71
The Challenge of Assessing Critical Thinking
Information Literacy Exceeds Meets Fails
Identifies acceptable types of source material
Conducts appropriate search strategy
Uses criteria to determine fitness of source material
Generates sufficient breadth in selected resources
Evaluates overall quality of support material
Appendix 2
Up to Speed Worksheet Name____
#1: Research Methods Value: 5 = solid preparation
10 of 12 counted for max of 50 pts 3 = fair preparation
1/6 of course points 1 = minimal preparation
Show & Tell: Find an example in the popular press or advertising industry where there is a
problematic cause–effect claim. How would you use experimental design to support or
disconfirm that claim?
Your question from chapter:
Talking points from chapter:
Appendix 3
Honors Introductory Psychology Presenter__
Presentation Criteria Topic_____
Reviewer__
Each of the criteria below should be worth a maximum of 5 points. Use the following scale
to make your judgment about quality achieved in each criterion:
5 = excellence 2 = serious difficulty
4 = minor difficulty 1 = minimal effort/achievement
3 = moderate difficulty 0 = no achievement