A2| Saturday/Sunday, March 21 - 22, 2020 **** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
marriage licenses. They walked
in the minute the government
offices opened and hope to go
through with a small ceremony
next month.
Raj Machhar and Rachna
Randhawa spent the last year
planning a wedding with 460
people that was set for this
weekend at a resort in Orlando,
Fla. As the outbreak escalated,
the couple worried about family
members traveling from Seat-
tle, the U.K., Switzerland and
India. Dr. Machhar’s cousin was
on a jet bridge in Mumbai about
to board his flight last week
when an airline official told him
he would not be able to re-enter
India until mid-April at the ear-
liest. The cousin went home.
When it became clear their
ophonist draws laughs by play-
ing through a hole in his surgi-
cal mask.
Even if a big party is off, a
quickie wedding is no guaran-
tee either. Krista Evans, 30, an
information technology worker
and nurse at a San Francisco
hospital, did a lot of work for
her wedding herself, including
using the Japanese Shibori
technique to tie-dye runners for
the tables. She still wanted to
get married on April 4, but
learned that City Hall in San
Francisco was no longer per-
forming ceremonies.
So she and her fiancé, James
Longinotti, 31, rose at dawn re-
cently and drove to the clerk
recorder’s office in Santa Rosa,
Calif., that was still issuing
U.S. NEWS
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
(USPS 664-880)
(Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
(Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935) (Western
Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
Editorial and publication headquarters:
1211 Avenue of the Americas,
New York, N.Y. 10036
Published daily except Sundays and general
legal holidays. Periodicals postage paid at
New York, N.Y., and other mailing offices.
Postmaster: Send address changes to
The Wall Street Journal, 200 Burnett Rd.,
Chicopee, MA 01020.
All Advertising published in The Wall Street
Journal is subject to the applicable rate card,
copies of which are available from the
Advertising Services Department, Dow Jones &
Co. Inc., 1211 Avenue of the Americas, New
York, N.Y. 10036. The Journal reserves the right
not to accept an advertiser’s order. Only
publication of an advertisement shall constitute
final acceptance of the advertiser’s order.
Letters to the Editor:
Fax: 212-416-2891; email: [email protected]
Need assistance with your subscription?
By web: customercenter.wsj.com;
By email: [email protected]
By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL
(1-800-568-7625)
Reprints & licensing:
By email: [email protected];
By phone: 1-800-843-
WSJ back issues and framed pages:
wsjshop.com
Our newspapers are 100% sourced from
sustainably certified mills.
GOTATIPFORUS?
SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS
U.S. WATCH
SPECIAL DELIVERY: A postal carrier made rounds Friday near Galloway, Ohio. Thousands were without power after storms hit the state.
ERIC ALBRECHT/THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH/ASSOCIATED PRESS
CORRECTIONS
AMPLIFICATIONS
Readers can alert The Wall Street
Journal to any errors in news
articles by emailing
[email protected] by calling
888-410-2667.
A similar phenomenon has
been observed in the U.S.
California’s bag ban, ap-
proved in 2016, led to the
elimination of 40 million
pounds of single-use plastic
bags. But the savings were
offset by a 12-million-pound
increase in trash-bag pur-
chases.
Sales of small, medium
and tall trash bags increased
by 120%, 64% and 6%, re-
spectively, according to an
economist at the University
of Sydney who studied the
effect of the regulation.
While consumers have
Paper or
plastic?
This month,
New York
joined the list
of places that
have banned single-use plas-
tic shopping bags out of con-
cern for the environment.
But the choice is more
complicated than it sounds.
Independent studies con-
ducted from 2010 through
2019 by researchers in the
U.S., the U.K., Continental
Europe, Asia and elsewhere
all concluded that single-use
plastic bags—like the ones
commonly found in grocery
stores—rank better in almost
every environmental cate-
gory than bags made of pa-
per, cotton or more durable
plastics.
All the reports agree that
the extraction and produc-
tion of raw materials re-
quired to make carrier bags
have the greatest effect on
their environmental perfor-
mance. But not all of the
studies considered the harm-
fuleffectsoflitter,aprimary
concern of environmental-
ists.
And in that category, sin-
gle-use plastic bags are the
worst.
World-wide, one trillion to
five trillion plastic bags are
used each year, according to
the United Nations. They’re
among the top 10 items that
litter beaches. And evidence
of marine mammals harmed
by the waste—including
dead whales engorged with
plastic—has helped generate
support for bans on the dis-
posable carriers.
But bag bans have led to
some unexpected conse-
quences.
E
vidence suggests that
consumers may not
employ reusable bags
often enough to benefit the
environment, and doing
away with single-use bags
has caused some to purchase
heavier bags for secondary
tasks they previously re-
served for the ones that
were banned.
