The Washington Post - 05.03.2020

(nextflipdebug5) #1

A10 eZ M2 THE WASHINGTON POST.THURSDAy, MARCH 5 , 2020


the coronavirus outbreak


BY BRADY DENNIS,
JAY GREENE
AND HANNAH SAMPSON

The spread of coronavirus
around the country showed few
signs of slowing on Wednesday, a s
the disease known as covid-
claimed two more lives on the
West Coast, clusters of new infec-
tions surfaced in California and
New York, and lawmakers on Cap-
itol Hill raced to finalize an $8.
billion emergency spending bill to
combat the deadly outbreak.
California Gov. Gavin Newsom
(D) declared a state of emergency,
after officials there announced
the state’s first coronavirus-
linked death, bringing the death
toll in the United States to 11. The
fatality, w hich occurred northeast
of Sacramento in Placer County,
represents the first U.S. death out-
side Washington state.
Public health officials de-
scribed the deceased California
patient as an “elderly adult with
underlying health conditions.”
The patient was probably exposed
during a mid-february round trip
from San francisco on a Princess
cruise ship, officials said.
The head of the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention
on Wednesday said the agency is
working with California to exam-
ine the passenger manifest for
that trip. The ship, known as the
Grand Princess, is a sister ship to
the Diamond Princess, which was
at the center of a coronavirus
outbreak in february that sick-
ened more than 700 people and
led to seven deaths.
meanwhile, at the epicenter of
the U.S. outbreak in Washington
state, officials confirmed another
death and 10 new cases of corona-
virus in King County. The state’s
10 deaths all have occurred in
King and Snohomish counties —
largely consisting of elderly pa-
tients with existing health prob-
lems who have been linked to the


Life Care Center nursing facility
in Kirkland.
“This is a shifting landscape
and is shifting by the hour,” King
County Executive Dow Constan-
tine said during a Wednesday
news conference. County officials
advised people over 60 and with
underlying conditions, as well as
pregnant women, to stay home
and avoid large groups. They also
urged employees to telecommute
for the next three weeks if possi-
ble.
King County is in the process of
purchasing an 85-bed Econo
Lodge motel in Kent, Wash., just
south of Seattle, for $4 million to
provide emergency housing for
people with covid-19, the disease
caused by coronavirus.
The two-story motel met crite-
ria set by the county’s public
health agency, including separate
heating and air-conditioning in
each unit and doors that open to
the outside rather than a hallway.
The county has not yet deter-
mined who will stay in the motel,
located just off Highway 167.
The county wants to make sure
that as patients begin to recover,
they can move out of hospital
beds to make room for others.
“It’s a rapidly m oving emergen-
cy situation,” said Chase Gallagh-
er, a spokesman for the county.
In California, Los Angeles
County declared a local health
emergency Wednesday as officials
detailed six new cases of coronavi-
rus, bringing t he countywide total
to seven. Several of the patients
recently traveled to northern Ita-
ly, which remains among the
pa rts of the globe hardest hit by
the virus, officials said. The other
new cases were either family
members of the travelers or peo-
ple who worked in close contact
with them.
“This is not a response rooted
in panic,” K athryn Barger, chair of
the Los Angeles County Board of
Supervisors, said in a news con-

ference. “We’ve been preparing
with our local, state and federal
partners for the likelihood of this
scenario.”
In New York, Gov. Andrew m.
Cuomo (D) on Wednesday an-
nounced a flurry of new cases,
raising the state’s total to 11. The
new cases, which involved people
linked to a 50-year-old
Westchester County attorney di-
agnosed Tuesday, underscored
the virus’s capacity to spread rap-
idly.
The man’s wife and two chil-
dren were among those who test-
ed positive, as was a neighbor who
drove the man to the hospital,
Cuomo said. The attorney’s co-
workers at his midtown manhat-
tan law firm also are being tested.
“Some of the tests are pending,
but nobody has come back posi-
tive yet,” Cuomo said.
The synagogue the man’s fami-
ly attends will be closed until
Sunday, officials said. His daugh-
ter’s high school will be closed
until Tuesday. Its related elemen-
tary and middle school will be
closed through friday. The gover-
nor later announced that a 45-
year-old friend of the man who
lives in New rochelle, N.Y., also
tested positive for coronavirus.
That person’s 46-year-old wife,
two sons and a daughter also
tested positive.
New Jersey Gov. Phil murphy
(D) announced late Wednesday
the first positive case of covid-
in the state. officials said the
patient is a man in his 30s who
has been hospitalized since Tues-
day.
As some businesses instructed
employees to abandon nonessen-
tial travel and encouraged tele-
work, and as an increasing num-
ber of conferences and meetings
are canceled, the effects rippled
through the economy — e ven on a
day that saw the Dow Jones indus-
trial average end the day up nearly
1,200 points, or more than 4.

