Ancient Literacies

(Marvins-Underground-K-12) #1

alphabet within the context of the dialect of Homeric language (cf. Ruijgh


1997). Woodard 1997,Greek Writing from Knossos to Homer, makes a


linguistic argument for the continuity of literacy from syllabic to alpha-


betic scripts: ‘‘The Linear B syllabic script, the syllabary of the Cypriot


Greeks and the alphabet each stand as points along an unbroken con-


tinuum of Greek literacy.’’ The study of the evolution of the alphabet is in


any case inextricably tied up with questions concerning literacy (Bodson


1991). This development has received much attention within the field


of Greek epigraphy. In a review article, Walbank 1993 discusses the


challenges of interpreting the evidence, remarking that ‘‘the preponder-


ance of Attic inscriptions, as well as of Athenian literary material, has led


to an undeserved emphasis upon Athens in the history of the Greek


alphabet.’’ Recent work (Guarducci 1987, Jeffery 1990 [1st ed. 1961],


Immerwahr 1990) shows that ‘‘literacy was by no means the invention of


the Athenians.’’ Rather, as Immerwahr 1990: 29 suggests, the paucity


of the epigraphical documentation from Attica in the late eighth and first


three quarters of the seventh century indicates that ‘‘Athens seems to


have been a cultural backwater, at least so far as writing is concerned.’’
Pandolfini and Prosdocimi 1990 discuss the rise of alphabetic literacy in


Etruria and archaic Italy; Camporeale 2004: 192–208 conveniently sur-


veys this topic and provides further bibliography. The cultural signifi-


cance of Linear B has continued to be assessed. Whereas Palaima 1987


argues that writing in the Mycenaean world was the almost exclusive


province of the palace administration, Godart and Tzedakis 1989 recon-


sider the history of Linear B in light of recent discoveries of inscribed


vases. Driessen 1992 reflects on possible links between Linear B docu-


ments and other Aegean scripts, and asks whether the Mycenaeans had


an oral epic poetry and whether the Homeric poems show any knowledge


of it. For further comparanda with Aegean and other Mediterranean


scripts—such as cuneiform and hieroglyphic Hittite—see A. Davies



  1. Sherratt 2003 raises the question of whether a link may be found


between the introduction of alphabetic literacy in Greece and the ree-


mergence of syllabic literacy in Cyprus. Chrisomalis 2003 discusses the


Egyptian origin of the Greek alphabetic numerals.


The study of the bookroll—of its material and social contexts, of its


physical and conceptual structure—has undergone a renaissance, thanks


in part to an outpouring of dedicated scholarship that has benefited from


developing technology that allows investigation of the carbonized pa-


pyrus bookrolls discovered at Herculaneum without causing disastrous


further damage, partly also to dramatic recent discoveries such as the


Posidippus epigram book (P.Mil.Vogl. VIII 309), and partly to other new


work. The typology and material aspects of the ancient book were first
studied systematically by Birt 1882 before the spectacular discovery, in


the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, of fragments of thou-


sands of Greek literary bookrolls preserved at Oxyrhynchus and else-


where in Egypt. Fundamental contributions of the twentieth century to


Literacy Studies in Classics 335

Free download pdf