IFR Magazine – January 20, 2018

For daily news stories

@ visit http://www.ifre.com

Apollo falls short 08 Stronger pound prompts M&A loan spree 10 China bank tackles Aussie LBO 11

SoftBank mulls

mega telecoms float

„ Equities IPO could be biggest in Japan in nearly two decades

BY FIONA LAU

'LOBALûEQUITYûCAPITALûMARKETSû

BANKERSûAREûCIRCLINGûONEûOFûTHEû

BIGGESTû*APANESEûLISTINGSûONû

RECORDûAFTERûCONGLOMERATEû

SOFTBANK GROUPûSAIDûITûWASû

CONSIDERINGûLISTINGûITSûLOCALû

TELECOMSûBUSINESS

!CCORDINGûTOû*APANESEûBUSINESSû

DAILYû.IKKEIûSOFTBANK CORP, the

GROUPSûMOBILEûPHONEûUNITûPLANSû

TOûLISTûINû4OKYOûANDûOVERSEASû

POSSIBLYû,ONDONûINûTHEûSECONDûHALFû

OFûTHEûYEARûINûAûDEALûTHATûCOULDûRAISEû

ASûMUCHûASûcTRNû53BN   

3OFT"ANKû'ROUPûSAIDûINûAû

STATEMENTûTHATûAûLISTINGûOFûITSû

MOBILEûPHONEûSUBSIDIARYûWASûONEû

OPTIONûFORûITSûCAPITALûSTRATEGYûBUTû

MADEûCLEARûTHATûNOûSUCHûDECISIONû

HADûBEENûMADE

!ûLISTINGûWILLûALLOWû3OFT"ANKû

'ROUPûTOûACCELERATEûITSû

transformation into one of the

WORLDSûBIGGESTûTECHûINVESTORSû

WITHOUTûFURTHERûRAISINGûITSûALREADYû

HIGHûDEBTûLEVELS

4HEûPOSSIBILITYûOFûSPINNINGûOFFû

3OFT"ANKû#ORPûHADûBEENûDISCUSSEDû

WITHINûTHEûCOMPANYûINûTHEûPASTû

FEWûYEARSûPEOPLEûFAMILIARûWITHû

THEûSITUATIONûTOLDû)&2

h4HEREûHAVEûBEENûONûANDûOFFû

DISCUSSIONSûFORûSOMEûYEARSûBUTû

these are getting more serious

LATELYû!SûFARûASûWEûKNOWûTHEYû

HAVENTûFORMALLYûAPPOINTEDûBANKSû

ONûTHEûDEALûYETvûSAIDûONEûOFûTHEû

PEOPLE

h&ORûAûDEALûOFûSUCHûSIZEûWEû

BELIEVEûTHEYûWILLûHAVEûTOûHIREûAû

COMBINATIONûOFûDOMESTICûANDû

INTERNATIONALûBANKSvûSAIDûANOTHERû

PERSON

!ûcTRNû)0/ûWOULDûBEûONEûOFû

*APANSûBIGGESTûRIVALLINGû.44û

$O#O-OSûcTRNûLISTINGûINûû

)TûCOULDûALSOûBEûTHEûBIGGESTû)0/ûINû

!SIA

0ACIlCûTHISûYEARûCHALLENGINGû

THEûPOTENTIALûmOATûOFû#HINESEû

smartphone maker Xiaomi,

WHICHûISûEXPECTEDûTOûVALUEûTHEû

COMPANYûATûUPûTOû53BN

LOGICAL MOVE

Market participants reckon it is a

LOGICALûMOVEûFORûTHEûCOMPANYûTOû

SPINûOFFûTHEûMOBILEûUNIT

h)NVESTORSûALWAYSûASKûFORûAû

VALUATIONûDISCOUNTûINûCONGLOMERATESû

ASûTHEYûDONTûHAVEûDIRECTûCONTROLû

OVERûANYûOFûITSûBUSINESSESû3PINNINGû

OFFûTHEûTELECOMSûBUSINESSûWILLûHELPû

3OFT"ANKûREALISEûTHEûVALUEûOFûITSû

INVESTMENTûBUSINESSûWHICHûISûAûCOREû

DEVELOPMENTûFORûTHEûGROUPûINûTHEû