percent.
The rebound came a day after
the federal reserve delivered its
first emergency rate cut since the
2008 financial crisis and amid
volatile trading that saw concerns
over coronavirus trigger a sell-off
that erased trillions in value from
global markets.
United Airlines on Wednesday
announced it will cut domestic
flights by 10 percent and interna-
tional flights by 20 percent next
month. Executives are planning
“similar reductions” in may, the
airline said, underscoring the
steep drop-off in travel demand.
The airline is seeking volun-
teers to take unpaid leaves of
absence and is instituting a hiring
freeze “except for roles that are
critical to our operation,” the ex-
ecutives said.
Amid the ongoing uncertainty,
officials in the nation’s capital
sought to once again reassure the
public.
At a late afternoon White
House briefing, Vice President
Pence said he would travel to
minneapolis on Thursday to visit
3m, which is ramping up produc-
tion of masks for health-care
workers. Later, he plans to fly to
Washington state to meet with
Gov. Jay Inslee (D) and state
health officials.
“We understand the anxiety
this has created,” said Pence, who
added that he intends to make
sure local officials have “every-
thing they need.”
In a near unanimous vote, the
House on Wednesday approved
an $8.3 billion emergency spend-
ing bill to fight the coronavirus.
The Senate could follow suit as
soon as Thursday, and President
Trump is expected to quickly sign
the legislation.
The funding — m ore than triple
what the White House initially
requested to combat the outbreak
— would set aside billions of dol-
lars for vaccine development,

medical supplies, support for lo-
cal health agencies and other
preparation.
The package includes more
than $3 billion for research and
development on vaccines and oth-
er treatments, as well as $2.2 bil-
lion for the CDC to support state
and local agencies responding to
the outbreak. The bill also would
provide $1 billion in loan subsi-
dies for small businesses, which
Democrats said would enable the
Small Business Administration to
provide $7 billion in low-interest
loans for companies affected by
the outbreak.
While the vast majority of the
funding would be spent domesti-
cally, Wednesday’s emergency bill
also includes $1.25 billion for the
State Department to assist in bat-
tling the spread of the coronavi-
rus overseas.
Italy on Wednesday said it will
close schools and universities
throughout the country in an at-
tempt to control the spread of the
coronavirus, as it battles the most
serious outbreak in Europe.
A total of 2,706 people have
tested positive for the virus in the
country, and more than 10 per-
cent of those who have tested
positive are in intensive care,
straining Italy’s health-care sys-
tem, which is scrambling to add
extra beds.
Saudi Arabia suspended offsea-
son pilgrimage trips to its holy
cities of mecca and medina for all
citizens and residents as part of
an effort to combat the spread of
the virus, the state news agency
reported.
Iraq’s health ministry an-
nounced the country’s first offi-
cial death from covid-19 on
Wednesday. The patient was iden-
tified as a woman being t reated in
Baghdad, the capital.
Israel reported three more
covid-19 patients on Wednesday,
including a teenager whose diag-
nosis resulted in the health minis-

try ordering about 1,400 students
in his high school into quaran-
tine.
In London, British Prime min-
ister Boris Johnson announced
Wednesday that the U.K. govern-
ment will introduce emergency
coronavirus legislation that will
allow sick pay for people who
self-isolate from the first day of
their illness.
Under the current rules, em-
ployers have to give sick pay only
from the fourth day of illness.
Australia’s top physician
warned citizens against stockpil-
ing toilet paper, after stores across
the country ran out as shoppers
bought supplies amid the corona-
virus outbreak.“We are trying to
reassure people that removing all
of the lavatory paper from the
shelves of supermarkets probably
isn’t a proportionate or sensible
thing to do at this time,” Chief
medical officer Brendan murphy
told a Senate hearing Wednesday,
according to local reports.
meanwhile, in China, fewer
new cases were reported outside
the country than within, suggest-
ing that authorities’ efforts to
curb transmission may be paying
off at home, even as the casualty
count rises elsewhere. China
tightened restrictions on arrivals
amid concern about cases being
imported. Iran and Italy have re-
corded 92 and 107 deaths, respec-
tively. India reported a sharp rise
in cases Wednesday after Italian
tourists tested positive.
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]

seung Min Kim, Miriam Berger, rick
Noack, siobhán O’Grady, Loveday
Morris, Andrew Fr eedman, Louisa
Loveluck, Benjamin soloway, Paul
schemm, Karla Adam, ruth eglash,
Adam taylor, Jennifer Hassan, Felicia
sonmez, Kim Bellware, Ben Guarino
and Michael Laris contributed to this
report.

