Cities of God: The Religion of the Italian Communes 1125-1325

(Darren Dugan) #1

 388 BuoniCattolici


£ 3 ; and Nuta, avestita,£ 2. Perhaps strangely for a Gray Penitent, her one


corporate donation (£ 50 ) went, not to the Franciscans, but to the Domini-


cans.^37 Only one male’s will, that of Bello Ferrantini of Florence ( 27 May


1277 ), exhibits the concern for family and individuals seen in these women’s


wills. He left £ 800 flor. parv. to his daughters, and his horse to a friend. But


his familial piety was overshadowed by a grant of £ 1000 flor. parv. to the


poor and ‘‘pious places’’ (piis locis). This sum and some small grants to local


churches were disbursed at the discretion of the ministers of the Black Peni-


tents.^38 Perhaps he had neglected to make provision for his family earlier.


If this small sample reflects more general concerns, dying men thought


first of the poor, perhaps because in life they had victimized them by taking


usury. After that, they favored larger local religious communities. The


women, perhaps unburdened by social sins, bestowed their charity on indi-


viduals, especially needy people they knew or simply on their friends. Mass


bequests are rare. That duty normally devolved on the relatives, friends, and


neighbors. The narrowly expiatory and personal focus of wills, even those of


these professionally pious penitents, moved some communes to enact laws


modifying testamentary provisions to provide for public charities. In 1250 ,


Bologna ordered that one tenth of all testaments go to the reconstruction of


the duomo, since ‘‘that church is the mother of all the churches of the clergy


and laity of the city... and the Lord said to honor your father and


mother.’’^39 A benefaction to the duomo would have worked to the glory of


the city and pleased God, but it seems that the dying seldom made it. On


the other hand, it does seem that the dying heard the call for more socially


conscious benefactions generally. Over all, our period saw an increase in


bequests to religious entities, especially hospitals.^40


After the foreboding task of drafting a will, the ministering priest urged


the one dying to make a full and humble confession, omitting nothing. Ex-


tant rituals give forms for this general confession.^41 These rites preserve the


old dialogue format of the twelfth century. The priest began by examining


the dying on the articles of the faith, using a question-and-answer format


not unlike that used at baptism, although somewhat more extended. This


examination not only excluded heretics from the consolations of the Church


but reminded Catholics that confession was a ‘‘second baptism.’’ If under-


taken in faith, it left the one confessing in a state of innocence, ready to



  1. Ibid., 30 , pp. 219 – 20.

  2. Ibid., 15 ,p. 198.

  3. Bologna Stat.i( 1250 ), 5. 6 , 1 : 443 – 44 : ‘‘Quia ecclesia sancti petri episcopatus bon. mater est et
    capud omnium ecclesiarum clericorum et laicorum habitancium jn civitate predicta et eiusdem diocesis,
    et ab eis omnibus debeat exaltari et honorari dicente Domino honora patrem et matrem tuam ut sis
    longevus super terram, quod de matre spirituali que nos regenerat debeat intelligi.’’

  4. A change that Antonio Rigon, ‘‘Orientamenti religiosi e pratica testamentaria a Padova nei secoli
    xii–xiv(prime ricerche),’’Nolens Intestatus Decedere, 51 , calls, using the words of Vauchez, a ‘‘re ́volution de
    la charite ́.’’

  5. I follow here the forms found in theRituale di Hugo [di Volterra], 285 – 87 (ca. 1180 ).

Free download pdf