a2 eZ re the washington post.monday, april 6 , 2020
happening today
For the latest updates all day, visit washingtonpost.com.
download the
Washington post app
stay informed with award-winning
national and international news,
Plus complete local news
coverage of the d.c. metro area.
scan top headlines for must-read
stories. get fresh perspectives on
the world from Post bloggers.
save articles for offline reading in
My Post. Fr ee to download on the
app store and Play store,
subscribers enjoy unlimited
access.
KLMNO
neWspaper deLiVery
For home delivery comments
or concerns contact us at
washingtonpost.com/subscriberservices or
send us an email at
[email protected] or call
202-334-6100 or 800-477-
to suBscriBe
800-753-Post (7678)
to adVertise
washingtonpost.com/mediakit
classified: 202-334-
display: 202-334-
Main phone nuMBer
202-334-
to reach the neWsrooM
Metro: 202-334-7300;
[email protected]
national: 202-334-7410;
[email protected]
Business: 202-334-7320;
[email protected]
sports: 202-334-7350;
[email protected]
reader advocate: 202-334-7582;
[email protected]
to reach the opinion pages
letters to the editor:
[email protected] or call
202-334-
opinion:
[email protected]
Published daily (issn 0190-8286).
PostMaster: send address changes to
the Washington Post, 1301 K st. nW, Washington,
d.c. 20071.
Periodicals postage paid in Washington, d.c., and
additional mailing office.
Wisconsin
Two men arrested in
fatal shooting of couple
A University of Wisconsin
physician and her husband,
whose bodies were found at the
school’s arboretum near the
Madison campus, were shot to
death, and a second suspect in
the killings has been arrested,
police said.
Police said Saturday that they
arrested Ali’jah Larrue, 18, on
Friday night. Larrue was booked
into jail on two counts of party
to the crime of first-degree
intentional homicide.
UW police spokesman Marc
Lovicott said Sunday that Larrue
is an acquaintance of the other
suspect, Khari Sanford, 18, who
was arrested earlier Friday and
booked on the same charges.
“We are confident these are
the two guys,” Lovicott told the
Associated Press, although the
investigation remains active.
A jogger found the bodies of
Beth Potter, 52, and her
husband, Robin Carre, 57, on
Tuesday in a ditch at the
university’s arboretum, a
popular research and
recreational area.
Lovicott said that the couple
had been shot at the arboretum
sometime overnight before their
bodies were found, but that
police were not ready to discuss
a motive. Police have said the
couple was targeted and that
Sanford was known to the
victims’ family.
The men have not been
formally charged but are
expected to make their initial
court appearances early this
week, Lovicott said.
— Associated Press
georgia
Outreach group to be
led by MLK’s daughter
One of the daughters of the
Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. will
help lead a new outreach
committee in Georgia as the
state copes with the novel
coronavirus, Gov. Brian Kemp
(R) said Sunday.
M ore than a dozen other
members, including business
and nonprofit leaders, make up
the committee.
“Comprised of talented
individuals from the public and
private sectors, I am confident
this committee will ensure that
our state remains prepared in
the fight against COVID-19,” t he
Republican governor said in a
statement on Sunday.
— Associated Press
West Virginia
Mine blast observance
canceled due to virus
A planned public gathering
was shelved on the 10th
anniversary of the worst U.S.
mining disaster in decades.
Heartfelt speeches gave way
Sunday to silent remembrances
and individual prayers for the
29 men who died at the Upper
Big Branch mine in West
Virginia.
The coronavirus pandemic
prompted the decision weeks
ago to cancel the event. Instead,
mourners were allowed to lay
wreaths from dusk to dawn at a
memorial site in Whitesville, not
far from the mine.
To mmy Davis, who was
working at the mine on April 5,
2010, said he was going
regardless. He lost a son, brother
and a nephew.
“I’ll be there to pay my
respects and do my
remembering and set out my
flowers as I usually do,” s aid
Davis, now retired. “ I’m doing
my normal thing. I don’t change
nothing up regardless of what’s
going on in the world around
us.”