Death toll continues to rise in the U.S. as clusters of new cases emerge


tors,” said Elijah A. White, presi-
dent of ZoLL resuscitation. “It’s
not just China, it’s not just the
United States, it’s all over the
place.”
If the outbreak expands and
individual states have hundreds
or thousands of patients instead
of just a few, regional plans must
be established to coordinate care,
said Christopher Greene, an
emergency room doctor at the
University of Alabama at Bir-
mingham.
Severely ill p atients needing t o
be placed on mechanical ventila-
tors will have to be moved to
hospitals with higher levels of
care, and t hat presents further
challenges for ambulance opera-
tors and staff, Greene said. “This
is a rapidly evolving thing. In a
matter of days you can go from
60 cases to many, m any more,’ ’ he
said. Large hospitals are devising
contingency plans for a growing
outbreak, he said, but “we want t o
see that level of urgency at the
federal level a s well.’’
Leaders at r hode I sland Hospi-
tal in Providence have been plan-
ning for weeks for the arrival of
the coronavirus. The virus ap-
peared last week in one student
and one staff member who trav-
eled to Italy on a trip sponsored by
a parochial high school. As worry
spread through the state , people
who called the hospital to seek a
test were asked to remain in their
cars until a doctor could go out to
screen them.
“We have a physician in protec-
tive equipment go out to the car
and put masks on anybody in the
car, and take a history, and do a
limited screening exam, and then
do the testing, which i n most cases
is a nasal swab,’’ said John B.
murphy, president of rhode Is-
land Hospital and Hasbro Chil-
dren’s Hospital. In the two posi-
tive cases, the results were avail-
able in four hours.
Now, officials are tracing con-
tacts of all students and staff
members o n the trip t o Italy.
rhode Island Hospital has
7 0 “negative-pressure’’ patient
rooms — which means airborne
particles cannot escape — that
can be used to isolate people.
The hospital’s engineers are an-
alyzing how to t urn entire floors
of the hospital into isolation
wards.
The hospital has about 25 pa-
tients on ventilators on an average
day. It can treat more than
100 people on ventilators in a
demand surge, murphy said. Be-
yond that, he said, the hospital
would be forced to work with state
officials to find outside f acilities to
isolate and treat patients.
[email protected]
[email protected]

and manage the ill residents.”
A similar study of assisted-
living facilities published in 20 14
found that 41 percent had no pan-
demic p lan.
Lona mody, a professor of med-
icine a t the University of michigan
and co-author of both studies,
said that she thinks many nursing
homes have improved since the
study but that more needs to be
done.
federal officials estimated in
2005 that in the event of a severe
pandemic, such as the 1918 flu,
more than 740,000 people would
require ventilators. But there are
only about 200,000 ventilation
machines in U.S. medical facilities
and a national stockpile, accord-
ing to experts.
“If it is the severe scenario, we
will not have enough ventilators,”
said Watson, of the Johns Hopkins
Center for Health Security. “I
don’t think this [novel coronavi-
rus] is the severe scenario, b ut if it
is, we will have to make some
difficult decisions.”
The makers of ventilators said
that, indeed, they have seen a
dramatic r ise in demand.
“We are seeing — and I suspect
all the players are seeing — an
increased demand for ventila-

they’re incentivized to work when
sick, u nfortunately,” S weet said.
A survey of hundreds of nurs-
ing homes published in the Jour-
nal of the American m edical Asso-
ciation in 2008 showed that
slightly more than half lacked a
plan to deal with a pandemic.
only about half had stockpiled
supplies such as gloves, alcohol
rub, surgical masks and antiviral
medications, the study found.
The nursing homes surveyed
for the study were in Nebraska
and michigan, but experts said
the findings probably were repre-
sentative of the n ation.
Advocates of the nursing home
industry said facilities are better
prepared now because of regula-
tions in 2016 regarding emergen-
cy preparedness and infection
co ntrol.
“A ll facilities need to have an
infection-control plan in place,
which includes what to do during
an outbreak,” said Beth martino,
senior vice president of public af-
fairs for the A merican Health Care
Association. “These plans include
the infection-control strategies a
center has in place for surveil-
lance of new infectious cases, w ho
to report to and the steps to take to
minimize the spread of an illness

