The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are So Rich and Some So Poor (W W Norton & Company; 1998)

(Nora) #1

(^544) NOTES



  1. Fukazawa, "Non-Agricultural Production," pp. 314-15.

  2. Raychaudhuri, "Non-Agricultural Production," p. 286.

  3. Thus Raychaudhuri, ibid., p. 295: "If necessity is the mother of invention, its
    pressure in the Indian case was not insistent."

  4. Ibid., pp. 286-87.

  5. F. Buchanan, A Journey from Madras... (1807), cited ibid., p. 291. Raychaud-
    huri agrees.

  6. Brennig, "Textile Producers," p. 86. The words in quotes are his.

  7. On these Banjara (a nomadic caste) caravans, see Habib, Agrarian System, p. 62,
    and Brennig, "Textile Producers," pp. 68-69. As Brennig puts it, "time was of little
    importance."

  8. Chaudhuri, Trading World, Appendix 5, Table C.20, pp. 540-41.

  9. Wadsworth and Mann, The Cotton Trade, p. 117.

  10. Spear, The Nabobs, p. 75. Indian shipbuilders, be it noted, were highly reputed and
    built vessels not only for locals but for customers in other parts of Asia. The Europeans
    relied on them almost exclusively, not only because their work was good (teak was bet-
    ter than oak) and cost less, but also because European-made vessels were already in
    well-used condition by the time they reached the Indian Ocean.

  11. Habib, "Potentialities," p. 63.

  12. Raychaudhuri, "Non-Agricultural Production," p. 292, speaks of Indian ship-
    wrights riveting planks and says this was superior to European caulking. Is this a mis-
    reading for "rabbeting"? On Indian techniques, see Barendse, "Shipbuilding" and
    Bhattacharya, "A Note on Shipbuilding." This ferruginous temper was an old story in
    Europe. Gimpel, Medieval Machine, pp. 65-66, cites the number and variety of nails
    kept in store: half a million in Calais in 1390; tens of thousands in a dozen different
    sizes (listed with their prices) at York Castie in 1327. The specialization of nails by use
    is indicative of the sophistication of this technology.

  13. Kuppuram, "A Survey of Some Select Industries," p. 46.

  14. Habib, "Potentialities," p. 62 and n. 4, citing J. Ovington, A Voyage to Surat in
    the Tear 1689 (London, 1929), pp. 166-67. Ovington says that Indian craftsmen
    found it hard to make clocks because dust clogged the wheels. Implausible. That may
    have been a problem, but not insoluble with Indian technology. As for Chinese clocks,
    they were poor imitations of European work. On Claude Martin, who left a large es-
    tate that still finances schools called La Martinière in Lucknow, Calcutta, and Lyons,
    see Landes, Revolution in Time and Vheure qu'il est.

  15. Chaudhuri, Trading World, pp. 273-74. Cf. Bernier, Voyage dans les états, p. 168.

  16. Kerr, "Colonialism and Technological Choice," pp. 95-97. Kerr sees the Indian
    choice as quite rational, but rationality is a function of ends as well as means.


CHAPTER 16


  1. Cf. the references to McCloskey in Landes, "Fable," p. 163, n. 27. Pollard, Peace-
    ful Conquest, does not see the story of European industrialization as one of strenuous
    response to the British challenge, but rather as a harmonious diffusion of technology
    along lines defined by the market. It was that... too. Cf. Davis, "Industrialization in
    Britain and Europe," pp. 54-55.

  2. Cited by Crouzet, De la supériorité, p. 105.

  3. Ibid., p. 107.

  4. Voltaire, Essai sur les moeurs et l'esprit des nations (Paris: Garnier, 1963), II,
    695-97; cited in Crouzet, "Les Français," p. 24. The date of the first Navigation Act
    was actually 1651, followed by another in 1660, just after the restoration of the monar-
    chy.

Free download pdf