PASTûFEWûYEARSvûSAIDûAûFUNDûMANAGER

4HEûLONGûLINEûOFûNEWû

INVESTMENTSûHASûMADEûVALUINGû

3OFT"ANKûDIFlCULT

For instance, SoftBank owns a

ûSTAKEûINû#HINESEû

E

COMMERCEûGIANTû!LIBABAû

ACCORDINGûTOû4HOMSONû2EUTERSûDATAû

!SûOFû*ANUARYûûTHEûSTAKEûWASû

WORTHû53BNûFARûMOREûTHANûTHEû

53BNûMARKETûCAPûOFû3OFT"ANK

4HEû53BNû6ISIONû&UNDûTHATû

SoftBank set up with others to

INVESTûINûTECHûCOMPANIESûMAKESû

VALUINGûTHEûCONGLOMERATEûEVENû

HARDERûASûTHEREûISûLITTLEûPUBLICû

INFORMATIONûONûTHEûFUNDSû

INVESTMENTSû!ûRESEARCHûREPORTû

FROMû'OLDMANû3ACHSûFORûEXAMPLEû

GAVEûAû

MONTHûTARGETûPRICEûOFû

cûTOû3OFT"ANKûAFTERûASSIGNINGû

ZEROûVALUEûTOûTHEû6ISIONû&UND

3HARESûOFû3OFT"ANKûCLOSEDûATû

cûONû&RIDAY

4HEûOTHERûADVANTAGEûOFûAû

POTENTIALûSPIN

OFFûISûTHATûTHEûFUNDSû

RAISEDûCANûBEûUSEDûTOûSUPPORTû

3OFT"ANKSûFUTUREûINVESTMENTSûINû

TECHûCOMPANIESûWITHOUTûADDINGûTOû

ITSûlNANCIALûLEVERAGE

4HEû.IKKEIûREPORTûSAIDû3OFT"ANKû

PLANNEDûTOûSELLûABOUTûûOFûITSû

MOBILEûUNITûTOûINVESTORSûANDûTHEû

FUNDSûWEREûLIKELYûTOûBEûUSEDûFORû

INVESTMENTûINûOVERSEASû)4û

COMPANIESûRATHERûTHANûPAYINGû

DOWNûDEBT

!CCORDINGûTOûTHEû'OLDMANû

REPORTû3OFT"ANKSûNETûDEBT

TO

%BITDAûRATIOûWASûATûûFORûTHEû

lNANCIALûQUARTERûENDEDû

3EPTEMBERû (^) „
FROMûAûWEAKûûANDûRANKINGûITû
THIRDûBEHINDû-ORGANû3TANLEYû
ANDû0û-ORGAN
4HEûUNDERWRITINGûPERFORMANCEû
HELPEDûPOWERû'OLDMANûTOûITSû
SECONDûBESTûYEARûINûINVESTMENTû
BANKINGûSINCEûITSû)0/ûINûû4HEû
DIVISIONûBROUGHTûINû53BNûINû
REVENUESûUPûûONûTHEûYEARûASû
-!ûADVISORYûFEESûROSEûûTOû
53BN
4HEûBANKSûTROUBLESûINû&)##û
CONTINUEûTOûWORRYûINVESTORSû
HOWEVERûANDûREVENUESûINûTHEû
BUSINESSûFELLûûONûTHEûYEARûTOû
53BN
4HEûBRIGHTûSPOTûMAYûBEûTHATûITû
SHOULDûNOTûBEûTOOûHARDûTOûDOû
BETTERûINûû!LREADYûBANKERSû
AREûSAYINGûTHEûlRSTûQUARTERûISû
LOOKINGûMOREûTRADITIONALûANDû
CLIENTSûAPPEARûTOûBEûRE
ENGAGING
h)TûWILLûGIVEûTHEMûBREATHINGû
ROOMûIFûTHEYûSTARTûRACKINGûUPûBIGû
NUMBERSûTHISûYEARvûSAIDû$ICKû
"OVEûAûBANKûANALYSTûATûTHEû6ERTICALû
'ROUPûh%VERYONEûWILLûFORGETû
EVERYTHINGûTHATSûHAPPENEDûANDû
SAYû@'OLDMANûISûBACKûBUTû)ûDONTû
THINKûTHEYûWILLûFORGETûINTERNALLYvû
HEûSAID
"OVEûSAIDû'OLDMANûBIGWIGSû
AREûPANICKEDûATûHOWûLONGûITûISû
TAKINGûTOûGETûTHEûBANKûBACKûONû
TRACK
In the fourth quarter, as with
THEûPRIORûTHREEûQUARTERSû'OLDMANû
