Car UK May 2019

148

Specialist

Morgan insurance

0333 043 3911

rhspecialistinsurance.co.uk

2001 Morgan Aero 8.

Value £41,000.

Mileage 3,000 per annum.

SDP use. Kept garaged at EX23.

Annual comprehensive cover premium.

£356.20 + IPT. £250 excess applies.

44 year old accountant, clean licence.

CARMAGAZINE.CO.UK | MAY 2019

CX-3 ★★★★★

> Late arrival to compact crossover party is worth

a look thanks to smart cabin and crisp drive. Pity

about the firm ride > VERDICT Pricey, but better

than most rivals and well equipped

CX-5 ★★★★★

> How an SUV should drive. Better than ever, and

yet it’s still unfairly ignored in favour of inferior

rivals > VERDICT It’s the closest you’ll ever get to a

five-seat MX-5

MX-5 ★★★★★

> Shorter than the ’89 original, and in real terms

half the price. 1.5 sweet but a little slow; 158bhp 2.0

quicker but charismatically challenged

> VERDICT Brilliantly uncomplicated budget sports

car. Dink the GTI for this

MX-5 RF ★★★★★

> When a folding fabric roof above your head is

just too common to contemplate, pay more for the

heavier and more complicated RF and never fold

the bloody roof down anyway > VERDICT Right car

in the wrong spec

MERCEDES

A-CLASS ★★★★★

> Sharp looks and an interior swish enough to put It’s only taken Merc four attempts to get right.

higher-class cars to shame – even if most of the

best kit is optional. Dynamically still a bit slushy

> VERDICT Finally, a compact hatch worthy of

being called a Merc

A45 AMG ★★★★★

REPLACED

SOON

> Mad turbo four-pot makes 367bhp

and 350lb ft. Goes like a banker who

knows the game is up > VERDICT

Option the Dynamic Plus pack with LSD as well

B-CLASS ★★★★★

> Mercedes has resisted the temptation to turn

sort-of MPV into sort-of SUV. Hatchback handling

and fancy interior. Oddly short of useful cubbies,

though > VERDICT Like an A-Class, but taller. Who

knew?

C-CLASS SALOON/ESTATE ★★★★★

> Mini-S-Class styling and almost all the same

cutting-edge on-board technology > VERDICT

BMW is still better to drive, but if you want a

relaxing techno cocoon, this is it

C-CLASS COUPE ★★★★★

> Sexpot C-Class 10cm longer and available with air

suspension. Still tight in the back for those with legs

> VERDICT Much more of an event than the BMW

4-series, but the latest Audi A5 is right back in the

game; a nice problem

C63 AMG ★★★★★

> Madder than ever with bi-turbo 4.0 V8; coupe

gets unique 12-link rear suspension for sharper

responses > VERDICT Mega traction and one of

the best turbo engines ever

E-CLASS SALOON/ESTATE ★★★★★

> It may look like a fat C-Class but this techno

tour-de-force thinks it can drive better than you.

Exceptional interior out-luxes all comers

> VERDICT New four-cylinder diesel is so smooth it

churns motorway miles into butter

E-CLASS COUPE ★★★★★

> Swish, clever and satisfyingly capable, as long

as there’s six cylinders up front. Like coupes used

to be before everyone decided they needed to be

‘Ring-meisters > VERDICT Middle age has never

been so appealing

AMG E63 ★★★★★

> Only AMG would offer the E63 with an

all-wheel-drive system that you can switch off

in Drift Mode (on the S version). Which is exactly

why you should buy one, and possibly open an

account at Kwik Fit at the same time > VERDICT Go

S or go home

CLS ★★★★★

> Comfy four-door coupe has great interior and

loads of tech, although it can’t match the original for

visual drama. AMG 53 is punchy

> VERDICT Slick

S-CLASS ★★★★★

BEST IN

CLASS

> Enormously technically

accomplished, with camera-guided

ride quality and stacks of safety kit

> VERDICT Makes 7-series and A8 seem like

under-specified toys. Captains of industry should

insist on it

S-CLASS COUPE/CABRIOLET

★★★★★

> Over five metres of barking mad indulgence;

Coupe carries it off like Errol Flynn on a bender

> VERDICT Howard Hughes would approve, but he

went crazy in the end

S63/S65 AMG ★★★★★

> Twin-turbo 577bhp V8 and 621bhp V12 S-Class

variants, because being richer than the world isn’t

enough and you need to out-drag it, too

> VERDICT S63 V8 is bonkers, S65 V12 utterly

certifiable. Does your chauffeur deserve it?

GLA ★★★★★

> Confused A-Class on stilts with lifestyle

pretensions and a surplus of interior vents. GLA45

AMG is entertaining but unnecessary

> VERDICT An A-Class for the bewildered

GLC ★★★★★

> GLK replacement project, now available in right-

hand drive. Sounds like you shouldn’t care, but the

interior might just make you moist

> VERDICT Rivals are cheaper and better to drive

but GLC makes you feel special inside

G-CLASS ★★★★★

> Turns out you can teach an old dog new tricks,

so long as you completely overhaul its entire

personality and physical structure. W464 still OTT

but now isn’t a pig to drive or sit in > VERDICT A

dinosaur that has evolved to avoid extinction

GLE ★★★★★

> Seven-seat SUV dials up the refinement and

gadgets. Active air springs can make it tilt like a

Pendolino at speed or hop like a baller’s low-rider

> VERDICT No longer an also-ran plush-UV

GLS ★★★★★

> Luxo-monster seven-seater lacks Range Rover

panache but it’s comfy and refined, and the

infotainment doesn’t come from Poundland

> VERDICT A brilliant bus

SLC ★★★★★

> Buy the SLC43 AMG and it’s like an uglier but

cheaper F-Type with a nicer interior. Buy any other

SLC and you’ve lost your mind > VERDICT Come

back 718 Boxster, all is forgiven

SL ★★★★★

> The plastic surgeon was worth every penny.

Turning up the sporty makes the most of the super-

stiff structure, too > VERDICT Think twice about

that Ferrari California. No, seriously

AMG GT ★★★★★

> GT C is the very tasty sweet spot, GT R is track-

bred lunatic and ‘Ring fast-lapper. Whichever you

MAZDA > NISSAN

SHOGUN ★★★★★

> Old-school workhorse if your workplace is

covered in mud, oil or bomb craters. Big, noisy

diesel, chunky underpinnings and reliable, with

hose-down cabin > VERDICT If you don’t think you

need this car, you don’t need this car

OUTLANDER ★★★★★

> Midlife overhaul brings sleeker looks and

lifts cabin ambience by miles. Diesel still a bit

of a tractor but PHEV comfy and refined

> VERDICT The UK’s best-selling plug-in hybrid

MORGAN

3-WHEELER ★★★★★

> As comfortable as riding over Niagara Falls in a

barrel and equally sane. Not as quick as it feels, but

quick enough for a three-wheeler on bike tyres

> VERDICT Brilliant Caterham alternative without

the macho trackday posturing

AERO ★★★★★

> Droptop was first of the new-era Morgans and

goes it alone since Aero Supersports, Coupe and

Squiffy Perkins bought it at the Somme

> VERDICT Two worlds collide. And with 367bhp in

the front they may not be the only ones doing some

colliding

PLUS 4/FOUR FOUR/ROADSTER

★★★★★

> Entry-level Mog still with ‘traditional’ ash frame

and ‘traditional’ (ie awful) dynamics. Four-seat 4/4

is surprise eco champ: 44mpg > VERDICT Cheap,

considering the extensive craftsmanship, even at

£33k, but if you want an old car, buy an old car

PLUS 8 ★★★★★

> Don’t be fooled by tally-ho styling, 8 is built on

‘modern’ bonded and riveted Aero chassis. Fidgety

like a child with worms > VERDICT Classic Morgan

style, modern BMW V8 poke, manners like a five-

term borstal veteran

NISSAN

MICRA ★★★★★

> So much better than the old car, the

current Micra is on Wikipedia right now

deleting all mention of its predecessor. Proves

that a car designed by Europeans will appeal to

Europeans > VERDICT Bigger and better, although

not all versions are equally good

JUKE ★★★★★

> Mould-breaking compact crossover; you think

it would look like that if the mould hadn’t broken?

Cheap interior and so-so dynamics belie the

hype > VERDICT Does it still count as ‘different’ if

everybody’s got one?

LEAF ★★★★★

> promises better range, and single-pedal driving. Less gawky than pioneering first-gen Leaf, and

Shame about the dull interior > VERDICT Version

2.0 of people’s EV now far more... normal

QASHQAI ★★★★★

> Crossover for the masses gets more luxury and

a facelift > VERDICT It’s no Volvo XC but still has

huge family appeal

X-TRAIL ★★★★★

> Used to be a rough, tough off-roader designed on

an Etch-a-Sketch. Now it’s a Qashqai put through

a photocopier at +10% > VERDICT Still not exciting,

but selling a lot better

GT-R ★★★★★

> Now with a slightly thicker veneer of luxury (and

pick, it’s blessed with a 4.0-litre twin-turbo V8 and

jaw-dropping looks > VERDICT Got muscle, maybe

lacks finesse

AMG GT 4-DOOR ★★★★★

> Yes, it looks like a steroidal CLS and, yes, it’s a

tried-and-tested formula under the skin, but boy

does it work. Forget the E63 S, because this is

arguably AMG’s M5 rival. Pricey, mind > VERDICT

Ignore the confusing name, this thing’s good

MG

MG 3 ★★★★★

> Tough-looking, spacious supermini has handling

that lives up to the promise of that once-British

badge. As does the woeful build, crap engine and

concrete ride > VERDICT The Chinese are coming!

But so far they’ve only got to Tajikistan

GS ★★★★★

> Spacious, duck-faced SUV hamstrung by coarse

1.5 turbo petrol, shonky gearboxes and shoddy

interior. Actually handles okay, if you can hack the

firm ride > VERDICT Cheap, but not sufficiently so.

Dacia will sleep well tonight

ZS ★★★★★

> Looks a lot like a Chinese knock-off of a Mazda

CX-3 and has the knock-off driving dynamics, build

quality and price to match > VERDICT Stone dead

last in a very competitive sector, would still be last

in easier company

MINI

HATCH/CONVERTIBLE ★★★★★

> Bigger and less charming, but comes with choice

of smooth and peppy engines, while ride has

improved without ruining handling. Britpop rear

lights a thorny issue for some > VERDICT Better

than ever to own, even if you love it slightly less

COOPER S/JCW ★★★★★

> BMW 2.0-litre four-pot-powered 228bhp JCW

most powerful Mini ever. Terrific fun, if a tad

synthetic > VERDICT Beware the options list

CLUBMAN ★★★★★

> Replace circus-freakery of old one with full

complement of portals, add longer wheelbase,

bigger boot; now bake > VERDICT Loaf-alike maxi-

Mini freshness, the grown-ups’ choice

COUNTRYMAN/PACEMAN ★★★★★

> A Mini SUV that drives like the hatch. Spacious,

solid inside and just funky enough, but expensive

> VERDICT A respectable family car now, rather

than just a chubby brand extension

MITSUBISHI

MIRAGE ★★★★★

> Facelift can’t hide the Mirage’s catastrophic lack

of style or charm. As well suited to the small-car

segment as a Sopwith Camel is to executive short-

haul flights > VERDICT Want your kids to stay off

the roads? Buy them one

ASX ★★★★★

> Box-ticking small SUV feels like it was designed

on a spreadsheet. At least it’s cheap and well kitted

> VERDICT Best bought on the internet

ECLIPSE CROSS ★★★★★

> Last of the old Mitsubishis or first of the new

Renault-Nissan ones? Off-road ability says former,

but cushy ride and renewed interior quality says

latter > VERDICT Petrol-CVT combo sounds wrong

but it’s civilised and looks sharp