THE MAKING OF MEANING ■ 223
of this dialectic tension, this alternation between differentiation on the
one hand and integration on the other. From this point of view, individ-
ual life appears to consist of a series of different “games,” with different
goals and challenges, that change with time as a person matures. Com
plexity requires that we invest energy in developing whatever skills we
were born with, in becoming autonomous, self-reliant, conscious of our
uniqueness and of its limitations. At the same time we must invest
energy in recognizing, understanding, and finding ways to adapt to the
forces beyond the boundaries of our own individuality. Of course we
don’t have to undertake any of these plans. But if we don’t, chances are,
sooner or later, we will regret it.
Forging Resolve
Purpose gives direction to one’s efforts, but it does not necessarily make
life easier. Goals can lead into all sorts of trouble, at which point one
gets tempted to give them up and find some less demanding script by
which to order one’s actions. The price one pays for changing goals
whenever opposition threatens is that while one may achieve a more
pleasant and comfortable life, it is likely that it will end up empty and
void of meaning.
The Pilgrims who first settled this country decided that the free
dom to worship according to their conscience was necessary to maintain
the integrity of their selves. They believed that nothing mattered more
than maintaining control over their relationship with the supreme
being. Theirs was not a novel choice for an ultimate goal by which to
order one’s life—many other people had done so previously. What
distinguished the Pilgrims was that—like the Jews of Masada, the Chris
tian martyrs, the Cathars of southern France in the late Middle Ages
who had chosen similarly—they did not allow persecution and hardship
to blunt their resolve. Instead they followed the logic of their convictions
wherever it led, acting as if their values were worth giving up comfort,
and even life itself, for. And because they acted thus, their goals in fact
became worthwhile regardless of whether they had been originally valu
able. Because their goals had become valuable through commitment,
they helped give meaning to the Pilgrims’ existence.
No goal can have much effect unless taken seriously. Each goal
prescribes a set of consequences, and if one isn’t prepared to reckon with
them, the goal becomes meaningless. The mountaineer who decides to
scale a difficult peak knows that he will be exhausted and endangered
for most of the climb. But if he gives up too easily, his quest will be