Reinventing Romantic Poetry : Russian Women Poets of the Mid-nineteenth Century

(Wang) #1

type of the poet, egoism, escapism), literary primitivism (bards, minstrels,


ballads, and romances), and a return to nature—and, one could add, the


search for nation—women poets more typically concerned themselves


with female heroism; female desire; domestic affections; home, family,


and community; female childhood; education; motherhood; and careers


(Wolfson, “Romanticism and Gender,” 385–96). If Romanticism describes


only the concerns of men, it may not make sense to speak of women Ro-


mantic poets—unless we expand our definition of Romanticism.


This is not to suggest that these women poets did not write lyrics on

the Romantic themes of the poet, nature, and nation, as well as love


lyrics. We have seen in chapter 2 that they did, although usually from


their own point of view. I would suggest, however, that because the work


of women poets does not conform to the gender norms of Romantic po-


etry—for example, the male’s quest to be reunited with the female


Other—their work has been marginalized or considered insufficiently


intellectual, philosophical, or “universal.” Of course, middle- and


upper-class women—whose lives were characterized by physical, le-


gal, and often psychological limitations, financial dependency, and


expected subservience to men—would not have found relevant the


metaphor of a quest, even for a male Other. Nor could the German


philosophical striving for an idealized yet sexualized “eternal femi-


nine” serve as a tenable basis for their poetry. In addition, the mythol-


ogy available to men poets could not help them depict women’s expe-


riences. A recent study of Romanticism includes chapters on the male


archetypes of Werther, Faust, Prometheus, Napoleon, the dandy, and


Don Juan.^57 The only female Romantic archetype discussed is La Belle


Dame Sans Merci, a soulless man-destroying character, who has much


in common with the archetype that Dolores Barracano Schmidt calls


the “Great American Bitch” (“The Great American Bitch,” 900–905).


Like their European counterparts, these Russian women poets in

their lyrics not only reinterpreted male Romantic themes but also


treated the “women’s themes” just mentioned. Images of female hero-


ism, for example, appear in Kul’man’s poems about Korinna and Sap-


pho, Pavlova’s “Jeanne d’Arc” ( 1839 ), Rostopchina’s “Kak liubiat zhen-


shchiny: predsmertnaia duma Sharloty Stiglits” (How women love:


The dying thoughts of Charlotte Stieglitz, 1841 ), Bakunina’s “legend in


verse” about the early Christian martyr Iulianiia Nikomidiiskaia ( 1849 ),


and in Fuks’s Osnovanie goroda Kazani( 1837 ). The theme of female desire


appears in the lyrics of almost all these women poets, but without the


pornographic overtones that often accompany descriptions of male de-


Gender and Genre 83

Free download pdf