Cities of God: The Religion of the Italian Communes 1125-1325

(Darren Dugan) #1

 122 LaCitadeSancta


was fitting for celestial defenders of the republic, one held a cross and the


other the communal banner. The image carried the inscription ‘‘Justice,


Mercy, Truth, and Peace.’’^136 As for the Mother Church, so for the city’s


nonecclesiastical buildings. On 20 May of the same year, the fathers commis-


sioned a painting of the Virgin and San Giminiano for the Palazzo del Po-


polo, ‘‘that they might protect and extend the liberty of the people of


Modena.’’ Oil lamps illuminated the new images at night.^137


Such artistic embellishments made a doctrinal statement. Cities placed


images over their gates to proclaim communal orthodoxy. ‘‘Let images be


placed over the five major gates of the city in honor of the Blessed Virgin,


Saint Michael the Archangel, Saint Christopher, Saint Peter, and the blessed


martyrs Felix and Fortunatus; and let this be completed between Easter and


the first of August,’’ ordered the commune of Vicenza in 1262 —a visible


declaration of orthodoxy after the expulsion of the impious and heretical da


Romano tyranny.^138 Attitude toward cultic images of the saints could, in fact,


be a litmus test of orthodoxy. The notary Ugonetto de’ Molari was walking


one day with two acquaintances. He suggested that they drop into a church


and pray there before the images of the saints. His friends agreed to come


and pray, but refused to venerate the images. Such images were made ‘‘more


for worldly use than out of devotion.’’ They certainly were ‘‘worldly’’ in the


sense of ‘‘communal’’ and ‘‘civic.’’ But they were holy objects of devotion as


well. The inquisitor who took down Ugonetto’s words concluded the men


were heretics, under the influence of some Waldensian preacher.^139 Perhaps


they were from another city as well. Honoring images of the saints proved


both Catholic and communal identity.


Bologna commissioned marble images of Saints Peter and Paul to embel-


lish the major portal of the duomo, a sign of fidelity to the Roman See.^140 At


Pisa in 1275 , the new podesta pledged himself to assure, in cooperation with


the officials of the city, that images of the Virgin, Saint Peter, and Saint


Mark be painted over the principal gates. He became responsible for their


preservation.^141 Sacred images embellished city palaces—sometimes flanked


by paintings of condemned criminals. Heaven might mix with hell in scenes


worthy of Dante. Padua ordered counterfeiters to be depicted on the com-


munal palace walls, with bags of false money around their necks. The Pa-


duan damned took their place beside the city’s saints. The city’sLiber


Falsariorumlists the names of some one hundred counterfeiters for the period



  1. Modena Stat. ( 1306 / 7 ), 1 : 99 ; on this sculpture, see Webb,Patrons, 124 – 25.

  2. Modena Stat. ( 1306 / 7 ), 1 : 158 – 59.

  3. Vicenza Stat. ( 1264 ), 3 – 7.

  4. Alberto of Castellario, ‘‘Inquisicio que fit et fieri intenditur per fratrem Albertum de Castelario
    de Cuneo inquisitorem ( 1335 ),’’ ed. Grado G. Merlo, ( 13 ), Merlo,Eretici e inquisitori, 166.
    140 .CCB:Vill. ( 1223 ), 87 ; later further embellished with columns:CCB:A, B, Vill. ( 1252 ), 131.

  5. Pisa Stat.i( 1275 ), pp. 46 and 52 ; repairs were ordered a decade later: ibid. ( 1286 ), 1. 154 , pp.
    264 – 65.

Free download pdf