“A lot of single-use bags
are used to dispose of rubbish
in the kitchen,” said Simon
Aumônier, whose consulting
firm Environmental Resources
Management analyzed differ-
ent types of carrier bags for
the Environment Agency for
England and Wales. “As they
are no longer available, you
see an increase in the number
of dedicated rubbish bags
bought instead. Is that, over-
all, a good outcome or a less
good outcome?”
ing Americans not to gather
with more than 10 people at a
time. Many couples are spend-
ing their wedding days haggling
for refunds, begging for credits
or eating pizza in their sweat-
pants.
Katie Monnin, who post-
poned her wedding ceremony at
a New Zealand winery next
week, has spent the last few
days boxing up wedding sup-
plies at home in Las Vegas, stor-
ing her custom-made shoes and
the groom’s suit with the date of
their intended ceremony, March
24, stitched into the lining.
“I feel like I’m packing up an
old boyfriend’s stuff,” she says.
To console herself, she and fi-
ancé Corey Loomis are getting a
puppy—“a ‘your wedding is can-
celed, here’s an emotional sup-
port puppy,’ ” she says of the
chocolate Lab mix they decided
to name Nova. “We thought ‘Co-
rona’ was too on the nose.”
Some weddings managed to
go on, just under the lockdown
wire, or with guest lists pared
down to a few people. Across
the internet, newlyweds pose
for photos in protective gear. In
an online video, a wedding sax-
Continued from Page One
we have to get married in our
officiant’s backyard with his
two goats, that’s what we’ll do,”
Ms. Krauss said in a recent
phone call. Her future husband
could be heard in the back-
ground: “Dammit, we will get
married!”
On Sunday, when the Cen-
ters for Disease Control and
Prevention advised against so-
cial gatherings of more than 50
people, Ms. Krauss and Mr.
Hancock, 23, cut their guest list
to just family members for
their wedding. But even that
still came to 75 people, leaving
them with the prospect of
snubbing 25 relatives. They
were almost relieved the next
day when the limits on crowds
tightened to 10 people.
The couple, who cut their
$10,000 party short by two
hours, is sitting on enough craft
beer and wine for 120 people.
And they have to eat the cost of
250 fancy pretzels for the re-
ception. (They will donate the
snacks to a good cause.)
Sydney Styler and her fiancé
hope to keep their April 4 wed-
ding date. The 25-year-old real-
estate agent will reschedule a
bigger reception later, but be-
fore then, she dreams of gather-
ing two people from each side
of her wedding party and both
sets of parents in a field sur-
rounded by green hills near her
Southern California home, gov-
ernment restrictions permitting.
She is so excited to exchange
vows she doesn’t even mind the
location: a city named Corona.
wedding wouldn’t happen as
planned, Dr. Machhar created
an elaborate calendar to track
the availability of their guests
and their roughly 18 wedding
vendors. They are thinking
about a new date in October.
The Sikh and Hindu couple
will keep the wedding outfits
they bought on a trip to India
with their moms last year. They
will keep their two wedding
ceremonies, two priests, two ca-
tering companies and two bhar-
ats—the traditional entrance
for the groom—so Dr. Machhar
can arrive at the Sikh ceremony
on a horse and the Hindu cere-
mony in a sports car. One of the
few changes will be the content
of their wedding speech, which
now will contain an oblique ref-
erence to the pandemic. “We’re
just keeping things in perspec-
tive,” says Dr. Machhar, 31, an
attending physician at NYU
Langone Health in New York.
“We’re counting our blessings.”
Some couples don’t want to
give up wedding dates that they
have obsessed about for
months. Ms. Krauss and Mr.
Hancock, who will be joined by
a small wedding party while
streaming their vows and re-
ception, were determined to
keep their ceremony this Satur-
day, 3/21 or 3-2-1.
Ms. Krauss, a 23-year-old
graduate student from Win-
ston-Salem, N.C., notes that her
high-school volleyball jersey
number was three, and the
wedding is in the third week of
the third month of the year. “If
of workers rushing to claim
unemployment benefits fol-
lowed, and many states re-
ported the largest increases in
claims they have ever seen.
Ohio released updated fig-
ures on Friday morning show-
ing jobless claims rose to nearly
140,000 through Thursday, com-
pared with about 5,000 for the
same period last week. By noon
Thursday, New York’s website to
register for benefits had about
200,000 logins. The state’s La-
bor Department website is aver-
aging more than 250,000 logins
each day, a 400% increase over
the normal average.
States continued releasing
unemployment-claims figures
despite a request from the
Trump administration to re-
frain before the publication of
national weekly U.S. jobless
claims by the Labor Depart-
ment on Thursdays.
A Labor Department
spokesperson said state data
are regularly embargoed until
the national numbers are pub-
lished on Thursday mornings.
Asking states to withhold
claims reports “strikes me as
being really unusual,” said
Keith Hall, a Republican econ-
omist who served as commis-
sioner of the Bureau of Labor
Statistics under President
George W. Bush and later as
director of the Congressional
Budget Office.
