The Psychology of Gender 4th Edition

(Tuis.) #1
Sex-Related Comparisons: Observations 103

If there are more similarities than


differences between women and men,


why does it seem that women and men


are so different? Why do books like John


Gray’s (1992)Men Are from Mars, Women


ArefromVenusbecome best sellers if men


and women are not opposites? Why did


my father respond to the publication of


this textbook by saying, “If you can figure


out why men and women are so differ-


ent, that would become a best seller!” One


reason is that differences are more salient


and more provocative than similarities. I


mentioned in Chapter 1 that sex is a very


salient attribute of a person. Thus when


two people perform differently on a task


and we look for an explanation, we can


easily draw the inference that sex must be


the distinguishing factor. Second, we have


stereotypes about men’s and women’s


behavior that are quite strong and quite


distinct. We often recall information that


confirms our stereotypes and disregard


information that disconfirms our stereo-


types. This is calledconfirmatory hypoth-


esis testing. We are most likely to do this


when we have strong expectations, when


the stereotype is about a group, and when


the stereotype is about a trait (Stangor &


McMillan, 1992). For example, one ste-


reotype about babies is that males are


more active than females. Several years


ago, my husband and I were visiting some


neighbors. There was a male infant and a


female infant, both of whom seemed in-


tent on tearing up the house! The mother


of the male infant remarked, “Isn’t it true


about how much more active boys are


than girls? Look at Justin compared to


of body fat than men. These are bio-


logical facts. However, even within the


realm of biology, a great number of sim-


ilarities exist between women and men.


Most women and men have two eyes,


two arms, and two legs; most women


and men have a heart, lungs, and vocal


cords with which they can speak. The


same logic applies to the cognitive and


social domains. Although there may be


some differences, by far, women and


men have more in common in the way


they think and in the way they behave.


If there are so many similarities be-


tween women and men, why do we focus


on differences? Belle (1985) suggests that


we tend to focus on differences when we


are confronted with two of anything. For


example, parents with two children are


more likely than parents of three or more


children to emphasize the differences


between the children: “Jennifer is better


in math than Matthew; Matthew is bet-


ter in geography than Jennifer.” Parents


with three children, however, are more


likely to describe each child individu-


ally without making a comparison to the


other children: “Mary is good in math,


Johnny is good in geography, Paul is


good in English.” Belle also reported that


the same phenomenon occurs among


anthropologists studying two kinds


of cultures. Whereas two cultures are


often described in comparison to one


another, anthropologists who study more


than two cultures emphasize the diver-


sity of human nature. Thus we would be


less likely to emphasize sex differences if


there were at least three sexes!


M04_HELG0185_04_SE_C04.indd 103 6/21/11 8:02 AM

Free download pdf