Clinical Diagnosis and Assessment 105
(a question that contemporary science is just beginning to try to answer). They
look to ancestral spirits for an answer to such a question, even when a particular
person is beset with mental rather than physical symptoms. A fi rst experience
of hallucinations and delusions may signal the beginning of a long and chronic
course of schizophrenia, or it may be a one-time occurrence brought on in part
by extreme stress or severe substance intoxication. In the latter case in Zimba-
bwe, the hallucinations and delusions are viewed as signs that the individual is
being called to become a healer, a n’anga, and not as indicators of mental illness.
Thus, knowledge of the patient’s culture infl uences how an outside researcher
such as Linde understands the symptoms. When a patient in Zimbabwe claims to
be hearing voices of dead ancestors, Linde undoubtedly interprets this symptom
somewhat differently than he would if a white, American-born patient made the
same claim. At the same time, knowledge of a patient’s family history of chronic
schizophrenia (which may indicate a neurological factor—genetic, in this case) will
also infl uence the interpretation of the patient’s symptoms. Thus, assessment of each
type of factor can infl uence the assessment of the other types.
However, comprehensive assessment of all three factors in the same pa-
tient is extremely costly and rarely undertaken. Formal testing beyond a brief
questionnaire that the patient completes independently can be relatively ex-
pensive, and often health insurance companies will not pay for routine assess-
ments; they will pay only for specific assessment procedures or tests that they
have authorized in advance, based on indications of clear need (Eisman et al.,
2000). Beyond an interview, other forms of assessment are most likely to occur
as part of a legal proceeding (e.g., custody hearing or sentencing determina-
tion) or as part of a research project related to psychological disorders and
their treatment.
Key Concepts and Facts About Assessing Psychological Disorders
- An assessment may be performed in order to obtain additional
information for a diagnosis, monitor the course of symptoms,
determine what type of treatment might be most benefi cial, or
monitor the progress of treatment. - Assessment tools and techniques must be reliable and valid,
and clinicians should take care to compare a patient’s assess-
ment data to an appropriate norm for the patient’s background. - Neurological and other biological factors may be assessed with
various methods. Neuroimaging techniques can assess brain
structure (X-rays, computerized axial tomography, and mag-
netic resonance imaging) and brain function (positron emis-
sion tomography and functional magnetic resonance imaging).
Neurotransmitter levels can be assessed through magnetic
resonance spectroscopy, and neurotransmitter and hormone
by-products can be measured in blood, urine, and cerebrospinal
fl uid. Neuropsychological testing can assess brain functioning.- Various methods are used to assess psychological factors.
These include the clinical interview (unstructured, structured,
or semistructured), observing the patient (e.g., appearance and
behavior), the patient’s self-report, and the reports of others
involved in the patient’s life. Each method has advantages and
limitations. Specific aspects of psychological functioning can
be assessed through tests of cognitive abilities and personality
functioning can be assessed with inventories, questionnaires,
and projective tests. - Some techniques used to assess psychological factors (such
as interviews and questionnaires) also can be used to assess
social factors—such as family functioning—as well as to provide
a more detailed portrait of the patient’s community and culture.
These social factors affect, and are affected by, neurological and
psychological factors.
- Various methods are used to assess psychological factors.
P S
N
Diagnosing and Assessing Rose Mary
and Rex Walls
Now that you know something about diagnosis and assessment, let’s review what
we know—and what we don’t know—about the Rose Mary and Rex Walls, start-
ing with Rex. We know that he drank alcohol—regularly and to excess. In fact,