetics ofbreaking news,
the almost-camp spectacle apparently
required for the circulation of informa-
tion in dire times.
The entire coWltry is now red. The
pandemic has jammed the chum of so-
cial life, pausing hum.an interaction in
medias res. Theatres, con.c:ert'YC!lUCS, and
cinemas have closed. Rcsmurant!i in New
York are open only fut takeout and de-
livery. What else is there to do butwatcli
TV? Friends ask fut recorrunendati.ons.
("High Maintenance" if you're missing
your neighbors; "The Leftovers" if you're
a masochist.) I quite liked "DCVB," a bru-
tally elegant work of science fiction, set
in a jaundiced San Francisco in the near
future, and would have reviewed it, had
the world not changed.
It has been a long time since "tele-
vision" conjured the box around which
families once gathered to watch "The
Ed Sullivan Show" or to first glimpse
the surfu:e of the moon; in this cen-
tury, it encompasses whatever can be
streamed via a Rok:u, a PlayStati.on, or
an iPhone. But this crisis has already
created a culture. & we self-isolate, the
Internet has become host to an ambi-
ent, crowd.sourced documentary of the
time, and video is the anxious medium
of social life. On lnstagram, a friend
has shared communiqu.Cs from a young
doctor telling New Yorkers what to do
if they experience shortness of breath.
The illustrator Wendy MacNaughton
begins her daily drawing classes on In-
stagram Live by stretching to Madness's
"Our House"; John Legend streamed
a live concert from his living room with
his wife, Chrissy Teigen, perched on
the piano. The migration of social ac-
tivities to the Internet predates our cur-
rent emergency by decades, but live
streaming, which once seemed to pres-
age the dissolution of human intimacy,
now looks like its preservation.
I've also watched many hours of ac-
tual. TY. Days before the general pub-
lic seemed to understand how social dis-
tancing could help "Hatten the curve,"
shows made a display of rcsponsibk: cit-
izenship. The sudden absence of live
in-studio audiences was pleasingly ab-
surd. "Wdoome to 'The View'!"Whoopi
Goldberg shouted, eight times, to no
one, during a live taping. Subbing for
Jimmy Kimmel, Pete Buttigieg was a
shy but game entertainer-politician,
66 THE NEY~ MARCH 30, 2020delivering an opening monologue to
his husband, Chasten, and a handful of
"Kimmer team members. He roasted the
Trumps, implored vigilance in the &cc
of the pandemic, and interviewed Pat-
rick Stewart, sharing a photo of himself
as a child in a Sta.rfleet uniform. But, as
the week went on, resilience seemed to
waver.Joy Behar, who is seventy-seven,
announced that she would stop coming
to tapings of"The View."
I am not the fust person to find that
the most innocuous aspects of TV
watching now induce a rdlcxive unease.
On "American Ido~" the hosts' displays
of consolation toward eliminated con-
testants, conveyed through the rubbing
of the singers' shoulders, made me ner-
vous. Earlier this month, watclllng "The
Bachelor," I had been annoyed by Pe-
ter's disrespect of Hannah Ann; two
weeks ago, I couldn't stand the inces-
sant stroking of faces. Commercials ad-
vertising &st food are otgiastic displays
of careless skin contact. In the U.K.,
KFC's "finger-lickin' good" ads have
been pulled.0
n Sunday, after the Diocese of
Brooklyn annoWlced the suspen-
sion ofMass,I watched a service streamed
from the St. James Cathedral Basilica,
on the New Evangelization Television
channel. At any other time, the empty
pews would have offered further proof
of the institution's decline. Later that
day, driving up Flatbush Avenue for
last-minute provisions, I watched a
woman run across the street to a store-
front black church, where members of
the congregation were dancing and
sweating in close quarters. In the eve-
ning, the Democratic Presidential de-
bate fClt like a consummation of the in-
evitable. The podiums were six feet apart;
Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders greeted
each other with an elbow bump. After
Sanders challenged Biden on his health-
care policy, Biden said that he didn't
want to get into a "back-and-forth, in
terms of our politics," and exploited a
hWlger fut stirring rhetoric. "We are at
war with a virus,"he said.
On March uth, "The Late Show
with Stephen Colbert" annOWlced that
it would stop production altogether.
Four days later, when New York State
banned gatherings of more than fifty
people, Colbert surprised viewers witha monologue reamled in his bathtub.
Immersed in bubbles, fully suited, he
provided his signature mix of acid cri-
tique and avuncular reassurance. The
segment-which was followed by a
rerun-looked like it was filmed with
an iPhone. "Hey, everybody! Hi!" Col-
bert said. "Welcome to my bathroom."
These days, theatrics make public
:figures seem untrustworthy; the real he-
roes have no need fut laurels. At press
oonferences, govanors and mayors have
mostly abandoned speechifying in f.avor
of :8.at statements. Andrew Cuomo, the
guvernor ofNcw York, in a brown leather
jacket and a white baseball cap, is a steady-
ing figure. But even President Trump
has dialled down the bombast. Sweat-
ing and breathing heavily as he pro-
nounced from the Oval Office that
America would beat the coronavirus, he
appeared to represent the ailing global
gerontocracy. "I will always put the well-
being of America first," he said earlier
this month. Last week, he seemed to
have ceded the role of steward to An-
thony Fauci, the director of the National
Institute of Allergy and Infectious Dis-
eases. Fauci has appeared on SWldaytalk
shows and CNN panels, and is now a
comforting presence at Trump pressers,
standing to the side, taking questions
from reporters after Trump and Mike
Pence rattle off their false promises. The
President claimed that the pandemic was
under "tremendous control,.; on CNN's
"State of the Union," Fauci straightfor-
wardly contradicted him. "People some-
times think that you're overreacting,"
Fauci said. "I like it when people are
thinking I'm overreacting, because that
means we're doing it just right."
A small, seventy-nine-year-old pub-
lic servantwho barely clears the lectern,
Fauci has a distaste for drama, and em-
anates authority. The President, who
initially told the public that the coro-
navirus would go away, "like a miracle,"
seemed, last Tuesday, temporarily cow00
by Fauci's preience.The next day, Trump
told the reporter YamicheAlcindo.r that
it was correct to call the coronavirus
"kung flu" and the "Chinese virus. "The
racism is tactical, a diversion from the
Administration's failures. More embar-
rassingly, it is also a way of shifting at-
tention from Fauci, who, Trump was
forced to concede, had become "a major
television star."•