Teaching Critical Thinking in Psychology: A Handbook of Best Practices

(ff) #1

Nina Lamson & Katherine Kipp


248


words on the cell phone as they walked the maze. The instructor analyzed and shared the


data with the students for inclusion in the Results section and for drawing conclusions in


the Discussion section as to how the findings relate to the possible effects of cell phone use


while driving.


Steps 1, 2, 3: “Literature Review”

For each of these three steps, students read an article on cell phone use and driving. For


each article students then answer 9 to 12 questions pertaining to the goal, methodology,


outcome, and conclusions. These modules expose the students to how to investigate a


question of interest. In class, lecture and discussions draw parallels between the scientific


method and the execution of a research study.


Step 1 (Strayer & Johnston, 2001) sample questions: “What are the two hypotheses


stated that guide the research on cell phone use and driving? (Hint: they


are set in italics in the introduction sections.) What is the focus of each?”


Step 2 (Spence & Read, 2003) sample question: “What was considered the single


task and what was considered the dual task?”


Step 3 (Radeborg, Briem, & Hedman, 1999) sample question: “What was the


principal result of the study as presented in the discussion section?”


Steps 4–10: Conducting, Writing, and Presenting the Research

Step 4: The Introduction

Here students use an “introduction template,” and they fill in the missing information


based on what they learned in Steps 1–3. They also correctly cite the sources, based on


provided APA-style examples (American Psychological Association, 2001), and create a


title page. This module allows the students to see the type of information included in an


introduction, how to write it, and, most importantly, how a hypothesis emerges from


exploring the literature.


Step 5: The Method Section

Students write this section after they conduct or participate in the in-class experiment.


They learn that the purpose of the Method section is to outline how to test the


hypothesis. They learn that it is important to be precise so that another researcher


could duplicate the study. To complete this step, students receive guidelines as to what


information they should include. They use a diagram of a simplified method section to


complete this section.

Free download pdf