Another Upper Big Branch
retiree, Stanley Stewart, said he
agreed with the decision to
cancel the event. He has skipped
visiting the memorial every year
in favor of personal reflections at
home. He and his wife planned
to observe a moment of silence
at 3:02 p.m., the time of the
explosion, Stewart said.
— Associated Press
digest
John hart/Wisconsin state Journal/associated Press
Vehicles from the Madison Police Department, the Dane County
Sheriff's Office and the University of Wisconsin Police Department
are stationed outside the arboretum in Madison, Wis., as law
enforcement personnel investigate a double homicide on March 31.
the Week ahead
tuesday
the Wisconsin legislature
considers all-mail primary voting.
Wednesday
the Federal reserve’s Federal
open Market committee releases
minutes of its March 15 meeting.
thursday
Jobless claims for the week
ended april 4 may total 5 million.
producer prices for March are
expected to fall by 0.3 percent.
Friday
consumer prices for March are
expected to rise 0.3 percent.
BY KARIN BRULLIARD
The new coronavirus, which
has traversed the globe to infect
more than 1 million people, began
like so many pandemics and out-
breaks before: i nside an animal.
The virus’s original host was
almost certainly a bat, as was the
case with Ebola, SARS, MERS and
lesser-known viruses such as
Nipah and Marburg. HIV migrat-
ed to humans m ore than a century
ago from a chimpanzee. Influenza
A has jumped from wild birds to
pigs to people. Rodents spread
Lassa fever in West A frica.
But the problem is not the ani-
mals, according to scientists who
study the zoonotic diseases that
pass between animals and hu-
mans. I t’s us.
Wild animals have always had
viruses coursing through their
bodies. But a global wildlife trade
worth billions of dollars, agricul-
tural intensification, deforesta-
tion and urbanization are bring-
ing people closer to animals, giv-
ing their viruses more of what they
need to infect us: opportunity.
Most fail. Some succeed on small
scales. Very few — like SARS-
CoV-2 — triumph, aided by a su-
premely interconnected human
population that can transport a
pathogen around the world on a
jet in mere hours.
As the world scrambles to cope
with an unprecedented public
health and economic crisis, many
disease researchers say the coro-
navirus pandemic must be taken
as a deadly warning. That means
thinking of animals as partners
whose health and habitats should
be protected to stave off the next
global outbreak.
“Pandemics as a whole are in-
creasing in frequency,” said Peter
Daszak, a disease ecologist who is
president of EcoHealth Alliance, a
public health organization that
studies emerging diseases. “It’s not
a random act of God. It’s c aused b y
what we do to the environment.
We need to start connecting that
chain and say we need to do these
things in a less r isky way.”
Some 70 percent of emerging
infectious diseases in humans are
of zoonotic origin, scientists say,
and nearly 1 .7 m illion u ndiscovered
viruses may exist in wildlife. Many
researchers are searching for the
ones that could cause the next ani-
mal-to-human spillover. The likeli-
est hot spots have three things in
common, Daszak said: lots of peo-
ple, diverse plants and animals,
and rapid environmental changes.
They also are home to many of
the likeliest zoonotic disease
hosts: rodents and bats. About
half of mammal species are ro-
dents, and about a quarter are
bats. But bats make up about 50
percent of mammals in the most
biodiverse tropical regions, and
while t hey are valuable pollinators
and pest eaters, they are also as-
tounding virus vessels. Bats have a
superhero-like immune system
th at a llows them t o become “reser-
voirs to many pathogens that do
not impact them but can have a
tremendous impact on us if
they’re able to make the jump,”
said Thomas Gillespie, a disease
ecologist at E mory University.
Increasingly, w e make the j ump
easier.
Late last year, a horseshoe bat
coronavirus is thought to have
leaped in China, where commerce
in exotic animals is d riven by luxu-
ry tastes in game and demand for
parts u sed f or medicinal purposes.
