P 1 :JZP
0521551335 apx 2 CUNY 160 /Joannides 052155 133 1 January 11 , 2007 14 : 26
442 APPENDIX 2. THE LAWRENCE COLLECTION OF DRAWINGS- 1830 - 75 ?/ 1836 - 95 / 1850 - 112 /Weimar, Sachsen-Weimar
Collection (Von Ritgen photograph, 1865 ,no. 50 as
Michelangelo; Delacre, 1938 ,p. 315 )/Phillips, London, 7 July
1999 ,lot 121 ;black chalk, heightened with white, 398 ×
261 mm, as Roman School, sixteenth century. See 1850 - 112
for further details. - 1814 - 15 0 2,asfrom the collection of Lamberto
Gori/part of 1830 - 139 ?/ 1836 - 98 (with the provenance given
incorrectly as Buonarroti and Wicar, that from Gori
omitted)/ 1850 - 148 bought by Brondgeest/Weimar Sachsen-
Weimar Collection/Phillips, London, 7 July 1999 ,lot 119 ,
black chalk, 393 × 229 mm, as circle of Daniele da Volterra.
See 1850 - 148 for further details. - 1830 - 119 ?/ 1836 - 99 / 1850 - 15 6,bought by Brondgeest, 59
guilders. Not further identified; untraced. - 1830 - 17 / 1836 - 100 / 1838 - 59 / 1850 - 123 ?, bought by Engel-
bert/Frankfurt, St ̈adelsches Kunstinstitut, Inv. 393 /Corpus
Twoofthese drawings 1836 - 24 / 1838 - 9 and 1836 - 26 / 1838 -
51 cannot be identified in William II’s posthumous sale of
The August 1838 Purchase
Following this purchase of February 1838 ,William II
returned to Woodburn in August of the same year and
bought an additional forty drawings by various artists. Lists
of these are not available, but Woodburn’s account of this
transaction, as published by Hinterding and Horsch ( 1989 ),
does specify that one very important drawing by Michelan-
gelo was included among them: this is “the Large Cartoon
M. Angelo,” theEpifaniacartoon ( 1836 - 30 ), which appearedin William’s sale in 1850 as lot 212 .Itislikely that William
bought further drawings by or attributed to Michelangelo
on this occasion, although none of the remaining draw-
ings exhibited in 1836 wereamong them. Ten further draw-
ings by or after Michelangelo in William’s sale cannot
be connected with the 1836 exhibition. What may have
been two of the most important of these were 1850 - 15 0,
1850 - 153.The Sale to Oxford University
At the end of 1838 therefore forty of the one hundred draw-
ings included in the 1836 catalogue remained in Woodburn’s
hands: of these one, theRepose( 1836 - 11 )must have been
sold to an unidentified client between 1838 and184 2,leaving
thirty-nine: 1836 - 1 , 1836 - 2 , 1836 - 4 , 1836 - 5 , 1836 - 6 , 1836 - 7 ,
1836 - 8 , 1836 - 9 , 1836 - 10 , 1836 - 14 , 1836 - 16 , 1836 - 17 , 1836 - 21 ,
1836 - 23 , 1836 - 31 , 1836 - 32 , 1836 - 33 , 1836 - 41 , 1836 - 45 , 1836 -
46 , 1836 - 47 , 1836 - 49 , 1836 - 50 , 1836 - 52 , 1836 - 53 , 1836 - 54 ,
1836 - 55 , 1836 - 67 , 1836 - 68 , 1836 - 71 , 1836 - 76 , 1836 - 80 , 1836 -
82 , 1836 - 89 , 1836 - 91 , 1836 - 92 , 1836 - 93 , 1836 - 96 , 1836 - 97.
All of these were in the group sold to Oxford.
However, Oxford actually received eight-seven plus one,
that is eighty-eight mountings (several of which bore more
than one drawing) of drawings attributed to Michelangelo.
The184 2prospectus in fact listed eighty-seven mountings,
butone must be added since two were given the same num-
ber, no. 28 ,tomake eighty-eight. Five of these eighty-eight
came from Jeremiah Harman’s collection and had never
formed part of Lawrence’s series. The remaining eighty-
three mountings of drawings given to Michelangelo there-
fore contained thirty-nine mountings that had been exhib-
ited in 1836 and forty-four that had been owned by Lawrence
buthad not been exhibited.D
Catalogue des Tableaux Anciens et Modernes de Diverses
Ecoles, Dessins et Statues formant la Galerie de feu Sa
Majest ́eGuillaume II, roi des Pays Bas, 12 – 20 August 1850Dessins- 1830 - 138 /Not exhibited in 1836 /August 1838 pur-
chase?/Untraced. - 1830 - 39 / 1836 - 15 / 1838 - 4 /Lawrence Gallery, 1853 ,pl. 17 /
Wellesley Sale,186 6,lot 2417 /Malcolm 56 /BM W 42.
1 02. 1830 - 19 / 1836 - 36 / 1838 - 17 /Lawrence Gallery, 1853 ,pl.
16 /186 0- 132 /Robinson/Malcolm 58 /BM W 2.
103.Reproduced by Ottley,Italian School,f.p. 33 / 1814 -
1768 / 1830 - 60 / 1836 - 84 / 1838 - 49 /186 0- 125 /E. Galichon, his
sale, May 1875 ,lot 16 /Malcolm 80 /BM W 60.
104.Probably 1830 - 65 / 1836 - 69 / 1838 - 38 /186 0- 127 /J. P.
Heseltine/ BM W 63.
1 05.Probably 1830 - 47 / 1836 - 27 / 1838 - 12 /186 0- 115 /Malcolm
73 /BM W 81.- 1830 - 67 / 1836 - 44 / 1839 - 24 /Weimar, Sachsen-Weimar
Collection/National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa. By Jacopo
Pontormo, c.15 4 0.See 1830 - 67 for further details. - 1830 - 55 / 1836 - 74 / 1838 - 42 /186 0- 134 /Malcolm 74 /BM
W 57. - 1830 - 23 i/Not exhibited in 1836 /part of August 1838
purchase?/186 0-15 2/Chantilly, Musee Cond ́ e; Lanfranc de ́
Panthou, 1995 ,no. 39. - 1830 - 111 / 1836 - 75 / 1838 - 43 /186 0- 143 /J. C. Robinson/
Malcolm 55 /BM W 87.