Italian Ceramics: Catalogue of the J. Paul Getty Museum Collection

(Nancy Kaufman) #1

i2-i, 73);^22 the sacrifice of Iphigenia (Ecouen, Musee de


la Renaissance, inv. Cluny 1863);^23 the death of Achilles


(New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art, inv. 84.3.2J,-^24


and an allegorical scene with Calliope and a youth


(Washington, D.C., Corcoran Gallery of Art, inv. 26.


348).^25 Five other pieces with scenes of Saint George and


the Dragon, Perseus and Andromeda, the Brazen Bull of


Phalaris, Cygnus changed into a swan, and an uniden­


tified subject are in the Royal Scottish Museum, Edin­


burgh.^26 A final plate with the Rape of Europa, whose


present whereabouts are unknown, was formerly in the


Damiron collection, Lyons.^27 Subjects drawn from


Ovid's Metamorphoses—and loosely based on the illus­


trations to the 1497 Venice edition of that book^28 —pre­


dominate on the Calini service. The inclusion of the


Brazen Bull subject from the first-century moralizing an­


ecdotes of Valerius Maximus (available in Italian at the


time) and the thirteenth-century Golden Legend tale of


Saint George and the Dragon,^29 makes a unified icono-


graphic program for the Calini service elusive.


An intriguing subject for further research involves


the possibility that a group of individuals from Brescia


and Mantua, linked by family and politics, might have


helped to spread Nicola's fame and expand his patronage


in the early 1520s. (It would not have been unusual for


them to discuss the appeal of maiolica table services


decorated with beautiful painting and intellectually


stimulating iconography, along with other topics of


artistic and humanist interest.) Certainly we know that


during this period Nicola produced services for two Man-


tuans (Isabella d'Este Gonzaga and Federico Gonzaga),


for one Brescian family (the Calini, heirs to the Gambara


family),^30 and for the marriage of a Mantuan man (Va-


lente Valenti, who was given an important concession by
Francesco Gonzaga in 1518) to a Brescian woman
(Violante Gambara who, like Isabella d'Este, was a
woman of letters). It is interesting to note that the Man-
zoli fragment belonging to Nicola's final service from
this period ended up in the collection of the counts of
Gonzaga of Novellara, possibly passed on by a member of
the Manzoli family to a Gonzaga on the transfer of the
title of patriarch of Alessandria.^31

Notes


  1. Bohn 1857, 185, no. 1767.

  2. Kube 1976, no. 58.

  3. Giacomotti 1974, no. 829.

  4. Conti 1971A, no. 16.

  5. Liverani 1985, nos. 4-6, pi. 125; Wilson 1987A, 44-45, 49, no. 62;
    Palvarini 1994, 10-17.

  6. Wilson 1987A, 50, no. 63.

  7. Darcel 1864, 181; Berardi 1984, 17 n. 9; Negroni 1985, 15-20; Mallet
    1987, 284-86.

  8. For an examination of the artist's life and work see, in addition to the
    works cited above, Rasmussen 1972, 51-64; Wilson 1987A, 44-51;
    Palvarini 1994, 11-12.

  9. Mallet 1998, 286.

  10. Wallen 1968, 95-105; Negroni 1985, 13-20.

  11. Examples from this service are reproduced in Chambers and Martineau
    1981, nos. 131-33, 135-36, 138; Rasmussen 1989, 110-11, no. 66; for
    the dating of this set see Mallet, "The Gonzaga and Ceramics," in
    Chambers and Martineau 1981, 40.

  12. Also called the Ridolfi Service. Wallis 1905; Mariacher 1958, 8-27;
    Cherido 1986, 73-79.

  13. Palvarini 1989-90, 151-64.

  14. Palvarini 1994, 10-17.

  15. Mallet, "The Gonzaga and Ceramics," in Chambers and Martineau
    1981 , 40; see also examples reproduced as nos. 194-95, 197.

  16. The arms include a ladder, whose rungs are called scalini in Italian. The
    word becomes calini when pronounced with a Brescian accent that
    drops the initial "s" sound in words where the "s" is followed by a con­
    sonant (I am grateful to Brescian architect and historian Valentino Volta
    for his information regarding this and other things Brescian). For
    identification of these arms see Ravanelli Guidotti 1985A, 394-99; for
    a discussion of the Calini family see Schrattenhofen 1927, 243-57; and
    for the postulation that this service may have been executed for Luigi
    Calini on the occasion of the 1525 birth of his first son, Muzio Calini,
    see Watson 1986, 112-14. F°r further biographical information, see
    Spreti [1928-35] 1969, 2: 246, s.v. "Calini"; Dizionario biografico
    i960- 725, s.v. "Calini."

  17. The woodcuts are reproduced in Wallis 1905, 39, 51, figs. 16, 22.

  18. Mallet 1981, 175-78, in particular, no. 133.

  19. For a discussion of architecture in Nicola's work see Rackham 1945,
    144-48; for a general examination of architecture painted on maiolica
    see Bernardi 1980. See also Manara 2000, 83-101.

  20. Renaissance artists often replaced the ancient aulos (reed flute) men­
    tioned in the legend with its contemporary counterpart, the zampogna
    (bagpipe) (Winternitz 1959, 187-89).

  21. The woodcuts are reproduced in Wallis 1905, 39-40, figs. 16-17.

  22. Wilson 1987A, no. 53.

  23. Giacomotti 1974, no. 820.

  24. Rackham 1928B, pi. 3D.
    25. Watson 1986, no. 45.
    26. Curnow 1992, 59-63, nos. 62-66. Except for the Getty Museum's plate,
    all the Calini pieces are illustrated in Rackham 1928B, pis. 1-4.
    27. Sale cat., Sotheby's, 1938, lot 57; Rackham 1937B, 256, fig. 9.
    28. See, for example, the comparisons made by Rackham 1928B, pi. 3D.


148 Armorial Dish with the Flaying of Marsyas
Free download pdf