TheReligionofLoveand
thePuritansofIslam:
SufiSourcesof √Æfiæ’sAnti-clericalism
LeonardLewisohn
Mise-en-scène
There exists a strong tradition of parody and satire of religious dignitaries among
thePersianpoetsthatcanbetracedbacktotheearlySeljukperiod,^1 whichmakesit
possibletospeakofanti-clericalisminIslamassimultaneouslyasocialphenomenon,
literary topos and spiritual attitude. Although caricature and castigation of figures
belonging to both the esoteric Sufi and exoteric clerical hierarchy appear among
nearlyallclassicalPersianpoets–Sanā’ī,‘Aṭṭār,NizārīQuhistānīand‘UbaydZakānī
inparticular–Ḥāfiẓ’sDīvānisuniqueinbeingalmostentirelyanti-clericalincom-
position.^2 In fact, one may say that his poems are as virulently anti-clerical as the
communist poetry of Vladimir Mayakowsky and Nazim Hikmat in early twentieth-
century Russia and Turkey are rabidly anti-capitalist. Yet Ḥāfiẓ’s anti-clericalism
comprisesnotsimplysocio-politicalcriticismwithareligiousveneer.Itrepresents
his own original, hypersophisticated psychological re-evaluation of religious ideas
andvalues,theliteraryandreligioussourcesofwhicharedirectlyderivedfromSufi
ethicalandmetaphysicaldoctrines,aswellasteachingstakenfromtheQur’ānand
ḥadīth,nottomentionseveralothersources.Below,myfocusofconcernwillbeon
theSufiandotherspiritualsourcesofhisanti-clericalpoetics,andinparticulartwo
characters in his lexicon: the sanctimonious Muslim pharisee or puritan ascetic
(zāhid);andhisnemesis:theInspiredLibertine(rind).^3
TheGracelessZealotandtheCreedofLove
ForModesofFaith,letgracelesszealotsfight;
Hiscan’tbewrongwhoselifeisintheright.
AlexanderPope^4
Without exception, all members of the Muslim ‘clergy’^5 of Ḥāfiẓ’s day evoke his
scornandsatire.Thestockcharactersinthepoet’santi-clericallexiconincludethe