Telling the Evolutionary Time: Molecular Clocks and the Fossil Record

ANGIOSPERM DIVERGENCE 153

Th

e f

os

sil

• b

as
ed

es

tim

ates

a
re

, c

ont

ra
ry

to t

hei

r us

e,
a
ss
um

ed to p

rov

id
e a

m

ini

m
um

a
ge

fo

r^
th

e s

pli

t b

etw

ee

n th

e t

axo

n i

n q

ue

st
ion a

nd i

ts s

ist

er g

rou

p.

Co

lum

n^1

li

sts

t

he ta

xa

a

cc

ordi

ng

t

o th

eir u

sa

ge

, a

nd c

olum

ns

2–

5 li

st our a

ge

es

tim

ates

(

no

de nu

m

bers

c

orres

pon

d to t

ho

se

on t

he

c

hro

nog

ra

m

s,

Fig

ures

8.3

-^8

.6)

. T

he

a

ge s

pa

n g

iv

en

in

c

ol

um

n 2 r

es

ults

fr

om

th

e th

ree

c

ons

ec

uti

ve

an

aly

se

s u

sin

g A

CC

TR

A

N

an

d D

EL

TR

AN

opt

im

iza

tio

n a

nd m

axi

m

um

lik

eli

ho

od f

or

ca

lc

ul

ati

ng

b

ra

nc

h^

le

ng

th

s.^

Th

e^

sp

ec

ifi

c a

ges

, r

es

ulti

ng

fr

om

e

ac

h a

na

ly

sis

a

re

re

port

ed i

n c

olum

ns

3–

5. C

ol

um

n^

6 i

ndi

ca

tes

t

he

b

oots

tra

p

es

tim

at

es

of

sta

nd

ard

error

, a

nd c

ol

um

ns

7–

8 li

st

fo

ss

il-

ba

se

d es

tim

ates

ext

ra

ct

ed f

rom

M

ag

all

ón

et^

al

. (

1 999)

an

d M

ag

allón

an

d S

ande

rs

on (

2001

).

Th

e s

pec

ifi

c

fo

ssi

l-

ba

se

d a

ge

(c

ol

um

n 7)

c

orre

sp

onds

to th

at g

ive

n b

y M

ag

alló

n

et^

al.

(^1999

) a

nd M

ag

alló

n a

nd

S

ander

son

(^2

0 01)

a

nd

a

lso

in

di

ca

te

s on w

ha

t ta

xon t

he

ag

e

es

tim

at

e w

as

b

as

ed.

C

ol

um

n^8

lis

ts i

ns

ta

nc

es

w

hen

th

e t

opol

og

y i

m

pl

ie

s th

at s

om

e^

oth

er

fo

ss

il p

rov

id

es

a b

et

ter

m

ini

m

um

ag

e es

tim

ate f

or

a^ nod

e. I

n a

ddi

tio

n,

fu

rt

he

r

co

m

pa

ris

on

s^

ar

e m

ade w

he

nev

er

th

e f

os

sil

• b

as

ed

es

tim

at

e w

as

b

as

ed on

a

le

ss

in

clus

iv

e ta

xon.

T

he

ag

e

fo

r th

e

Ar

istolo

ch

iace

ae

• L

act

or

id

ace

ae

cl

ad

e,

fo

r exa

m

pl

e,

w

as

b

as

ed o

n L

ac

tori

da

ce

ae

pol

len

(

Za

va

da

1987

).

W

e h

av

e^

th

ere

fo

re

in

clud

ed

co

m

pa

ri

so

ns

w

ith

b

oth

t

he A

ri

sto

loc

hi

ac

eae

-L

ac

to

rid

ac

eae

a

nd

La

ct

or

id

ac

ea

e cl

ad

es

.

a T

he f

os

sil

• b

as

ed a

ge

co

nc

erns

th

e s

tem

• g

rou

p a

nd not

th

e c

row

n-

gr

oup a

s f

or

rem

aini

ng

ta

xa

(M

ag

all

ón a

nd S

an

ders

on 2

001)

.

b W

e^

ar

e u

na

bl

e^

to

c

om

pa

re

th

e f

os

sil

• b

as

ed

e

sti

m

ate

fo

r^ th

e l

es

s i

nc

lu

siv

e

ta

xo

n^

w

ith

a

m

ol

ec

ul

ar

es

tim

ate

si

nc

e

th

e t

axo

n w

as

not

in

cl

ude

d i

n th

e m

ole

cu

la

r

da

ta

se

t.

c M

ag

al

lón

et^

al.

(

199

9)

ind

ica

te

d a

n

Ap

tia

n (

124

.5–

11

2 M

a)

oc

curr

enc

e^

for

Po

pu

lu

s p

oto

ma

ce

ns

is,

b

ut

th

e or

ig

in

al^

doc

um

enta

tio

n of

th

is ta

xon

in

di

ca

te

d

th

e

Al

bi

an

(^1

12

• 97 M

a; D

oy

le

an

d H

ic

key

1976

).