Islam and the Future of Tolerance: A Dialogue

(lily) #1
107

some very ugly truths— which puts one in mind of
the doctrine of taqqiya, wherein it is said that Mus-
lims are encouraged to lie to infi dels whenever it
serves their purpose. I hope you will enlighten me
about that. But before you do, I’ll give you another
example, from a non- Muslim context, to show you
how weird these conversations with the devout can
sometimes be.
I once attended a wedding where I was intro-
duced to a close friend of the groom. As it turned
out, this man was an Orthodox Jew. After a suitable
period of small talk, I said, “What’s your opinion of
all the barbarism in Leviticus, Deuteronomy, and
Exodus? For instance, what do you make of that bit
about a woman’s not being a virgin on her wedding
night— should we really take her to her father’s door-
step and stone her to death?^19 Seems a bit harsh. And
I rather like this woman our friend is marrying.”
My companion then began to wax rabbinical on
how these seemingly brutal strictures must be un-
derstood in the context of their time. Needless to
say, he assured me that they don’t apply today. In
fact, he said, these rules applied only when there



  1. Deuteronomy 22:13–21.


Bereitgestellt von | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Angemeldet
Free download pdf