At a “wet market” in Wuhan
linked to an early cluster of coro-
navirus cases, at least one store
sold creatures including wolf c ubs
and masked palm civets for con-
sumption. Such markets, experts
say, feature stressed and ill ani-
mals stacked in cages, bodily flu-
ids sprinkling down, as well as
butchering — prime conditions
for v iral spillover.
Although horseshoe bats are
hunted and eaten in China, how
the s uspected bat virus first infect-
ed people will not be easily de-
duced. An early cluster of cases
was traced to the sprawling ani-
mal market, but it was closed and
sanitized b efore researchers could
track down what animal might
have been implicated. And it was
probably not the location of the
spillover itself, which could have
happened weeks earlier, possibly
in November. Some of the first
cases had no connection to the
animal market.
Because the new virus isn’t
identical to any known bat virus,
somewhere between the bat and
human beings, the virus mutated
in at least one intermediary, per-
haps the endangered pangolin, a
mammal heavily trafficked for its
scales.
The 2003 SARS outbreak,
which eventually was linked to
horseshoe bats by scientists who
spelunked through slippery caves
lined with bat guano, was also
traced to wild animal markets.
Scientists think that coronavirus
jumped from b ats to masked palm
civets — catlike mammals sold for
meat — to humans.
“One of the key interfaces for
these spillover events to occur are
markets and the international
trade of wildlife,” Chris Walzer,
executive director for the Wildlife
Conservation Society’s global
health program, told reporters on
Thursday.
In Africa, dwindling popula-
tions of large mammals means
game is increasingly from smaller
species, including rodents and
bats, said Fabian Leendertz, a vet-
erinarian who studies zoonotic
diseases at the Robert Koch Insti-
tute in Berlin. While some is con-
sumed for subsistence or tradi-
tional purposes, exotic meat sales
are also a “huge economy” in the
fast-growing megacities, Leen-
dertz said.
“That’s something I would stop
first,” he said. “The risk is not
because the meat travels... but it
results i n higher hunting pressure
and higher contact rate for those
who go hunting and those who
take i t apart.”
The international trade in exot-
ic pets such as reptiles and fish is
also a concern, because the ani-
mals are rarely tested for patho-
gens that could sicken humans,
Daszak said. So are large “factory”
farms packed with animals,
Gillespie said.
“When I think about what’s the
primary risk f actor, it’s i nfluenza A
that’s linked to pig and chicken
production,” he said.
But harvesting and raising ani-
mals are not the only venues for
spillover. Humans increasingly
share space with wildlife and alter
it in perilous ways, researchers
say.
Lyme disease, caused by a bac-
teria, spreads more easily in the
eastern United States because
fragmented forests have fewer
predators, such as foxes and opos-
sums, that eat mice that host
Lyme-spreading ticks, studies
have found. Building leads to a
closer coexistence with some wild
animals, including bats, Leen-
dertz said.
Scientists point to the 1998
emergence in Malaysia of Nipah
virus, which has killed hundreds
of people in several outbreaks in
Asia, as a vivid example of spill-
over fueled by environmental
change and agricultural intensifi-
cation. The clearing of rainforests
for palm oil and lumber and live-
stock displaced fruit bats, some of
which ended up on new pig farms
where m ango and o ther f ruit trees
also grew, they say. Bats “drop
more than they eat,” Gillespie said,
and their saliva and feces infected
the pigs. Pigs sickened farmwork-
ers a nd others in t he industry.
“Wherever we’re creating novel
interfaces, this is likely a risk that
we need to be seriously consider-
ing,” he said. “It’s forcing wildlife
to look for new food sources. It’s
forcing them to change their be-
havior in ways that puts them in a
better position to transfer the
pathogen to u s.”
As Earth’s human population
hurtles toward 8 billion, no one
thinks human-animal interaction
is going to decrease. The key is
reducing the risk of a devastating
spillover, scientists say — and not
by killing bats. But they acknowl-
edge that cultural and economic
pressures make change d ifficult.
