The Wall Street Journal - USA (2020-12-02)

(Antfer) #1

THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Wednesday, December 2, 2020 |A


on Monday said it projected a
budget deficit in the year end-
ing March 30 to jump to at
least C$381.6 billion, or 17.5% of
gross domestic product, versus
a deficit of C$39.39 billion, or
1.7% of GDP, in the previous 12-
month period. The U.S. budget
deficit tripled during the year
that ended Sept. 30, to reach
$3.1 trillion, or the equivalent
of 16.1% of economic output.
The deficit could swell to
near C$400 billion because of
deteriorating economic condi-
tions related to a second wave
of Covid-19 infections. Canada
anticipates the deficit to nar-
row next fiscal year to between
C$121 billion and C$166 billion,
depending on how much new
spending is deployed.
Canada has recovered about
80% of the jobs lost in March
and April because of the virus,
whereas the U.S. has regained
just over half of employees
shed. Growth is expected to
grind to a halt in the final three
months of 2020 as restrictions

from all levels of Canadian
government will surge to
roughly 115% of GDP this year
from 89% in 2019, the IMF
said. The debt-to-GDP ratio
this year in the U.S. is forecast

to reach 131%; 108% in the
U.K.; and 73% in Germany, ac-
cording to the IMF.
When downgrading the coun-
try’s rating to double-A-plus in
late June from triple-A, Fitch

re-emerged to deal with a sec-
ond wave of Covid-19 infections.
The federal government’s
debt is also set to surpass C$
trillion for the first time this
year, or 50% of GDP, and debt

Changeinfiscalbalanceasa
percentageofGDP

Source: International Monetary Fund

Note: Discretionary fiscal support is measured
as the change in the cyclically adjusted primary
balance; nondiscretionary fiscal support is the
residual in percentage points.

–20 pct. pts. –10 0

Canada

U.K.

U.S.

Italy

Japan

Germany

France

Discretionary
Nondiscretionary
(including automatic stabilizers)

GDP Jumped 40.5%
In Third Quarter

OTTAWA—Canada ended
two straight quarters of virus-
fueled declines in output with
a surge in the third quarter,
with household spending driv-
ing growth.
The quarterly gain, however,
came in well short of market
expectations, and indicates the
road to a full recovery will be
long and uneven, as the Bank
of Canada has warned.
The central bank has sig-
naled it will keep its bench-
mark interest rate, which is at
near zero, unchanged until

2023, and Canada’s federal
government has pledged this
week another large dollop of
fiscal firepower to juice the
economy.
Early indicators suggest
fourth-quarter output will be
weak, as a second wave of
Covid-19 infections force au-
thorities to impose new eco-
nomic restrictions.
Canada’s gross domestic
product, the broadest measure
of goods and services produced
in the economy, surged at a
40.5% annualized rate in the
third quarter to 2 trillion Cana-
dian dollars, the equivalent of
US$1.54 trillion, Statistics Can-
ada said on Tuesday.
—Paul Vieira

Learn more at
habitat.org.

every


one


deserves a decent


place to live.


alexa


3NYP

FREE INSIDE THE


OUT


TODAY


150 +golden treasures for


eeveryone on your list!veryoneonyourlist!


HHOLIDAYOLIDAY


GGIFTIFT


GGUIDEUIDE


WORLD NEWS


Ratings cited a steep rise in gov-
ernment debt and skepticism
about the ability among political
leaders to stabilize debt growth
after the pandemic passes.
Carolyn Wilkins, the second-
highest-ranking official at the
Bank of Canada, said fiscal pol-
icy is a powerful tool with inter-
est rates near zero and business
activity constrained. Without
massive fiscal outlays, “you
wouldn’t be seeing the recovery
we’re seeing now,” she said.
Deputy Prime Minister and
Finance Minister Chrystia
Freeland on Monday said the
fiscal taps will remain wide
open for the foreseeable fu-
ture. She said in an annual fall
economic update that the gov-
ernment is set to spend up to
C$100 billion over a three-year
period starting in 2021 to help
fortify the recovery from the
pandemic. Stimulus spending
would cease only when bench-
marks related to employment
data were met, she said.
“Canadians understand that
this crisis demands targeted,
time-limited support to keep
people and businesses afloat
and to build our way out of the
Covid-19 recession,” she said.
Ms. Freeland said the govern-
ment would introduce rules to
stabilize debt growth but only
after the recovery is complete.
Mr. Jean, of Desjardins Se-
curities, said the government
is betting the massive fiscal
outlays will prevent a catas-
trophe in household and cor-
porate bankruptcies.
Yet David Rosenberg, econ-
omist and head of Toronto-
based consulting firm Rosen-
berg Research, pointed out
that combining mounting gov-
ernment debt and what house-
holds and nonfinancial corpo-
rations owe puts Canada’s
total debt-to-GDP ratio at
more than 400%—ahead of the
Americans and Chinese, but on
par with Italy and Greece. The
latter two countries dealt with
fiscal crises last decade.
“The only way that Can-
ada’s aggregate debt ratio is
sustainable is if we just have
interest rates close to zero in
perpetuity,” he said.

OTTAWA—Canada’s deficit
is growing at the fastest rate
among developed nations as it
seeks to prop up its economy
during the Covid-19 pandemic.
Canadian officials are bet-
ting the aggressive approach
will pay off, pointing to the
number of jobs recovered, and
argue that the country can af-
ford to pour money into the
economy while borrowing
costs are historically low. But
some economists warn the
heavy spending could lead to a
fiscal crisis, and one major
ratings firm has stripped the
country of its triple-A rating.
Canada isn’t alone in its
spending spree: The Interna-
tional Monetary Fund esti-
mates governments around the
world have doled out $12 tril-
lion to minimize the economic
damage from restrictions in
place to halt transmission of
Covid-19. Canada’s virus-related
spending, the bulk of which
originates with the federal gov-
ernment, has totaled about 382
billion Canadian dollars, the
equivalent of US$294 billion,
and accounts for roughly 19%
of Canada’s economic output.
Yet IMF data indicate Can-
ada’s fiscal position during the
pandemic—incorporating all
levels of government—has de-
teriorated at the fastest pace
among the major economies in
the Group of 20 industrialized
countries as it seeks to keep
the economy pumping.
“Canada could come off as
heroic if this spending is done
right,” said Jimmy Jean, a
strategist at Desjardins Securi-
ties in Montreal. “If Canada
fails, all the emergency spend-
ing might have been done in
vain because we won’t have
the capacity to power the
post-vaccine recovery.”
The Canadian government


BYPAULVIEIRA
ANDKIMMACKRAEL


Canada Spends Its Way Into Huge Deficit


Government officials


hope aggressive steps


to prop up economy in


pandemic will pay off


A closed furniture store in Toronto reflects the potential economic toll in coming months from new restrictions aimed at stemming Covid-19.

CHRIS HELGREN/REUTERS

NY
Free download pdf