Nature - USA (2020-08-20)

(Antfer) #1
Nature | Vol 584 | 20 August 2020 | 375

with an amplitude of 2.0 mA and a frequency of 503 Hz. The other
measurement configurations, such as the wire structure and the mag-
netic field, are the same as those of the d.c. measurement (Fig. 2b).
Here, Rω corresponds to the linear resistance R 0 , which is independent
of the current magnitude. In contrast, R 2 ω represents the second-order
resistance, which is proportional to the current and the magnetic field
(Rγ 2 ω=R 20 BI). Both Rω and R 2 ω were measured while sweeping the mag-
netic field at 4.2 K (Fig. 3a). R 2 ω is greatly enhanced during the transitions
and antisymmetric with respect to the magnetic field when the mag-
netic field is orthogonal to the current (±y direction), whereas it is
negligibly small when the magnetic field is set parallel to the current
(+x direction). This direction-dependent R 2 ω is characteristic of the
Rashba superconductors. To our knowledge, this is the first direct
evidence of the Rashba superconductivity in a three-dimensional super-
lattice. We next measured the temperature dependence of the R 2 ω
signals, to compare with that of the ΔIc (Fig. 3b). The R 2 ω signals observed
at each temperature are enhanced around the critical field, perhaps
because the nonreciprocal charge transport may be caused by super-
conducting fluctuations^10 ,^13 ,^21.
The temperature dependence of the γ values, which are calculated
as γ=RB^2 Rω^2 ωI (see equation ( 1 )), is plotted in Fig.  4. Here, we adopted the
maximum R 2 ω for each temperature and the corresponding Rω and
magnetic field. The notable observations are that the γ value increases
in the vicinity of Tc and reaches γ ≈ 550 T−1 A−1 at its maximum. These
trends are entirely consistent with those in other low-dimensional


systems. The magnetochiral anisotropy of the [Nb/V/Ta]n superlattice
naturally leads to nonreciprocal critical current; this was also clearly
observed in the vicinity of Tc.
Finally, we discuss the possible origin of the magnetochiral ani-
sotropy in the [Nb/V/Ta]n superlattice from a theoretical point of
view. A first-principles calculation was performed to identify the
band structure of a [Nb/V/Ta]n superlattice, where two-atomic-layer
slabs of body-centred cubic Nb, V, and Ta were repeatedly stacked
five times (see Methods). Indeed, we noticed the Rashba spin–orbit
interaction-induced energy splitting near EF (Extended Data Fig. 1), which
was estimated to be ER = 10 meV at maximum (about 1% of EF). The Rashba
splitting is induced by the artificially engineered superlattice structure of
intrinsically centrosymmetric metals. Thus, the Rashba splitting, which
causes nonreciprocal charge transport in the [Nb/V/Ta]n superlattice
(Fig.  3 ), is also verified theoretically, and can be controlled by the super-
lattice structures. Our first-principles calculation reveals that electronic
states near EF are composed of strongly hybridized orbitals of Ta, Nb and
V atoms. Such orbitals are affected by asymmetric heterostructures, and
a combination with a large atomic spin–orbit interaction of Nb and Ta
atoms generates a sizeable Rashba spin–orbit interaction. Here, an essen-
tial feature of the Rashba superconductor is the mixing state of the spin
singlet and triplet pairings^22 –^25. According to the predictions from Wakat-
suki and Nagaosa^21 , one of the mechanisms of magnetochiral anisotropy
in Rashba superconductors could be the superconducting fluctuation
with the mixed spin-singlet and spin-triplet pairings. If we adopt this

a

c

b

–0.2 –0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2

0

2

4

6

8

ΔIc

(mA)

I (mA)c

ΔIc

(mA)

Magnetic 
eld (T)

+I


  • I


4.2 K
6.6 mA

2 46810

0

1

2

3

4


  • I
    0.02 T
    0.06 T
    0.10 T
    0.14 T
    0.18 T


Resistance (

Ω)

|I| (mA)

4.2 K

+I

–0.4

–0.2

0.0

0.2

0.4

–0.4

–0.2

0.0

0.2

0.4

–1.0 –0.5 0.00.5 1.0

+y


  • y


2.0 K 3.0 K 4.0 K

4.2 K 4.3 K
Magnetic
eld (T)

–1.0 –0.5 0.00.5 1.0
Magnetic
eld (T)

–1.0 –0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0
Magnetic
eld (T)

4.35 K

+y


  • y


+y


  • y


+y


  • y


+y


  • y


+y


  • y


Fig. 2 | Asymmetric R–I curves and the nonreciprocal critical currents in the
[ N b/ V/ Ta]n superlattice. a, Current dependences of the sheet resistance
under various magnetic fields for both positive and negative currents at 4.2 K.
b, Nonreciprocal critical current Ic as a function of the magnetic field. The red
dashed line indicates a current of 6.6 mA, corresponding to the current


amplitude, demonstrating the superconducting diode effect shown in Fig.  1.
c, The nonreciprocal component of the critical current ΔIc plotted as a function
of the magnetic field at various temperatures. As the temperature increases
towards the Tc, the ΔIc clearly appears and subsequently shrinks.

–0.6–0.4–0.2 0.00.2 0.40.6

–0.2

–0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

Magnetic eld (T)

3.5 K4.0 K
4.1 K
4.2 K4.3 K
4.35 K

abAmplitude 2.0 mA


–0.4 –0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4

0

1

2

3

4

R 2 Z
RZ
+y

+y
+x


  • y


Magnetic eld (T)

RZ


) (^2) ZR

) R^2
(Z
Ω)
–0.10
–0.05
0.00
0.05
0.10
Amplitude 2.0 mA4.2 K +y–y Fig. 3 | Nonreciprocal charge transport during the
superconducting transition in the [Nb/V/Ta]n
superlattice. a, Magnetic field dependence of first-
(Rω) and second-harmonic (R 2 ω) sheet resistances at
4.2 K. The white and blue shadings indicate the
superconducting and normal conducting regions,
respectively. R 2 ω values are clearly enhanced when
the directions of the current and magnetic field are
orthogonal. b, Temperature dependence of the
antisymmetric second-harmonic sheet resistances.

Free download pdf