Women & Islamic Cultures Family, Law and Politics

(Romina) #1

the nursling’s mouth only or also other, indirect
ways, such as pouring milk from the breasts of a
woman into a strange infant’s mouth with no act of
sucking, giving an infant the milk of a strange
woman from a vessel, feeding an infant with bread
or with other kinds of food mixed with a strange
woman’s milk, or pouring strange woman’s milk
into an infant’s nose, eye, ear, and so forth? What is
the minimal number of sucklings that create an
impediment to marriage? What is the maximal age
at which breastfeeding creates an impediment to
marriage? Does the absorption of the milk of a
dead woman create an impediment to marriage?
Legal discussions on these themes reveal there was
much disagreement among those Muslim jurists
who tried to define exactly under which circum-
stances breastfeeding created impediments to mar-
riage. Fatwas, in many cases reflecting aspects of
daily life, are an indication of the relevance of these
questions in Muslim societies throughout premod-
ern times.
In Shì≠ìIslam, the rules of milk kinship were
developed along more or less the same lines as in
the Sunnìlaw. However, the discussion of milk kin-
ship in the writings of contemporary religious
scholars in Iran reveals some differences. For in-
stance, according to Ayatollah Khomeini, a mini-
mum of fifteen suckling sessions in succession are
needed to create a milk relationship between a
nursling and a non-maternal nurse, and the milk
must be suckled at the breast. Moreover, it is rec-
ommended that the wet nurse be a practicing
Twelver ImàmìShì≠ìMuslim. In practice, non-
maternal nurses have been employed in contem-
porary Iran only when it was absolutely essential
and attention has been paid to avoid the choice of
a wet nurse that could affect future marriage
arrangements.


overview 357

Bibliography
S. Altorki, Milk-kinship in Arab society. An unexplored
problem in the ethnography of marriage, in Ethnology
19 (1980), 233–44.
Bahrain, Ministry of Health, Bahrain child health survey
1989 , managing editor S. Farid, Manama 1992.
G. J. Ebrahim, Cross-cultural aspects of breast-feeding, in
Ciba Foundation, Breast-feeding and the mother,
Amsterdam 1976, 195–204.
A. Giladi, Breastfeeding in medieval Islamic thought. A
preliminary study of legal and medical writings, in
Journal of Family History 23 (1998), 107–23.
——, Infants, parents and wet nurses. Medieval Islamic
views on breastfeeding and their social implications,
Leiden 1999.
F. Héritier, Les deux soeurs et leur mère. Anthropologie de
l’inceste, Paris 1994.
A. al-Ka™làwì, Bunùk al-laban. Shubuhàt ™awla bunùk
al-laban. Diràsa fiqhiyya muqàrana, Cairo 1998.
J. Khatib-Chahidi, Milk kinship in Shi≠ite Islamic Iran, in
V. Maher (ed.), The anthropology of breast-feeding.
Natural law or social construct, Oxford 1992, 109-32.
——, Sexual prohibitions, shared space and fictive mar-
riages in Shi≠ite Iran in S. Ardener (ed.), Women and
space. Ground rules and social maps, London 1981,
112–35.
V. Maher, Breast-feeding in cross-cultural perspective.
Paradoxes and proposals, in V. Maher (ed.), The
anthropology of breast-feeding. Natural law or social
construct, Oxford 1992, 1–35.
Màlik b. Anas, al-Muwa††a±, n.p. 1977.
≠A. M. al-Najjàr, Mawqif al-islàm min bank laban al-
ummahàt, in Majallat al-Azhar 59 (1986), 447–55.
Oman, Ministry of Health, Oman child health survey, ed.
M. J. Suleiman, A. al-Ghassany, and S. Farid, Muscat
1992.
Oman, Ministry of Health, and Council of Health
Ministers of GCC States, Oman family health survey


  1. Principal Report, ed. A. J. M. Suleiman, A. al-
    Riyami, and S. Farid, Muscat 1996.
    Qatar, Ministry of Health, Qatar child health survey, ed.
    A. Salman, K. al-Jaber, and S. Farid, Doha 1991.
    Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Health, Saudi Arabia child
    health survey, ed. Y. al-Mazrou and S. Farid, Riyadh


  2. J. Schacht, J. Burton, and J. Chelhod, Ra∂à≠or Ri∂à≠a,
    Encyclopaedia of Islam, new ed., viii, 361–2.
    United Arab Emirates, United Arab Emirates child health
    survey, ed. A. al-Muhaideb et al., Abu Dhabi 1991.




Avner Giladi
Free download pdf