Elusive Victories_ The American Presidency at War-Oxford University Press (2012)

(Axel Boer) #1

284 e lusive v ictories


International audiences, as suggested, proved much less receptive to
Bush administration arguments. Apart from a few of Saddam Hussein’s
neighbors, foreign leaders did not regard him as an immediate threat.
Some nations, such as France, benefi ted from trade with Iraq under the
oil-for-food program, as well as more illicit dealings. Moreover, if
al-Qaeda terrorism prompted concern, so did unchecked American bel-
licosity, and the Bush Doctrine justifying preventive war stirred fears of
the destabilizing eff ects when one nation acquires disproportionate
power in the international system.
Th e administration struggled to reassemble the kind of broad multi-
national coalition that stood against Saddam Hussein when he had
invaded Kuwait a decade before. Erstwhile American allies such as
France declined to participate; Turkey held back, complicating any
invasion plan that would have involved entering Iraq from the north. 
Colin Powell urged Bush to build international support for military
action by seeking a UN resolution to demand that Iraq submit to
inspections of its suspected WMD programs.  Although this would
mean putting the invasion plans on hold, the president agreed, and
Powell led a diplomatic effort that secured unanimous support for
Security Council Resolution 1441 on November 8, 2002.  Later, the
secretary of state would put his prestige on the line when he returned to
the United Nations in early 2003 to present the administration’s evi-
dence that Saddam had continued his WMD programs in violation of
UN resolutions. But the intelligence that seemed to the Bush adminis-
tration to confi rm its worst assumptions about the Iraqi dictator failed
to sway other nations.  (In time, the shoddy basis for Powell’s assertions
became public and badly tarnished his reputation.)  If the president
decided to move against Iraq, he would do so with many fewer allies
than his father’s administration had recruited in 1990–1991.


McNamara Redux


Th e invasion of Iraq occurred against a backdrop of civil-military ten-
sions strikingly similar to those that marked the Vietnam era. As we saw
in the previous chapter, Robert McNamara took up his position as sec-
retary of defense determined to reform the Pentagon from top to
bottom, and he clashed fi ercely with the military leadership throughout

Free download pdf