An unparalleled number of
Americans filed for unemploy-
ment benefits this week as the
coronavirus pandemic shut
down businesses and left
many people without a job,
economists say.
State-level anecdotes sug-
gest applications for unem-
ployment benefits—a proxy for
layoffs—could hit more than
2 million in next Thursday’s
Labor Department report, the
largest weekly increase in job-
less claims and the highest
level on record, according to a
note from Goldman Sachs.
A panel of economists sur-
veyed by The Wall Street Jour-
nal projected that 875,000 new
jobless claims would be filed
for the week ending Saturday.
That would easily exceed the
record 695,000 claims filed in
the week ended Oct. 2, 1982.
Claims had been trending
near a 50-year low for the
past 12 months. In the week
ended March 7, 211,000 new
claims were filed. Last week,
the figure rose to 281,000.
States and localities have
been ordering businesses, such
as restaurants and bars, to
temporarily close to protect
against the spread of new cor-
onavirus, immediately hitting
parts of the economy. A wave
BYSARAHCHANEY
ANDERICMORATH
Jobless Claims Soar as
Virus Shuts Businesses
CALIFORNIA
Plácido Domingo
Quits Opera Union
Superstar Plácido Domingo re-
signed from the U.S. union that
represents opera singers and will
contribute $500,000 to sexual-
harassment eradication programs
and a fund that helps opera em-
ployees in crisis, the union said
Friday.
The development came weeks
after investigations by the Ameri-
can Guild of Musical Artists and
Los Angeles Opera found sexual-
harassment allegations against the
79-year-old tenor, to be credible.
Multiple women accused Mr. Do-
mingo of harassment and abusing
his power while he held manage-
ment positions at two companies.
—Associated Press
WISCONSIN
Man Is Charged
With Killing Student
A 53-year-old man was
charged Friday in the 2008 killing
of a University of Wisconsin-
Madison student who was found
strangled and stabbed in her
downtown apartment.
David Kahl was charged with
first-degree intentional homicide
as a party to a crime and by use
of a dangerous weapon. The
charges come 12 years after the
April 2, 2008, death of 21-year-
old Brittany Zimmermann, whose
killing rocked the city of Madison.
Mr. Kahl was in custody Friday
on a drunken-driving offense and
didn’t have an attorney in the
murder case.
—Associated Press
Coronavirus
Crashes
Weddings
Krista Evans and James Longinotti rose at dawn on a recent
morning to get a marriage license the minute the office opened.
KRISTA EVANS
been encouraged to turn to
reusable bags made of stur-
dier plastic or natural fibers
to diminish the harm caused
by single-use plastic bags,
even in the absence of a bag
ban, these durable carriers
need to be reused many
times to compensate for the
greater environmental costs
of making the bags.
A cotton bag must be
used 50 to 150 times, accord-
ing to the U.N., which con-
ducted a meta-analysis of
carrier-bag studies. A sturdy
polypropylene bag must be
used 10 to 20 times. And a
paper bag must be used four
to eight times.
If the single-use plastic
bags are reused—for shop-
ping or as bin liners—the
other bags must be used
more times to keep up.
Even well-intentioned
consumers don’t necessarily
do this.
“We see in the U.K. very,
very high rates of the pur-
chase of reusable bags,” Mr.
Aumônier said. “It suggests
people buy a lot and then
leave them at home or leave
them in the car and buy
more in the store.”
Or, if it’s an option, they
revert to single-use bags.
But Mr. Aumônier raises a
provocative question: Are
the bags to blame for envi-
ronmental hazards, or the
consumers?
“We wouldn’t have the
same degree of problems if
people responsibly disposed
of the waste at the end of its
life,” Mr. Aumônier said.
A
2018 Danish study
found that, from an
environmental point
of view, it’s best to recycle
or incinerate carrier bags
when it’s time to throw them
out.
In the U.S., most are di-
verted to landfills.
In 2017, the country gen-
erated 4.14 million tons of
plastic bags, sacks and
wraps, according to the Envi-
ronmental Protection
Agency. When they were dis-
carded, more than 3 million
tons went to landfills; 0.
million tons were inciner-
ated; and 0.39 million tons
were recycled.
The report didn’t estimate
how many escaped into the
environment.
So, given all of the trade-
offs, which bag is best?
According to the U.N., it’s
the one you already have at
home—no matter what it’s
made of.
Just make sure you use it
alot.
THE NUMBERS|By Jo Craven McGinty
What Happens When Plastic Gets the Sack?
=1use
Nonwoven
polypropylene
34 10
9
5
1
Low-density
polyethylene
Paper (40% recycled content)
Paper (100% recycled content)
Single-use plastic bags
Number of times alternatives must be used to have
the same environmental impact as a single-use
plastic bag, by type*
*High-density polyethylene bag assuming no secondary use
Source: Robert M. Kimmel, Clemson University Kathryn Tam/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL