78 may 2019 | subscribe to car for just £2.60 a month! http://www.greatmagazines.co.uk
3-series vs the worldOf the eight hopefuls, three make it to the shortlist: BMW 320d M Sport,
Peugeot 508 GT and Alfa Giulia Veloce.
Not long ago, Peugeot was floundering, but in the last few years it’s
undergone a product-led renaissance, and the 508 continues that momen-
tum. It is the best like-for-like alternative to the 3-series. The suave exterior
and interior design channels French intellectual cool to make this a stylish,
knowingly different choice, and you’ll find the 508 similarly practical to a
3-series too – if with less rear legroom but a larger boot. Many buyers will
prefer that it focuses more towards comfort and refinement too, and yet it
can still flow and entertain over a great road. That our GT-spec model is
substantially cheaper than the 320d and requires almost no extra spend is
another reason to break the German habit.
Alfa Romeo has undergone a similarly promising transformation in
recent years, one spearheaded by the Giulia, its first rear-wheel-drive model
since 75 production ended in 1992. It is not a rounded BMW substitute like
the Peugeot, most notably in its tighter rear accommodation, but also some
interior quality. What the Giulia does so well is tackle the 3-series’ core
attributes of design desirability and driving dynamics head-on. Design,
well, you decide, but I’d say the Alfa is the more beautiful car. The GiuliaVeloce also rides with more fluency and has the nerve to go toe-to-toe with
the 3-series on dynamics then comes out on top. In Veloce spec with its 2.0-
litre turbo petrol engine, it delivers both a lightness of touch and a level of
driver engagement no matter your commitment that makes every drive a
special occasion. If it’s all about the drive, the Giulia is your choice.
Perhaps predictably, the BMW 320d proves that it’s the Jack of all trades
that manages to be pretty excellent at them all. Its interior is a masterclass
in design desirability and driver-centric layout, and the G20’s growth spurt
means even large adults aren’t cramped in the back. The latest iDrive
infotainment is also great bounds ahead of the opposition, in terms of its
glossy hardware and graphics, and in the flexibility of interaction it allows.
Everything feels a bit frustrating after this.
In 320d M Sport xDrive trim, the BMW also drives extremely well, with
a chassis that can squeeze every last drop of performance from the 2.0-litre
turbodiesel and entertain in the process. Personally, I’d drop the xDrive as
an unnecessary expense in a car with pretty modest performance, but there
is no other car tested here able to maintain such a high batting average. For
that reason, the BMW takes overall honours today, but don’t overlook the
Peugeot and Alfa.Time to break the BMW habit?the verdictAlfa top for sheer
driving pleasure,
Peugeot for elan, but
3-series is the one
you want to live with