Poetry for Students Vol. 10

(Martin Jones) #1

214 Poetry for Students


The speaker recalls the idea of the boy’s entering
the world of adulthood when he calls him a “big
boy / Doing a man’s work, though a child at heart.”
The boy’s pleadings to his sister—his only spoken
words in the poem—reflect his age and create a
sense of the pathetic nature of his death. The reader
is moved, but the speaker seems cold: his reaction
to the boy’s plea is, “So. But the hand was gone
already.” This decidedly detached response re-
flects the speaker giving up his search for expla-
nations for the accident. All he can say is, “So”
(for the boy’s expression of terror needs no ex-
planation) and “But the hand was gone already.”
While the speaker earlier dwelled on the possibil-
ity of personification, he has now retreated into the
world of facts. There is, ultimately, nothing to say
about the boy’s death other than the facts that led
up to it.

Lines 28-32:
These lines describe the doctor’s attempts at
saving the boy and the boy’s final breaths. The
“dark of ether” into which the doctor guides the
boy is like the underworld to which many mytho-
logical heroes journey—another of the poem’s
ironies. When told that the boy “puffed out his lips
with his breath,” the reader is invited to contrast
this image with the earlier one of the boy running
and yelling to his sister. Like all living things, he
has moved from a world of noisy action to one of
quiet stillness. Like the earlier statement, “But the

hand was gone already,” the description of the
boy’s final moments is shocking because of the de-
tached tone in which it is described: “Little—less—
nothing!—and that ended it.”

Lines 33-34:
The final lines reflect the speaker’s turning
wholly toward an attitude of detachment and seem-
ing indifference. His final remark of how both the
doctor and the family “turned to their affairs” seems
callous and almost offensive (especially with he
word “affairs,” implying that they all began riffling
through their social calendars)—but one must keep
in mind that the language here is more figurative
than literal. Eventuallythey “turned to their af-
fairs,” since there is simply nothing else for them
to do. Since there is “No more to build on there”
and “they / Were not the one dead,” the adults must
continue their lives, bereft of both the boy and any
solid explanation for why he had to die such a ter-
rible death.

Themes


Childhood versus Adulthood
“Out, Out—” concerns a boy who loses his
hand—and then his life—in an accident involving
a buzz saw with which he is working on a rural
Vermont farm. The boy is initially portrayed as a
“big boy / Doing a man’s work.” He is using the
buzz saw in an attempt to behave in a grown-up
way, as children will often become their parents’
“little helpers” in an attempt to assert their inde-
pendence and maturity. (This is what his sister is
doing by wearing an apron and announcing “Sup-
per” as if she is the matriarch of the family.) The
fact that he is cutting wood with a buzz saw—truly
a dangerous and “adult” piece of machinery—at-
tests to his desire to be a “big boy,” helping with
the chores. Despite that fact, the boy would be
pleased with having been given “the half hour /
That a boy counts so much when saved from work,”
he continues sawing the wood for his family’s
stove, willingly contributing to the literal and fig-
urative warmth of his home.
However, once the accident occurs, the boy be-
gins figuratively “Doing a man’s work” by dying
like a man. In the second it takes the saw to “leap”
at his hand, the boy enters an adulthood marked by
violence, fear, and death. Although the boy wanted
to behave like a “big boy,” once the accident oc-
curs, he betrays his age by crying like a terrified
child:

Out, Out—

Media


Adaptations



  • A double audiocassette set titled Robert Frost
    Readswas released in 1997 by HarperCollins
    Publishers.

  • Another audio edition of Frost reading his work
    is The Robert Frost Poetry Collection,released
    in 2000 by Harper Audio.

  • The Poetry of Robert Frostis an audiocassette
    featuring poems read by Carl Reiner and Susan
    Anspach. It was released in 1996 by Dove
    Audio.

Free download pdf