The Wildlife Conservation Soci-
ety and other groups have called
on countries to prohibit the trade
in wild animals for food and close
wet markets. Anthony S. Fauci, the
nation’s top infectious-diseases
expert and the face of the U.S.
response to the pandemic, said
Friday that the world community
should pressure China and other
nations that host such markets to
shut them down
“It just boggles my mind how,
when we have so many diseases
that emanate out of that unusual
human-animal interface, that we
don’t j ust shut it down,” Fauci told
Fox News’s “Fox & Friends.”
China, which briefly stopped
the trade in civets after the SARS
outbreak, announced in January a
ban on the transport and sale of
wild animals, but only until the
coronavirus epidemic is eliminat-
ed. Permanent legislation is need-
ed, s aid Aili Kang, executive direc-
tor o f WCS’s Asia p rogram.
Not everyone agrees. Bans
could cause markets to move un-
derground, some say. Daszak not-
ed that Westerners also eat wild
animals — seafood and deer, for
example. Instead, he said, trade
should be regulated and the ani-
mals rigorously tested for patho-
gens.
Stronger surveillance f or illness
in wild a nimals — regarding them
as “sentinels” — is needed, Leen-
dertz said. So i s a widespread real-
ization that building in wild habi-
tats can fuel public health crises,
Gillespie said.
Many researchers say the coro-
navirus pandemic underscores
the need for a more holistic “one
health” a pproach, which v iews hu-
man, animal and environmental
health as interconnected.
“There needs to be a cultural
shift from a community level up
about how we treat animals, our
understanding o f the dangers and
biosecurity risks that we’re expos-
ing ourselves to,” s aid Kate Jones,
chair of ecology and biodiversity
at University College London.
“That means leaving ecosystems
intact, not destroying them. It
means thinking in a more long-
term way.”
[email protected]
Joel achenbach, Paulina Firozi and
William Wan contributed to this report.
Animals have always carried dangerous pathogens. Society has sped their spread.
Bonnie Jo Mount/the Washington Post
Bats gather in the Bat Cave in Queen Elizabeth National Park in Uganda in 2 018. Bats carry pathogens
that can be dangerous to humans and were probably the original host of the novel coronavirus.
9:30 a.m. | the supreme court issues orders. For developments, visit
washingtonpost.com/national.
11 a.m. | Washington capitals coach todd reirden holds a conference
call with reporters to discuss the state of the hockey team. Visit
postsports.com for details.
2 p.m. | Virginia gov. ralph northam (d) holds a briefing on his state’s
response to the novel coronavirus. For developments, visit
washingtonpost.com/local.
correction
the Washington Post is committed to
correcting errors that appear in the
newspaper. those interested in
contacting the paper for that purpose
can:
e-mail: [email protected].
call: 2 02-334-6000, and ask to be
connected to the desk involved —
national, Foreign, Metro, style, sports,
Business or any of the weekly sections.
comments can be directed to the
Post’s reader advocate, who can be
reached at 202-334-7582 or
[email protected].
Security Services
Site Security for
Open & Temporarily Closed Businesses
Estates • Churches • Schools
Retail • Commercial • Banks
Construction & Development • Hospitals
Secure Executive Transport
Investigation Services
Criminal Defense Investigations
Background Checks
Due Diligence
Surveillance • Process Service
Threat Assessments
http://www.sentinel-intg.com
Armed & Unarmed Uniform Security
Private Investigations
(800) 683-5 358
Call Sentinel today for a consultation.
Licensed in Virginia — DCJS# 11-
Benefiting
Make-A-Wish
®
Mid-Atlantic
WheelsForWishes.org Call:(202)644-
* Car Donation Foundation d/b/a Wheels For Wishes.To learn more about our programs or financial information,
call (213) 948-2000 or visit http://www.wheelsforwishes.org.
Your Car Donations Matter
NOW More Than Ever!
Wheels For Wishes
We’re still
accepting
donations and
pick ups
- 100%Tax Deductible
- MinimalTo No Human Contact
- FreeVehicle Pick Up ANYWHERE
- We Accept MostVehicles Running or Not