The Language of Argument

(singke) #1
2 6 0

C HaP Te r 1 1 ■ C h a n c e s


  1. What would Wendy’s chances of having colon cancer be if the other
    probabilities remained the same as in the original example, except that
    the conditional probability that the test is positive, given that the patient
    does not have colon cancer, is 1 percent (or 0.01)?

  2. What would Wendy’s chances of having colon cancer be if the other
    probabilities remained the same as in the original example, except that
    the conditional probability that the test is positive, given that the patient
    does not have colon cancer, is 10 percent (0.1)?

  3. Chris tested positive for cocaine once in a random screening test. This
    test has a sensitivity and specificity of 95 percent, and 20 percent of the
    students in Chris’s school use cocaine. What is the probability that Chris
    really did use cocaine?

  4. As in problem 7, 20 percent of the students in Chris’s school use cocaine,
    but this time Chris tests positive for cocaine on two independent tests,
    both of which have a sensitivity and specificity of 95 percent. Now what
    is the probability that Chris really did use cocaine?

  5. In your neighborhood, 20 percent of the houses have high levels of
    radon gas in their basements, so you ask an expert to test your basement.
    An inexpensive test comes out positive in 80 percent of the basements
    that actually have high levels of radon, but it also comes out positive
    in 10 percent of the basements that do not have high levels of radon. If
    this inexpensive test comes out positive in your basement, what is the
    probability that there is a high level of radon gas in your basement?

  6. A more expensive test for radon is also more accurate. It comes out
    positive in 99 percent of the basements that actually have high levels
    of radon. It also tests positive in 2 percent of the basements that do not
    high levels of radon. As in problem 7, 20 percent of the houses in your
    neighborhood have radon in their basement. If the expensive test comes
    out positive in your basement, what is the probability that there is a high
    level of radon gas in your basement?

  7. Late last night a car ran into your neighbor and drove away. In your
    town, there are 500 cars, and 2 percent of them are Porsches. The only
    eyewitness to the hit-and-run says the car that hit your neighbor was
    a Porsche. Tested under similar conditions, the eyewitness mistakenly
    classifies cars of other makes as Porsches 10 percent of the time, and
    correctly classifies Porsches as such 80 percent of the time. What are the
    chances that the car that hit your neighbor really was a Porsche?

  8. Late last night a dog bit your neighbor. In your town, there are 400 dogs,
    95 percent of them are black Labrador retrievers, and the rest are pit bulls.
    The only eyewitness to the event, a veteran dog breeder, says that the
    dog who bit your neighbor was a pit bull. Tested under similar low-light
    conditions, the eyewitness mistakenly classifies black Labs as pit bulls
    only 2 percent of the time, and correctly classifies pit bulls as pit bulls
    90 percent of the time. What are the chances that dog who bit your
    neighbor really was a pit bull?


97364_ch11_ptg01_239-262.indd 260 15/11/13 10:58 AM


some third party content may be suppressed from the eBook and/or eChapter(s). Editorial review has deemed that any suppressed content does not materiallyCopyright 201^3 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part. Due to electronic rights,
affect the overall learning experience. Cengage Learning reserves the right to remove additional content at any time if subsequent rights restrictions require it.
Free download pdf