ThePrinciplesatWorkInPursuitof
Excellence
OverthealtarofachurchinVenicehangsaRenaissancepaintingthatisclearlyamasterpiece.For 100 lire(lessthanthepriceofapackageofciga-rettes),atouristcouldputonearphonesandlistenastherecordedvoiceofanartcriticexplainingthesignificanceoftheworkannounced,"Thisisthegreat-estpaintingintheworld."Sucharecklessstatementmighthaveledtheknowledgeabletouristtoaskforhis 100lireback.Andyet,despitethefactthatworksofartcannotberankedonanyabsoluteanduniversallyaccept-ablescale,likediamondsoreggs,judgmentsofartisticmeritarecontinu-allybeingmade.Thephotographer,wheneverhelooksthroughhisviewfinderorexamineshisnegativesinthedarkroom,mustchooseonepicture
outofallthepossibili-ties;hemustbeabletodecidewhichexposuresarebetterthanothers—and
understand,intuitivelyorlogically,why.Ifhecannotemployprinciplesofpho-tographytorecognizeexcellence,hecannevermakeagoodphotograph—
except
byluck.Thisbookhasapproachedthedifficultquestionofgaugingsuccessinpho-tographybyexploringtheprincipaloptionsinvolvedincreatingapicture.Ev-
eryobjecttobephotographedcanbeanalyzedforanumberofcharacteris-
tics.Itmayexhibitoneormoreofthebasiccomponentsofvision—suchas
shape,texture,formandcolor—andthecomponentscanbearranged
withinthepictureframetogeneratevisualinteractionsthatsuggestsuchqualitiesas
balance,rhythm,proportion,dominanceandsubordination.InthehumorousphotographofaParisiancafedancerontheprecedingpage,forexample,AndreKerteszemployedthecontrastsbetweendarkandlighttomakean
abstractdesignatthesametimethattheyfocusattentiononthedancerandthepiecesofsculpturethatflankher.Thewittyparallelsbetweenthedancer's
poseandthesculpturewerealsodeliberatelysetuptocreateasenseoffun,satirizing
theexaggeratedshapesandgesturesofthestatues,forarrange-
ments
ofvisualelementscanbe(andgenerallyare)manipulatedtoshowacertainresponseonthepartofthephotographer—thatis,hisinterpretationof
themeaningofthesubject.
Thephotographer
alsomay
indicatehisintentthroughhisrepresentationofasenseof
time—acleverlyseizedinstantofaction,forexample,orarandomly
chosenmoment—orhemayachievehispurposebyhisbasicapproachto
photography,choosingeithertheorthodoxideaofphotographs
assmall,flatobjectsthatdepictreality
by
recordinglight
onfilm,
orsomenewerschemesuch
asscratchingonrawfilm,aprocessthatdoesnotdependonlightand
disregardsreality.
All
theseconsiderationsareanalogoustoamapofphotographicpossibli-ties.Thephotographerwhoisawareoftheregionsdescribed
by
thismapis
muchmorelikely
toreachhisgoalofexcellencethantheonewhoproceeds