34 Psychology as a Profession
economic prosperity of America in the 1920s, and the rapid
social changes in American society after the war were all fac-
tors that led to the further development of the profession of
psychology.
THE 1920s: THE DECADE OF
POPULAR PSYCHOLOGY
American historians have written of the public euphoria in
the United States that followed World War I. American forces
had helped to win the war in Europe. There was general
economic prosperity, and a growing belief in the American
dream that anything was possible, with hard work. Writing
for the American public in 1925, psychologist John B.
Watson (1878–1958) promoted this nurturistic optimism:
Give me a dozen healthy infants, well-formed, and my own
specified world to bring them up in and I’ll guarantee to take any
one at random and train him to become any type of specialist
I might select—doctor, lawyer, artist, merchant-chief and, yes,
even beggar-man and thief, regardless of his talents, penchants,
tendencies, abilities, vocations, and race of his ancestors.
(Watson, 1925, p. 82)Americans seemed delirious with the potential for psychol-
ogy to improve their lives. The first popular psychology
magazines (four of them) began publication in the decade.
Countless self-help books were published, and newspapers
carried daily columns of psychological advice. Touting the
value of psychology for the public, journalist Albert Wiggam
(1928) wrote:
Men and women never needed psychology so much as they need
it to-day.... You cannot achieve these things [effectiveness and
happiness] in the fullest measure without the new knowledge of
your own mind and personality that the psychologists have given
us. (p. 13)Public demand for psychological services grew rapidly, and
consequently, many individuals, with little or no training
in psychology, offered their services to the public as
psychologists.
Consulting psychologists were especially concerned about
such pseudopractitioners and petitioned the APA to create a
certification program to identify psychologists qualified to
consult with the public. Initially, the APA balked at the idea
but relented in 1924, when it established such a program. Four
years later, after fewer than 30 psychologists had received
certification, the program was abandoned (Sokal, 1982b).
There was no mechanism for enforcement of such a program,
and the public seemed incapable of making distinctions
between qualified psychologists and unqualified ones, or at
least was uninterested in doing so. Nevertheless, psychology
of all kinds prospered—and the professional opportunities in
business, school, clinical, and counseling psychology grew at
a rapid rate.STRUGGLES FOR PROFESSIONAL IDENTITYAs early as 1915, consulting psychologists had petitioned the
APA to recognize the growth of applied psychology by com-
mitting some program time at the annual meeting for discus-
sion of professional issues. But APA leadership had balked,
citing the APA’s sole stated objective as an organization that
existed for the advancement of psychology as a science.
When the American Association of Clinical Psychologists
(AACP) had been founded in 1917, there was concern within
the APA that the group would lead to a rupture in organized
psychology. In negotiations between the two groups, the
AACP agreed to dissolve in 1919 and reorganize as the Clini-
cal Section of the APA. The Clinical Section identified three
goals: “promoting better working relationships within clinical
and within allied fields, developing professional standards for
practitioners, and encouraging research and publication on
topics in clinical psychology” (Napoli, 1981, p. 26).
Two years later, in 1921, the APA created a second section
on consulting psychology, and the short-lived certification pro-
gram would stem from the efforts of this group. The consulting/
clinical psychologists recommended two additional APA sec-
tions, one on educational psychology and the other on indus-
trial psychology, but those two requests were denied.
As the professional opportunities for psychologists grew
and as problems in professional practice occurred, these psy-
chologists made additional requests of the APA. They called
on the APA to develop a code of professional ethics. They
sought help in protecting the label “psychologist.” They called
for changes in graduate training that included additional ap-
plied psychology experiences, including internships (which
had begun as early as 1908 but were still uncommon, see
Routh, 2000). And, they asked that psychology departments
hire more faculty who had significant practical experience.
Except for some minimal gestures toward the applied group,
the APA largely ignored those requests that were important for
the professionalization of psychology, reminding the group of
its mantra that the APA was a scientific association.
Throughout the 1920s, more than a dozen applied psy-
chology groups were formed, most of them state associations.
The largest of those was the New York State Association of
Consulting Psychologists, which had begun in 1921. By
1930, it was clear to the professional psychologists that the