ly on the ball,” said Sweet, who
keeps up with reports from mem-
bers at n ursing homes.
At the better facilities, she said,
managers have taken special
steps: checking the temperatures
of employees as they report for
work; reminding family members
and vendors to steer clear if they
are not feeling well; and running
special training for infection con-
trol.
At others, members have re-
ported to Sweet, there seems to be
no urgency to prepare.
“They’re not prepared at all,”
Sweet said. “They are putting
their residents i n jeopardy.”
one of the challenges at nurs-
ing homes, aside from the vulner-
ability of residents, is that one
worker, if infected, can become a
“super-spreader,” said Lauren An-
cel meyers, a professor at the Uni-
versity of Te xas at Austin who has
studied infectious-disease sur-
veillance.
moreover, many nurse’s aides
at such facilities might be reluc-
tant to stay home if they are not
feeling well, because they lack sick
leave.
“There’s a large proportion of
single mothers in this group who
need to put food on the table, and

preparedness in health care has
been in a slow, steady decline for
more than 15 years.
The amount of federal funding
given to state and local officials to
prepare for health emergencies
has been cut in half or more over
the past couple of decades, ac-
cording to Crystal Watson, senior
scholar at t he Johns Hopkins Cen-
ter for Health S ecurity.
The two key federal programs
amounted to $1.4 billion in 2003.
Those two programs amount to
$662 million this year.
“Every administration has
made cuts to these programs,”
Watson said.
Seven of the 11 deaths in the
United States have been linked to
the Life Care Center nursing home
in Kirkland, Wash., and that has
focused attention on the nation’s
more than 15,000 nursing homes
and 20,000 residential care facili-
ties.
Some facilities are prepared for
the outbreak, and some are not,
according to Lisa Sweet, chief
clinical officer of the National As-
sociation of Health Care Assis-
tants, a group that represents
nursing aides.
“It runs the gamut — there are
some good providers who are real-

emergency measure was being
wound down Tuesday as the
state’s testing capacity grows.
officials in King County, Wash.,
this week said they were purchas-
ing a motel to house patients who
needed to be placed in isolation.
In r ural areas of Te xas and else-
where, small hospitals do not have
test kits, and central labs for test-
ing samples are hours away.
“There’s not anywhere near a
sufficient number of kits to con-
firm or deny virus, or quarantine
or control all these patients,’’ said
John Henderson, who heads the
association for Te xas’s rural hospi-
tals.
Ventilators and intensive care
units, necessary to keep the most
acutely ill patients alive, are large-
ly limited to larger hospitals and
academic medical centers in cit-
ies.
front-line providers are dust-
ing off old protocols for handling
previous global health threats in-
cluding severe acute respiratory
syndrome ( SArS), middle East re-
spiratory syndrome (mErS),
H1N1 and E bola. B ut the coronavi-
rus is spreading rapidly and, with
mild symptoms that mimic the
flu, difficult to detect.
Nationwide, worries are grow-
ing about a lack of hospital beds to
quarantine and treat infected pa-
tients. major medical centers are
typically full even without a flood
of coronavirus patients.
“We just don’t h ave the c apacity
in the hospitals and health sys-
tems to deal with a massive influx
of patients and keep them isolat-
ed,’’ said Gerard Anderson, a pro-
fessor of health policy and man-
agement at Johns Hopkins Uni-
versity.
Despite weeks of preparations,
health planners continue to fret
about shortages of masks and
gowns for hospital staff, as well as
lifesaving mechanical respirators
for patients with severe cases of
the disease.
“We need masks, w e need venti-
lators for our medical facilities,
and we need it fast,” Sen. Patty
murray (D-Wash.), whose state
has experienced the largest fatal
outbreak in the country, said on
Tuesday.
Budget-conscious health sys-
tems do not maintain large vol-
umes of reserve supplies just for
the possibility of a pandemic, said
William Jaquis, president of the
American College of Emergency
Physicians. That l eaves the system
vulnerable.
“We don’t necessarily have the
backup readiness all the time for
these i ssues,’’ he said. “A nd they do
keep repeating.’ ’
f ederal funding for emergency


HospItAls from A


U.S. nursing homes appear especially vulnerable


dAVId ryder/reuters
Medics move a patient to an ambulance at the life Care Center of Kirkland, Wash., a nursing home that has been linked to seven of the 11
coronavirus deaths in the United states. officials in King County said they were purchasing a motel to house patients needing i solation.
Free download pdf