BLAMEDûWEAKûCOMMODITYûMARKETSû
FORûITSû&)##ûDECLINEû'OLDMANûISû
MOREûINVOLVEDûINûCOMMODITIESû
TRADINGûTHANûITSûRIVALSûANDûBLAMEDû
THATûEXPOSUREûFORûITSûPERFORMANCEû
WHICHûWASûSIGNIlCANTLYûWEAKERû
THANûITSûPEERS
&)##ûREVENUESûACROSSûTHEûBIGû
lVEûBANKSûINûTHEûFOURTHûQUARTERû
WEREûDOWNûûONûAVERAGEûANDû
THEûBIGGESTûDECLINEûAFTERû
'OLDMANSûûDROPûWASûAûû
FALLûATû0û-ORGAN (^) „
WANTING CONSENT
(OVNANIANûSAIDûITûHADûWONû
CONSENTûFROMûBONDHOLDERSûTOû
AMENDûCOVENANTSûONûSOMEûOFûITSû
EXISTINGûSECUREDûBONDSûTHATû
LIMITûITSûABILITYûTOûUSEûCASHûTOû
BUYûBACKûTHEûUNSECUREDûS
!ûMAJORITYûOFûTHEûûSû
HOLDERSûAGREEDûTOûDOûAWAYûWITHû
THEûRESTRICTIONSûBUTûHOLDERSûOFû
THEûûSûHAVEûSOûFARûBEENû
MOREûRETICENT
(OVNANIANûTHUSûSWEETENEDû
THEûTERMSûANDûEXTENDEDûTHEû
DEADLINEûTHOUGHûONEûSOURCEû
FAMILIARûWITHûTHEûMATTERûSAIDû
THEûCONSENTSûWEREûNOTûACTUALLYû
NECESSARY
7HILEûTHEûCOMPANYûWOULDû
BENElTûFROMûREMOVINGûTHEû
COVENANTSûTHEûDEBTûSWAPûCOULDû
STILLûGOûTHROUGHûASûITSûTERMSû
ALREADYûCOMPLYûWITHûALLûEXISTINGû
COVENANTSûTHEûSOURCEûSAID
4HEûNEXTûCOURTûHEARINGûINûTHEû
CASEûCOMESûONû*ANUARYû
"UTûWHATEVERûTHEûULTIMATEû
OUTCOMEûSOMEûFEARûTHISûISûALLûAû
step too far for a CDS market
WHOSEû53TRNûOUTSTANDINGû
NETûNOTIONALûISûONLYûAûHALFûOFû
WHATûITûWASûONLYûAûFEWûYEARSûAGO
h)ûHAVEûLOSTûAûTONûOFû
CONlDENCEûINûTHEûMARKETûANDûINû
#$3vûONEûVETERANû53
BASEDû
PORTFOLIOûMANAGERûTOLDû)&2ûh)TûISû
OUTRIGHTûMANIPULATIONv
$ERIVATIVESûPROFESSIONALSû
ACKNOWLEDGEûTHATûTHEûLATESTû
ANDûPERHAPSûMOSTûBLATANTû
EXAMPLEûOFûAûhMANUFACTUREDvû
DEFAULTûINûANûATTEMPTûTOûTRIGGERû
#$3ûnûRATHERûTHANûBECAUSEûAû
COMPANYûHADûGENUINELYû
DEFAULTEDûnûWOULDûASûONEûPUTû
ITûhSTARTûAûCONVERSATIONvûABOUTû
WHETHERûANDûHOWûTOûCHANGEû
THEûRULESûTOûELIMINATEûSUCHû
TACTICS
)TûISûCLEARûTHOUGHûTHATûDOINGû
SOûWILLûBEûTRICKYû)NTRODUCINGûANû
EFFORTûTOûDETERMINEûWHETHERûAû
DEFAULTûWASûhINTENTIONALvûFORû
INSTANCEûWOULDûREQUIREû)3$!Sû
Determinations Committee,
WHICHûDECIDESûWHETHERû#$3û
CREDITûEVENTSûHAVEûTAKENûPLACEû
TOûJUDGEûMOTIVEûSOMETHINGûITûISû
ILL
EQUIPPEDûTOûDO
h)ûDONTûSEEûANYONEûDOINGû
ANYTHINGûPROACTIVELYûABOUTûITû
)TûWILLûDEPENDûONûHOWûTHEû
MARKETûREACTSû!DDRESSINGûITû
through a change in the [ISDA]
DElNITIONSûTAKESûAûVERYûLONGû
TIMEûBECAUSEûTHEREûAREûSOû
MANYûINTERESTEDûPARTIESvûSAIDû
0OWERS (^) „