Recommendations
and Reviews
‘Jack Smart and John Haldane are both remarkable philosophers. Each in
his own way possesses the rare combination of formidable dialectical skills, an
original vision for philosophy, and immense personal integrity.’
Hilary Putnam, Harvard University.
‘Philosophers of both theistic and atheistic persuasions will find this import-
ant new debate on theism particularly interesting for themselves and for their
students.’
Linda Zagzebski, University of Oklahoma.
‘The discussions contain some outstanding treatments.’
William Alston, The Philosophical Quarterly.
‘One of the most pleasing aspects of this book is the clarity and lack of
evasion shown by its authors... a splendid volume.’
James Baillie, Philosophical Books.
‘At this stage in history, it’s hard for a book about God’s existence to come
across as a must-read... By that stringent test, this book is unusually suc-
cessful. The authors are to be congratulated on producing a remarkable and
valuable book.’
Timothy Chappell, Mind.
‘Both authors write with clarity and verve and evident conviction.’
William Lane Craig, Ratio.